Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S5M-04919 · Session 5

Censure and Apology on the Anniversary of the Chinese Agreement

Carried Lodged by Willie Rennie LD Lodged 27 Mar 2017 Debate 29 Mar 2017

The motion

That the Parliament notes that 21 March 2017 marked one year since the First Minister signed a memorandum of understanding with the Chinese companies, SinoFortone and China Railway No.3 Engineering Group; notes that extensive parliamentary questioning has revealed that Scottish ministers did not undertake basic checks on the companies prior to signing; further notes that China Railway Group was blacklisted by the Norwegian state pension fund and condemned by Amnesty International, and SinoFortone has been exposed as having no serious investment record; censures the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work for failing to exercise basic diligence initially and then subsequently criticising opposition MSPs for raising basic questions; calls on the Scottish Government to apologise and take steps to alert public bodies in the UK that they may have gained false assurance about the financial credibility of SinoFortone from the First Minister’s signature on the memorandum of understanding one year ago, and further calls for the working practices of the department and the sign-off protocols of the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work to be revised to make sure that basic checks on the human rights record and financial underpinning of potential investors are made at an earlier stage.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

The Liberal Democrats’ motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S5M-04919.2) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament notes that 21 March 2017 marked one year since the First Minister signed a memorandum of understanding with the Chinese companies, SinoFortone and China Railway No.3 Engineering Group;
171 words removed by S5M-04919.2notes that extensive parliamentary questioning has revealed that Scottish ministers did not undertake basic checks on the companies prior to signing; further notes that China Railway Group was blacklisted by the Norwegian state pension fund and condemned by Amnesty International, and SinoFortone has been exposed as having no serious investment record; censures the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work for failing to exercise basic diligence initially and then subsequently criticising opposition MSPs for raising basic questions; calls on the Scottish Government to apologise and take steps to alert public bodies in the UK that they may have gained false assurance about the financial credibility of SinoFortone from the First Minister’s signature on the memorandum of understanding one year ago, and further calls for the working practices of the department and the sign-off protocols of the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work to be revised to make sure that basic checks on the human rights record and financial underpinning of potential investors are made at an earlier stage.
S5M-04919.2 SNP recognises that Scotland has a strong track record in attracting investment as evidenced by the fact that Scotland has ranked as the best place for inward investment outside London for five of the last six years; further recognises that the memorandum of understanding (MoU) was about developing a working relationship to explore potential investment and that no legal, contractual or funding obligations on behalf of the Scottish Government have been made and there has been no engagement with the company since September 2016; notes with concern the human rights record of China Railway No.3 Engineering Group’s parent company, China Railway Group; regrets that the signing of the MoU gave rise to concerns, and commits to considering and taking account of these concerns in any future such situations; agrees that the Scottish Government must always consider the human rights implications of its engagement with countries and business; believes that investment agreements should only be signed where appropriate due diligence, including on the human rights record of companies involved, has been undertaken; welcomes Scottish Government engagement with Amnesty International and other organisations on human rights ahead of international engagements, and believes that, with appropriate care, it is possible for international trade to co-exist with support for human rights around the world.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S5M-04919.2 SNP Keith Brown Agreed vote, 63–55
  2. S5M-04919.1 Conservative Dean Lockhart Fell per the Official Report
  3. S5M-04919.3 Labour Jackie Baillie Defeated vote, 58–63

Vote

1 division
  1. 29 Mar 2017
    Carried
    64 for, 54 against, 3 abstained

Amendments

3
  1. No recorded vote
  2. Carried
    63 for, 55 against
  3. Defeated
    58 for, 63 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this motion.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S5M-04919
  1. 29 Mar 2017
    SinoFortone and China Railway No 3 Engineering Group Memorandum of Understanding
    Christine Grahame SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S5M-04919, in the name of Willie Rennie, on censure and apology on the anniversary of the Chinese agreement. 15:52

  2. 29 Mar 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The third question involves a pre-emption. If the amendment in the name of Keith Brown is agreed to, the amendment in the name of Dean Lockhart will fall. The question is, that amendment S5M-04919.2, in the name of Keith Brown, which seeks…

  3. 29 Mar 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The amendment in the name of Dean Lockhart is pre-empted. The next question is, that amendment S5M-04919.3, in the name of Jackie Baillie, which seeks to amend motion S5M-04919, in the name of Willie Rennie, as amended, be agreed to. Are w…

  4. 29 Mar 2017
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S5M-04919, in the name of Willie Rennie, on censure and apology on the anniversary of the Chinese agreement, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.