Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Amendment · S5M-03063.4 · Session 5

Taxation

Defeated Lodged by Patrick Harvie Green Lodged 13 Dec 2016 Debate 14 Dec 2016

Amendment to S5M-03063 Taxation

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S5M-03063 in the name of Murdo Fraser (Taxation), leave out from “not” to end and insert "have access to high-quality public services; notes that the SNP’s manifesto proposals on tax make no significant changes to current income tax rates and thresholds; supports a tax system that will challenge inequalities in wealth and income; agrees that people earning below the median should pay less, while high earners should pay more than at present, and supports a long-term tax shift from income to wealth, where inequalities are greater."

Vote

1 division
  1. 14 Dec 2016
    Taxation
    S5M-03063.4
    Defeated
    6 for, 115 against

Other amendments

3
  1. Taxation
    Kezia Dugdale Lab Lodged 13 Dec 2016
    Defeated
    29 for, 91 against
  2. Taxation
    Willie Rennie LD Lodged 13 Dec 2016
    Defeated
    27 for, 88 against
  3. Taxation
    Derek Mackay SNP Lodged 13 Dec 2016
    Defeated
    60 for, 61 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this amendment.

In the Official Report

3 contributions mention S5M-03063.4
  1. 14 Dec 2016
    Taxation
    Linda Fabiani SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    I remind people that we are so tight for time that, if anyone goes over time, the amount that they go over will come off the speaking time of other speakers from their party. Time is very tight. Patrick Harvie, you have no more than 7 minu…

  2. 14 Dec 2016
    Taxation
    Patrick Harvie Green Meeting of the Parliament

    I absolutely welcome the fact that we are finally able to have this debate, but if we take the logic that the Conservatives have to offer, through the laughable Laffer curve and all the arguments that we have heard from Murdo Fraser about …

  3. 14 Dec 2016
    Decision Time
    Ken Macintosh Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that amendment S5M-03063.4, in the name of Patrick Harvie, which seeks to amend motion S5M-03063, in the name of Murdo Fraser, on taxation, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.