Amendment · S4M-13248.1 · Session 4
Sewage Sludge Spreading
Amendment to S4M-13248 Sewage Sludge Spreading
The amendment
As an amendment to motion S4M-13248 in the name of Margaret Mitchell (Sewage Sludge Spreading), leave out from first "understands" to end and insert "understands that Scottish Water has improved procedures for sewage disposal and is now only transporting dried sewage pellets to Falkirk district, which are treated before arriving for disposal in the Falkirk area; understands that the majority of waste material disposed of is food waste not sewage and that gas created by anaerobic respiration during the decompression of this organic material causes an unpleasant smell; however understands that regulatory bodies have stated that this smell is not a public health issue and that soil samples of the farmland where the material is spread indicated no public health issues; understands that over 1,300 members of the community have submitted letters of objection regarding the practice to Falkirk Council; notes that community councils in the Falkirk area have lodged a petition with the Public Petitions Committee regarding sewage sludge spreading; understands that the spreading of human sewage on fields prevented residents from opening windows, hanging out laundry or sitting outside during the summer months; further understands that, before procedural improvements by Scottish Water, sludge was spilt onto roads in 2013 during transportation and a local primary school sports day had to be cancelled due to the stench from the sludge making children vomit; acknowledges that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA), Scottish Water, Falkirk Council and the Scottish Government are responsible for oversight of the various stages of sewage sludge treatment, transportation and spreading and that the Scottish Government is currently conducting a review of waste spreading in Scotland; notes that, given that the spreading of sewage sludge on farmland is the result of an EU directive banning the dumping of sewage at sea, Ian Hudghton MEP has lodged a question with the European Parliament about the disposal of sewage, referring in particular to rural Falkirk district, including Slamannan, and notes the view that there is merit in exploring alternative ways of treating human sewage, including increasing capacity for incineration as is the norm in other northern European countries, as well as ensuring that the current practice is meticulously monitored so that local communities are not adversely affected, and looks forward to the outcome of the Scottish Government’s formal review of the legislation and guidance in relation to sewage sludge, due to be released later in the summer."
Vote
No recorded vote on this amendment. Most motions are never debated, and many that are debated are agreed without a division. Vote records are published from 2011.
Supporters
14 MSPsSNP 12 Ind 1 Lab 1
Show all 14 supporters by party
SNP 12
- Colin Beattie
- Roderick Campbell
- Graeme Dey
- Rob Gibson
- Adam Ingram
- Richard Lyle
- Mike MacKenzie
- Joan McAlpine
- Gil Paterson
- Kevin Stewart
- Dave Thompson
- David Torrance
Ind 1
Lab 1
Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4M-13248.1 by reference.