Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S4M-12591 · Session 4

Supporting Scotland's Economy

Carried Lodged by Jackie Baillie Lab Lodged 9 Mar 2015 Debate 11 Mar 2015

The motion

That the Parliament believes that full fiscal autonomy within the UK would have an immediate and detrimental impact on Scotland's economy, particularly in light of this week's Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report; recognises that it would mean that Scotland would lose out on billions of pounds for public services, such as the NHS and schools, through the consequent scrapping of the Barnett formula; further believes that this would cut Scotland off from sharing in the wealth and resources of the UK, and calls on the Scottish Government to affirm that it would be better to retain the Barnett bonus than to have full fiscal autonomy within the UK.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

Labour’s motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S4M-12591.3) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament believes
105 words removed by S4M-12591.3that full fiscal autonomy within the UK would have an immediate and detrimental impact on Scotland's economy, particularly in light of this week's Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland report; recognises that it would mean that Scotland would lose out on billions of pounds for public services, such as the NHS and schools, through the consequent scrapping of the Barnett formula; further believes that this would cut Scotland off from sharing in the wealth and resources of the UK, and calls on the Scottish Government to affirm that it would be better to retain the Barnett bonus than to have full fiscal autonomy within the UK.
S4M-12591.3 SNP Scotland should have the powers that it needs to create a jobs-rich, more equal and more locally-based economy; further believes that this is key to reducing inequality and promoting a sustainable future; agrees that the UK Government’s fiscal austerity programme is having a disproportionate impact on the poorest in society and will reduce public spending to its lowest level since the 1930s, and calls on the UK Government to end the unfair cuts to public spending and invest to protect public services.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S4M-12591.3 SNP John Swinney Agreed vote, 62–55
  2. S4M-12591.1 Liberal Democrat Willie Rennie Fell per the Official Report
  3. S4M-12591.2 Conservative Gavin Brown Defeated vote, 54–61

Vote

1 division
  1. 11 Mar 2015
    Supporting Scotland's Economy
    S4M-12591as amended by SNP
    Carried
    62 for, 55 against

Amendments

3
  1. No recorded vote
  2. Defeated
    54 for, 61 against
  3. Carried
    62 for, 55 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this motion.

In the Official Report

5 contributions mention S4M-12591
  1. 11 Mar 2015
    Scotland’s Economy
    John Scott Con Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S4M-12591, in the name of Jackie Baillie, on supporting Scotland’s economy. 14:41

  2. 11 Mar 2015
    Scotland’s Economy
    Willie Rennie LD Meeting of the Parliament

    John Swinney is not disagreeing with my central claim; he is not backing up what Nicola Sturgeon said in London. The SNP wants to borrow more than Labour is planning to borrow. It is economically incredible that the SNP is proposing that. …

  3. 11 Mar 2015
    Decision Time
    Elaine Smith Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    There are seven questions to be put as a result of today’s business. I remind members that, in relation to the debate on supporting Scotland’s economy, if the amendment in the name of John Swinney is agreed to, the amendment in the name of…

  4. 11 Mar 2015
    Decision Time
    Elaine Smith Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    As that amendment was agreed to, the amendment in the name of Willie Rennie falls. The next question is, that amendment S4M-12591.2, in the name of Gavin Brown, which seeks to amend motion S4M-12591, in the name of Jackie Baillie, on suppo…

  5. 11 Mar 2015
    Decision Time
    Elaine Smith Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S4M-12591, in the name of Jackie Baillie, on supporting Scotland’s economy, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.