Amendment · S4M-08286.1 · Session 4
As an amendment to motion S4M-08286 in the name of Gil Paterson (Scottish Workers, Don’t be Feart), leave out from "condemns" to end and in…
Amendment to S4M-08286 Scottish Workers, Don’t be Feart
The amendment
As an amendment to motion S4M-08286 in the name of Gil Paterson (Scottish Workers, Don’t be Feart), leave out from "condemns" to end and insert "welcomes confirmation by BAE Systems that the Clyde is its preferred UK location for the construction of future Type 26 global combat ships; further welcomes that work on additional blocks for the aircraft carrier contract is being transferred to the Clyde from Portsmouth in order that workload in Scotland can be maintained; also welcomes that a new order for offshore patrol vessels has been promised to the Clyde under the terms of business agreement signed by the last Labour administration with BAE Systems, but notes that steel is not scheduled to be cut on this order until after the referendum on 18 September 2014; understands that job losses in the Clyde shipyards were not unexpected because the Clyde’s workforce had to be increased to cope with the increase in work on the Queen Elizabeth class and was likely to be reduced once the yard was configured for Type 26 orders but recognises that the impact of these will be substantial; considers that, just as in Portsmouth, every job loss is profoundly regrettable and each will be an individual tragedy for every family affected by them; understands that it is expected that substantial job reductions on the Clyde will be achieved by early retirement and similar measures; considers that BAE Systems and the Clyde yard trade unions have a long history of working collaboratively and welcomes the activity of both sides in seeking to achieve the best possible solution to these difficulties in the interests of the continuance of shipbuilding on the Clyde and the workforce as a whole; nevertheless, regrets that no firm order for the Type 26 has yet been placed; understands that the longstanding policy of the UK Government has been to retain sovereignty capability to construct complex warships in the UK and considers that it is perfectly clear that, if Scotland votes to leave the UK, the retention of this sovereign capacity will be impossible if Type 26 orders have been placed on the Clyde; expresses concern that SNP plans for a separate Scotland have not, to date, included any provision for immediate shipbuilding orders to fill the order book if the Type 26 order is placed elsewhere; understands that the Norwegian navy, which has been pointed to as an example by nationalists, has six frigates, all built in Spain, six submarines, all built in Germany, and has ordered a logistics ship, to be built in Korea; further understands that, of the 105 vessels built in Norway in 2012, 50% were under 30 metres long and none were the length of a Type 26; regrets what it considers the personalisation of the issues in relation to the future of the Clyde yards and hopes that all MSPs, including those who support a separate Scotland, will in future restrict their contributions to matters that might assist the workforce as restructuring takes place and that deal with the implications of separation on UK defence orders being placed in Scotland, and considers that the best way to ensure that UK defence orders are placed with the Clyde yards is for the Clyde and the rest of Scotland to remain in the UK."
Vote
No recorded vote on this amendment. Most motions are never debated, and many that are debated are agreed without a division. Vote records are published from 2011.
Supporters
10 MSPsLab 10
Show all 10 supporters by party
Lab 10
Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4M-08286.1 by reference.