Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Amendment · S4M-06766.4 · Session 4

Transforming Scotland's Railways

Defeated Lodged by Patrick Harvie Green Lodged 29 May 2013 Debate 30 May 2013 4 supporters

Amendment to S4M-06766 Transforming Scotland's Railways

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S4M-06766 in the name of Keith Brown (Transforming Scotland's Railways), leave out from first “acknowledges” to end and insert “recognises the constraints under which the ScotRail franchise must operate as a result of UK legislation, but considers that the Scottish Government could ensure greater transparency in its franchise decisions; believes that, when Scotland is able to remove the constraints of UK legislation, renationalisation of the railways or the use of a non-profit franchise holder would deliver better value for the public investment in Scotland’s railways; condemns the UK Government’s plans to reprivatise the profitable East Coast line, a decision that it understands was announced without reference to the Scottish Government; expresses concern that the Scottish Government’s road-building priorities risk making rail uncompetitive on price and journey times for routes north of the central belt, and believes that the public money currently committed to upgrading the A9 would be better spent on rail infrastructure, including the comparatively modest upgrades required to improve the Highland main line.”

Vote

1 division
  1. 30 May 2013
    Defeated
    4 for, 105 against

Other amendments

3
  1. Defeated
    11 for, 98 against
  2. Defeated
    38 for, 69 against
  3. Defeated
    49 for, 60 against

Supporters

4 MSPs

Ind 3 Green 1

Show all 4 supporters by party

Ind 3

Green 1

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

2 contributions mention S4M-06766.4
  1. 30 May 2013
    Scotland’s Railways
    Patrick Harvie Green Meeting of the Parliament

    I welcome the debate, and I see positive things to celebrate about the state of our railways, which is why the Green and independent amendment does not seek to delete the whole of the Government’s motion. However, we part company with the …

  2. 30 May 2013
    Decision Time
    Elaine Smith Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    The question is, that amendment S4M-06766.4, in the name of Patrick Harvie, which seeks to amend motion S4M-06766, in the name of Keith Brown, on transforming Scotland’s railways, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.