Standard Motion · S4M-06589 · Session 4
Scotland Favours an Effective Nuclear Deterrent
The motion
That the Parliament notes the results of a new poll on the support for nuclear weapons in Scotland commissioned by Lord Ashcroft; notes motion S4M-06547 in the name of Bill Kidd; understands that the poll showed that most Scots want a replacement for Trident when it comes to the end of its useful life and that more are in favour of the UK’s nuclear submarines continuing to be based in Scotland than are opposed; understands that the CND poll referred to in Bill Kidd’s motion, which found a large majority in favour of not buying new nuclear weapons, omitted to mention that the existing nuclear system is due to be decommissioned and considers therefore that its “decisive” results should be treated with caution due to its omission of a salient and relevant fact; believes that Lord Aschroft did not conduct the poll, as noted in motion S4M-06547, to “show that more than half of Scots are in favour of nuclear weapons”, but rather to find out Scots’ views on the subject; recognises that one of those findings was that 51% of Scots want a replacement for Trident, while only 34% would give up nuclear weapons completely; considers that it is hypocritical for an elected SNP politician to question the integrity of the poll on the grounds that Lord Ashcroft paid for it when the SNP has in the past relied on a number of his previous polls in support of its political position; understands that all of Lord Ashcroft’s polls are published in full, with no omitted details, and believes that this is a welcome development in understanding public opinion that can serve as a useful reality check for those astute enough to use it.
Vote
No recorded vote on this motion. Most motions are never debated, and many that are debated are agreed without a division. Vote records are published from 2011.
Supporters
No MSP has added their name to this motion.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4M-06589 by reference.