Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Standard Motion · S4M-04652 · Session 4

Forth Replacement Crossing a Welcome Departure from Labour’s Unfortunate PFI Legacy

Lodged by Kenneth Gibson SNP Lodged 31 Oct 2012 18 supporters

The motion

That the Parliament commends what it considers the diligent progress that has already been made with the Forth Replacement Crossing; understands that 1,100 people are directly employed by this project and that more than 300 Scottish companies are benefiting from contracts and subcontracts emanating from the development; recognises that the project is expected to be delivered on time for between £1.47 billion and £1.62 billion, which, it understands, is 30% to 36% less than the original estimate of £2.3 billion; believes that the money saved can now be invested in other infrastructure and building projects or in other vital areas of importance to the Scottish people, such as health, justice and education, at a time when the UK Government has cut Scotland’s block grant by over £3 billion; believes that the way this project has been financed represents a most welcome departure from what it considers the Labour Party’s previous reliance on the private finance initiative (PFI) funding mechanism while in government; considers that the problems associated with PFI are well exemplified by four schools in North Ayrshire with a capital value of £83 million between them, but which cost £400 million to build; notes that BBC Alba's Eorpa programme has suggested that some PFI contracts in Scotland will take more than a century to pay off; believes that this is hardly the legacy that Scotland should aspire to bequeath to future generations; finds it perplexing that Labour's shadow minister for transport was quoted by Holyrood magazine on 22 October 2012 as saying that the Forth Replacement Crossing was “sucking in a great deal of money”; notes that the shadow minister was further quoted as saying of the project “our position was that we supported that at the time. I have to say, personally, I do wonder whether we were right. I wonder whether there were other alternatives that could have been explored, which wouldn’t have been as expensive. Looking back, perhaps the Greens had a point. I sometimes think that the case for replacement was to a certain extent overblown”; believes that the shadow minister for transport’s subsequent comments at First Minister’s Question Time on 25 October 2012 did little or nothing to clarify whether she and her party still support the project; notes that Labour pledged on page 19 of its 2011 election manifesto to “deliver the new Forth Replacement Crossing” because it is “a vital project to safeguard an essential link in the country’s transport network and will be the largest infrastructure project in a generation”, and calls on the Labour shadow minister for transport, or Johann Lamont MSP, to clarify whether or not the Labour Party in Scotland still supports the Forth Replacement Crossing and all the benefits that it believes the project has already brought, not least in the way of jobs, as part of the open and honest debate that Ms Lamont has called for to take place in the Parliament.

Signatures by party

18 MSPs besides the lodger · 1 from other parties
SNP 17Ind 1

Party on the day each MSP signed. Signing a motion is voluntary and not whipped. Who signs whose motions

Vote

No recorded vote on this motion. Most motions are never debated, and many that are debated are agreed without a division. Vote records are published from 2011.

Supporters

18 MSPs

SNP 17 Ind 1

Show all 18 supporters by party

SNP 17

Ind 1

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

No contribution in the Official Report cites S4M-04652 by reference.