Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S4M-04594 · Session 4

The Future of Scotland

Carried Lodged by Johann Lamont Lab Lodged 29 Oct 2012 Debate 30 Oct 2012 1 supporter

The motion

That the Parliament notes with grave concern the confusion caused by the contradictory comments of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister as to whether or not legal advice had been sought regarding an independent Scotland's status in respect of EU membership; considers that clarification of the situation is still required and calls on the First Minister to make a full statement to the Parliament providing such clarification, and urges the Lord Advocate to inform the Parliament what advice he has provided to the Scottish Government, believing that the credibility of the First Minister and the Scottish Government are at stake and that nothing less than full disclosure is required.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

Labour’s motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S4M-04594.3) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament
107 words removed by S4M-04594.3notes with grave concern the confusion caused by the contradictory comments of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister as to whether or not legal advice had been sought regarding an independent Scotland's status in respect of EU membership; considers that clarification of the situation is still required and calls on the First Minister to make a full statement to the Parliament providing such clarification, and urges the Lord Advocate to inform the Parliament what advice he has provided to the Scottish Government, believing that the credibility of the First Minister and the Scottish Government are at stake and that nothing less than full disclosure is required.
S4M-04594.3 SNP welcomes the Edinburgh agreement, which provides the framework for Scotland to reach independence, and the commitment of the Scottish and United Kingdom governments to work together constructively in the light of the outcome of the referendum, whatever it is, in the best interests of the people of Scotland and of the rest of the UK; believes that an independent Scotland continuing in the European Union would be in the best interests of Scotland, the rest of the UK and the EU as a whole and that a Scotland rich in oil and other natural resources would be welcomed as a continuing member of the EU; notes that a range of international experts have made the case that an independent Scotland would continue in the EU and that, in light of the Edinburgh agreement, the Scottish Government has now commissioned specific legal advice on Scotland's position in the EU from the Law Officers; welcomes the independent investigation announced by the First Minister to determine whether there has been any breach of the Scottish Ministerial Code and calls on all parties in the Parliament to accept its findings, and regrets the Labour Party's unwillingness to use a debate entitled “The Future of Scotland” to address substantive policy issues on the future of Scotland such as the fact that, within the union, Trident nuclear weapons will remain on the Clyde and the damaging impact of UK Government welfare reforms that are impoverishing so many of Scotland's most vulnerable citizens, which are both compelling arguments for a different and independent future for Scotland.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S4M-04594.3 SNP Nicola Sturgeon Agreed vote, 62–51
  2. S4M-04594.1 Conservative Ruth Davidson Fell per the Official Report
  3. S4M-04594.2 Liberal Democrat Willie Rennie Defeated vote, 51–62

Signatures by party

1 MSP besides the lodger · 0 from other parties
Lab 1

Party on the day each MSP signed. Signing a motion is voluntary and not whipped. Who signs whose motions

Vote

1 division
  1. 30 Oct 2012
    The Future of Scotland
    S4M-04594as amended by SNP
    Carried
    62 for, 53 against, 1 abstained

Amendments

3
  1. The Future of Scotland
    Ruth Davidson Con Lodged 29 Oct 2012
    No recorded vote
  2. The Future of Scotland
    Willie Rennie LD Lodged 29 Oct 2012
    Defeated
    51 for, 62 against
  3. The Future of Scotland
    Nicola Sturgeon SNP Lodged 29 Oct 2012
    Carried
    62 for, 51 against

Supporters

1 MSP

Lab 1

Show all 1 supporter by party

Lab 1

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S4M-04594
  1. 30 Oct 2012
    The Future of Scotland
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S4M-04594, in the name of Johann Lamont, on the future of Scotland.14:18

  2. 30 Oct 2012
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    There are four questions to be put as a result of today’s business. I remind members that, in relation to today’s debate on the future of Scotland, if amendment S4M-04594.3, in the name of Nicola Sturgeon, is agreed to, amendment S4M-04594…

  3. 30 Oct 2012
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The amendment in the name of Ruth Davidson falls.The second question is, that amendment S4M-04594.2, in the name of Willie Rennie, which seeks to amend motion S4M-04594, in the name of Johann Lamont, on the future of Scotland, be agreed to…

  4. 30 Oct 2012
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The third question is, that motion S4M-04594, in the name of Johann Lamont, on the future of Scotland, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.