Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S4M-01878 · Session 4

Prison Visiting Committees

Carried Lodged by Annabel Goldie Con Lodged 31 Jan 2012 Debate 2 Feb 2012

The motion

That the Parliament notes with concern the Scottish Government's proposals to abolish prison visiting committees and replace them with a prisoner advocacy service; considers that the independent scrutiny of prison conditions through regular, unannounced inspections and the independent examination of prisoner complaints is an important check and balance for the prison system; believes that, as they provide regular external scrutiny, are appointed from the local community and are independent from the Scottish Prison Service, prison visiting committees provide a distinct but complementary role to Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons; notes that the Scottish Government's consultation on the independent monitoring of prisons, which was carried out in 2011, did not include proposals for an advocacy service to replace the committees and that 59 out of 60 respondents to the consultation wanted to retain the independent oversight role that it considers the committees fulfil; further notes that, in 2005, a review of the committees recommended that they be re-established as independent monitoring boards and that there should be changes to improve their impact and consistency; understands that, on 22 December 2011, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice said that the cost of running the committees was less than that anticipated for the proposed advocacy service, and believes that prison visiting committees offer excellent value for money, that they should be retained and that the proposed prisoner advocacy service should complement, but not replace, their role.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

The Conservatives’ motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S4M-01878.1) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament
229 words removed by S4M-01878.1notes with concern the Scottish Government's proposals to abolish prison visiting committees and replace them with a prisoner advocacy service; considers that the independent scrutiny of prison conditions through regular, unannounced inspections and the independent examination of prisoner complaints is an important check and balance for the prison system; believes that, as they provide regular external scrutiny, are appointed from the local community and are independent from the Scottish Prison Service, prison visiting committees provide a distinct but complementary role to Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons; notes that the Scottish Government's consultation on the independent monitoring of prisons, which was carried out in 2011, did not include proposals for an advocacy service to replace the committees and that 59 out of 60 respondents to the consultation wanted to retain the independent oversight role that it considers the committees fulfil; further notes that, in 2005, a review of the committees recommended that they be re-established as independent monitoring boards and that there should be changes to improve their impact and consistency; understands that, on 22 December 2011, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice said that the cost of running the committees was less than that anticipated for the proposed advocacy service, and believes that prison visiting committees offer excellent value for money, that they should be retained and that the proposed prisoner advocacy service should complement, but not replace, their role.
S4M-01878.1 SNP recognises the dedication and commitment of volunteer members of prison visiting committees but considers that, since the role and remit of the committees were designed in the 19th century, it is necessary now to develop an appropriate service fit for the 21st century; further notes that complaints by prisoners are now dealt with by the Scottish Prison Service (SPS) in line with best practice as set out by the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman’s Complaints Standards Authority; notes that, on monitoring, the chief executive of the SPS is accountable to the Scottish Ministers for compliance with legislation on the management and treatment of prisoners and that inspection of prisons is being delivered efficiently and effectively by HM Inspectorate of Prisons; further notes that research has identified that prisoners need a dedicated advocacy service that could provide them with independent advice and support; notes that the Scottish Government is considering how to build on the role performed presently by visiting committees by introducing a dedicated independent prisoner advocacy service to support prisoners in ways that match modern needs, and notes that the Scottish Government intends to carry out a further public consultation on these proposals in 2012 and will discuss the proposed timetable with stakeholders in developing the best way forward.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S4M-01878.1 SNP Kenny MacAskill Agreed vote, 63–52

Vote

1 division
  1. 2 Feb 2012
    Prison Visiting Committees
    S4M-01878as amended by SNP
    Carried
    62 for, 38 against, 14 abstained

Amendments

1
  1. Carried
    63 for, 52 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this motion.

In the Official Report

3 contributions mention S4M-01878
  1. 2 Feb 2012
    Prison Visiting Committees
    Elaine Smith Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S4M-01878, in the name of Annabel Goldie, on prison visiting committees. This debate is every bit as tight as the previous one, so I ask members to keep strictly to their times. 10:28

  2. 2 Feb 2012
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that amendment S4M-01878.1, in the name of Kenny MacAskill, which seeks to amend motion S4M-01878, in the name of Annabel Goldie, on prison visiting committees, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.

  3. 2 Feb 2012
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S4M-01878, in the name of Annabel Goldie, on prison visiting committees, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.