Written Question · S4W-18685 · Session 4
Which companies have been found liable under the Environmental Liability (Scotland) Regulations 2009 of causing (a) land damage, (b) water …
The question
To ask the Scottish Government which companies have been found liable under the Environmental Liability (Scotland) Regulations 2009 of causing (a) land damage, (b) water damage and (c) damage to protected (i) habitats and (ii) species, and what penalty was imposed.
The answer
The competent authorities under the Environmental Liability (Scotland) Regulations 2009 are SEPA, Scottish Natural Heritage and Marine Scotland.
SEPA has not to date received any notifications of “environmental damage” (as defined in the Regulations) from operators. SEPA has received two requests for action and review from interested persons. Both of these cases were found to be not plausible in accordance with regulation 14. SEPA has reported one case of “environmental damage” (land damage) to the European Commission. This involved the spillage of a large volume of fuel to ground following a collision between two road tankers. In respect of this incident, SEPA worked with the operator and the insurers to develop and implement a remedial strategy for the site.
On a further 15 occasions, SEPA has itself considered whether it had reasonable grounds to believe that environmental damage had occurred. SEPA did not find reasonable grounds to believe that environmental damage had occurred in any of these cases. This was either because the activity that caused the pollution did not fall within the scope of the Regulations or because the pollution did not meet the thresholds for environmental damage. SEPA is currently investigating one further case which involves the release of a large volume of fuel.
SNH issued notices of imminent threat of environmental damage to multiple operators in one case. The operators took action to prevent damage reaching the threshold of actual environmental damage. SEPA also took enforcement action (under other legislation) which led to two operators being prosecuted. Any other cases that have been identified as meeting, or threatening to meet, the threshold of environmental damage have been found to be exempt from the scope of the regulations.
Marine Scotland have not dealt with any cases.
SEPA has not to date received any notifications of “environmental damage” (as defined in the Regulations) from operators. SEPA has received two requests for action and review from interested persons. Both of these cases were found to be not plausible in accordance with regulation 14. SEPA has reported one case of “environmental damage” (land damage) to the European Commission. This involved the spillage of a large volume of fuel to ground following a collision between two road tankers. In respect of this incident, SEPA worked with the operator and the insurers to develop and implement a remedial strategy for the site.
On a further 15 occasions, SEPA has itself considered whether it had reasonable grounds to believe that environmental damage had occurred. SEPA did not find reasonable grounds to believe that environmental damage had occurred in any of these cases. This was either because the activity that caused the pollution did not fall within the scope of the Regulations or because the pollution did not meet the thresholds for environmental damage. SEPA is currently investigating one further case which involves the release of a large volume of fuel.
SNH issued notices of imminent threat of environmental damage to multiple operators in one case. The operators took action to prevent damage reaching the threshold of actual environmental damage. SEPA also took enforcement action (under other legislation) which led to two operators being prosecuted. Any other cases that have been identified as meeting, or threatening to meet, the threshold of environmental damage have been found to be exempt from the scope of the regulations.
Marine Scotland have not dealt with any cases.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S4W-18685 by reference.