To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2220)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Johann Lamont Lab 1
The record
12 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Figures this week show that 58 per cent of all murders that are committed in Scotland are committed with a knife; an all-time high. Next week, Labour will move an amendment to the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Bill that would ensure that, if someone is caught carrying a knife, they will go to jail. Will the Scottish National Party support us?
I am sure that Iain Gray would be the first to acknowledge that, while we all understand the seriousness of knife crime and homicide in Scotland, the figures that were released this week show the lowest level of homicide in Scotland for 10 years. That is not a satisfactory position and these are huge issues. Nonetheless, we should recognise the extent of that and put the figures into perspective. As Iain Gray also knows, the average sentence for knife crime in Scotland has increased under this Government from where the previous Government left it. There are substantial indications that significant progress is being made in the work that is being done on gangs and violence. We do not support his proposition of an automatic jail sentence for anyone who is caught carrying a knife.
The First Minister should also be aware that the figures that were released this week show that knife murders have increased over the past three years. He must know that the longer jail sentences for knife crime are down to the increase in the maximum jail sentence from two to four years, which was introduced by the previous Scottish Executive. The fact remains that the vast majority of convicted knife criminals do not go to jail. The First Minister should listen to knife crime campaigners such as John Muir. As the First Minister will be aware, Mr Muir’s son Damian was murdered in a knife attack. Mr Muir has said that if Labour’s policy had been in place, his son might well still be with us. Is the First Minister saying that Mr Muir is wrong?
I and every member of the Parliament have nothing but sympathy and respect for the victims of crime and their families. Once Iain Gray has had the opportunity to check his facts about the parliamentary process, I know that he will want to acknowledge that it was Stewart Maxwell who moved the amendment to increase the maximum sentence in the legislation to which he referred. That was an important amendment, which the Parliament carried. It means that 478 knife carriers have been prosecuted on indictment rather than on summary complaint, which has allowed greater sentencing power for the judge. Convictions have been made in more than three quarters of all concluded cases and 83 per cent of those convicted have been jailed. The average sentence for knife possession on indictment is 13 months and 24 days. The average prison sentence for possession of a knife increased from 161 days in 2006-07 to 217 days in 2007-08.
In another comparison with previous Administrations, Iain Gray will also want to acknowledge the change in violence reduction unit funding. In 1997, there was no funding for the violence reduction unit whereas there was in 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009, by which time support had doubled—under this SNP Government. There was no specific funding to focus on gang violence under the Tories or, indeed, the Labour-Liberal coalition, but this Government has authorised substantial funding.
When we deal with issues on which we share a joint and overwhelming concern—just as we share a joint and overwhelming concern for the affected families—it behoves us as a Parliament to recognise not only the seriousness of the situation but the initiatives that exist and the progress that is being made. That would be a better context in which to debate the issue.
This is about an overwhelming concern. Over recent months, I have helped to collect signatures on a petition in support of the Labour amendment that will be debated in committee next week and in support of knife campaigners such as Mr Muir. In my time, I have collected signatures on many petitions, but I have never had people queue up to sign a petition as happened with this one. Indeed, 30,000 Scots have signed the petition in support of Mr Muir and Labour’s amendment on knife crime. Does the First Minister not think that our absolute obligation to the victims of knife crime and those 30,000 Scots is to listen to them and stand up for them?
As a Parliament, we share an absolute obligation to address these issues. That is exactly what this Government has done. I have set out the progress that has been made on the issue in a detailed and factual way.
It is not enough.
I hear Johann Lamont say that it is not enough, but it is substantially more than was done by the previous Administration, in which she was a minister.
The difficulty that I have with politicians who see this issue as a matter of political or party advantage is that the argument that Iain Gray is now putting forward corresponds neither with what he and his colleagues did when they were in government in this Parliament nor with what his colleagues at Westminster are doing south of the border. The best way for the Parliament to proceed is to acknowledge the substantial progress that has been made on this hugely difficult issue, the fact that we have the lowest crime level in Scotland for a generation and the fact that, thanks to some parties that are represented in the Parliament, we have the highest recorded number of police officers in Scotland in our history. The Parliament should acknowledge that those things would not have happened and did not happen under a Labour-Liberal Administration and have happened under this Administration.
The action that we took previously on knife crime was to increase the maximum sentence. I acknowledge that we now believe that that was not enough. I believe that because two thirds of convicted knife criminals get no jail sentence at all and two thirds of those who do get sentences of six months or less. It worries me that the First Minister is planning to scrap all of those six-month sentences. It is no good the First Minister saying that this is party politicisation. The fact of the matter is that he is seeking to end six-month sentences—we will oppose that—and that the policy that he is pursuing will allow more than 600 convicted knife criminals every year to avoid jail completely. That is not being tough on knife crime, is not doing enough and is not what the people of Scotland want. Will the First Minister admit that and support our amendment next week?
Let me see whether I can crystallise the issue for Iain Gray and the Labour Party in one statistic. The average prison sentence for possession of a knife increased from 161 days in 2006-07 to 217 days in 2007-08. I point out to Iain Gray that 161 days, under the previous Administration, is less than six months and that 217 days is more than six months, in line with the Scottish National Party’s belief that people who commit serious offences should go to prison for serious amounts of time. That is the basis on which we are addressing criminal justice reforms.
The Parliament should acknowledge that this hugely serious issue, which affects many people in Scotland, goes deep into the nature of society and is related to abuse of drink, abuse of drugs and gang violence. It should acknowledge that those issues must be tackled, as this Administration is doing, and should understand the context in which crime takes place. Above all, it should understand—as every member of the community of Scotland understands—that the best basic protection for the community is to have more police officers on the streets of Scotland, like the 1,000 more police officers who are there today, compared with absolutely zero under the Labour Administration’s proposals at the 2007 election.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2010 →- Curriculum for Excellence Debate · 58
- Tasers Debate · 64
- Strathclyde Partnership for Transport Questions · 4
- A82 and A83 (Improvements) Questions · 6
- Major Road Projects Questions · 7
- Economic Crisis (European Funding) Questions · 5
- A92 Road Orders (Public Local Inquiry) Questions · 6
- Built Heritage Questions · 8
- NHS Lanarkshire (General Practitioners) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Strathclyde Partnership for Transport First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Rail Dispute First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Electoral Commission (Independence Referendum) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 (Community Right to Buy) Questions · 4
- Black Bees (Colonsay) Questions · 6
- Biodiversity (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Single Farm Payment (Livestock Numbers) Questions · 6
- Greener Scotland Questions · 6
- Recycling Questions · 9
- West of Scotland Catch Composition Rules Questions · 4
- Police (Arms Policy) Questions · 4
- Jury System (Reform) Questions · 4
- Her Majesty’s Prison Cornton Vale Questions · 8
- Serious and Organised Crime (West of Scotland) Questions · 6
- Police (Firearms Training) Questions · 5
- Double Jeopardy Questions · 6
- High Hedges Questions · 4
- “Inquiry into Future Support for Agriculture in Scotland” Debate · 46
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
- Perth 800 Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.