Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Disabled-friendly Housing (PE1554)

Tuesday 31 March 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:15–11:15 Petitions 26 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

26 contributions
John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The final new petition is PE1554, by Jacq Kelly, on behalf of Leonard Cheshire Disability, on improving the provision of disabled-friendly housing. Members have a note by the clerk and a SPICe briefing.

I welcome Jacq Kelly, who is the Scotland policy and parliamentary officer for Leonard Cheshire Disability. She is accompanied by Stephan Thomson, a Leonard Cheshire Disability service user. I invite Ms Kelly to speak to her petition for five minutes, to explain what it seeks to do, after which we will move to questions from members.

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

Our petition calls on the Scottish Government to make lifetime home standards the standard for ordinary builds and for 10 per cent of those builds to be wheelchair accessible.

Lifetime homes are a straightforward concept—basically, they are homes that people should be able to live in for their entire lives. They are not the same as completely accessible homes but are homes that can be adapted quite simply at relatively low cost—usually about £1,100. At the time of building a home, the builder thinks about adaptations that might be necessary in the future. There is a misconception that there are disabled people and non-disabled people. Our view is that anybody could be disabled in the future and they might not want to move out of their home because they want a good quality of life.

The principles of lifetime homes are fairly straightforward. They are about inclusivity, accessibility, adaptability, sustainability and good value. They have accessible doorways that people can fit a wheelchair through even if the people who are living in them are not wheelchair users at the time. That means that, if they become wheelchair users at some point in the future, it will not cost a huge amount of money to change the doorways to enable them to remain in their homes.

Lifetime homes also have reinforced walls so that grab rails can be installed. Grab rails are very important for allowing people to stay in their homes if they acquire a disability, but many walls are too flimsy for them and a grab rail will come straight down. Putting in a reinforced wall at the beginning, at the point of building a home, is much cheaper than making the adaptation later, not least because that is the sort of thing that leads to people having to go into residential care when that is not their choice or having a longer stay in hospital when they would like to get back into their home.

The other week, we had the announcement on health and social care integration from the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport. The extra £200 million that she announced towards that was welcome, but we know that one of the major factors in integrating health and social care properly is the availability of accessible, adequate housing.

We have heard stories about people having to live in the downstairs of their homes and wash in their kitchen sink, for example, because they do not have a bathroom that could be adapted for a wheelchair to fit into. Stephan Thomson will talk a little about his experience of that after I have finished.

I will explain why we chose to petition on this particular issue. I know that you have our submission, but I will give you a brief overview of our research. We found that, in the UK, one in six people with disabilities and half of all children with disabilities live in homes that do not meet their needs. Almost three quarters of people with disabilities in Scotland report that they live in a home with an inaccessible front door. At the current very slow rate of increase, it would take 62 years for there to be enough wheelchair-accessible houses for the people in Scotland who need them.

We just do not think that it is acceptable that anybody has to wash in their kitchen sink, is unable to get in and out of their house, is confined to it because the front door is inaccessible or has to go into residential care when that would not be their choice. There is nothing wrong with residential care when it is somebody’s choice, but 35 per cent of our residential service managers say that they have at least one person in their care home who would have chosen not to be there if they could have stayed in their own home. We think that that is completely unacceptable.

That is the personal cost to the individual; there is also a knock-on effect for the public purse. A study that we did recently—you will not have seen it yet as it is new research that we have just completed, but I can send it to you—shows that in January alone Scottish general practitioners spent the equivalent of four and a half working months, which equates to 939 hours, dealing with disabled and older patients because of injuries and illnesses caused by living in inaccessible homes. If that is true of all GPs in Scotland, it amounts to 27.3 million hours every year. The £1,100 figure looks tiny in comparison.

Stephan Thomson will talk about his experiences, and then we will be happy to take questions. You might want to ask about the lifetime home standard and what is covered by Scottish building regulations, because some things are covered. The Scottish Government is looking into amending those regulations, but we think that that could make homes less accessible in the longer term.

Stephan Thomson
link

I live in a house that is supposed to be wheelchair adapted, but it is actually just a wheelchair-friendly house. As for the point that Jacq Kelly made about doors and things being wide enough, with my chair I cannot move freely on my own in my home. I cannot turn 360° in my hallway or wear my footplates in my hallway to get in and out of the front door, which causes problems. I had to get my front door adapted to an electric door simply because it had a lip on it. Basically, I had to take a run at it to get into the house because there was a drop. Before I had my door put in, I actually fell out of my power chair and landed on the concrete. It took a long time, speaking with the council, to get a new door put in. It helped when that was done, but that is only one point.

Jacq Kelly also talked about the cost of patients being in hospital and things like that. I could tell you about a few occasions when I have fallen in my home because I have not had the right grab rails or things like that to be able to balance and transfer from A to B—say, out of my chair to my couch. I cannot walk, obviously. At one point, I fell on the floor and I ended up spending 13 hours waiting for one of my family members to come and find me. I had no access to my mobile phone, or a phone of any kind, so I had to lie there and wait for someone to come and get me.

Eventually, I had to have a call button put in, but I ask you to think about the time that it takes for someone to respond. You have to wait for them to come and help you and, even if they come, they have to wait for an ambulance or people who are trained to lift you, which also costs money.

If you end up in hospital, it can have a knock-on effect: not only does it cost more money for rehabilitation and the hospital stay, depending on what injuries you get, but you feel helpless because you have to depend on other people, which takes away your independence. You feel trapped because you are not able to get up on your own whereas, if you had a house that was designed for your wheelchair in the first place, you could cut down on the costs.

My house is nice but it is not a wheelchair house. The authorities said that it was wheelchair friendly. It does not have the right equipment in it. I have only once been assessed by an occupational therapist.

That takes me on to my third point, which is about my bathroom. Let us imagine that there was a doorway behind you and you needed to go to the bathroom but could not shut the bathroom door because there was not enough room in the bathroom for you and your wheelchair. You could not shut the bathroom door when your friends were in. We would all sit here and you would have to go to the bathroom but not close the door. That is against human rights.

The house is just too small. The doorways are not designed for a wheelchair. No OTs have come to examine the bathroom with a view to adapting it because there is not enough space. It is not a wet room. A couple of grab rails were put in and that was it. I have never seen an OT since then.

It is a big point that I cannot go to the bathroom in privacy in my own home, which should be designed for a wheelchair user. I have a friend whose house is adapted for her chair and it is possible to go into her bathroom and close the door, whereas my house is not adapted. It is to do with finances and money. The authorities do not have the money to adapt the house or make the changes that they need to, which cuts my quality of life. I have had to ask my friends to leave simply so that I can go to the bathroom, which I should not have to do.

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

Stephan is talking about cost. The estimated cost of one hip fracture caused by somebody falling over is £28,000, which puts the £1,100 cost of adaptation into perspective.

Stephan has friends who are wheelchair users who will not come round to his house because they cannot go to the bathroom in their wheelchairs. Particularly when somebody’s mobility is already restricted, it is simply unacceptable that they cannot have visitors to their house because the bathroom is not accessible.

The cost of putting in the grab rails would be much cheaper if the house had been built to lifetime standards and the doors been widened in the first place. There is a proposed change in the building regulations that will enable builders to make bathrooms smaller than they are currently required to, which means that, if a bathroom needs to be adapted in the future and turned into a wet room or a room big enough for a wheelchair to navigate around, it will be even harder to achieve.

I am sorry to have interrupted, Stephan.

11:00

Stephan Thomson
link

It is true that, when you are in a wheelchair, the hallways and doors in a house are not wide enough and you end up damaging your property because you bash into walls just trying to turn around. When you speak to the council about it, they just say, “We don’t have any wheelchair-friendly houses that we can give you.” There are just none available at the moment, so you just have to make do and I do not think that that is very fair. That goes back to the main point of the petition.

A person has a right to go to their bathroom without feeling embarrassed and to be able to have friends over without them feeling embarrassed about going to the bathroom. The only change that was made to my bathroom was that they put in two grab rails. That was it—they said that they could not do anything else. I am stuck in limbo because I do not know what else to do.

If people were given houses that were made for wheelchairs, as Jacq says, that could cut down on the cost of hospital stays, medication and everything else—it would have a knock-on effect on all those things. When someone is in a house that is not designed for their wheelchair, they can also cause more injury to themselves trying to do things in ways that they should not because they have no alternative.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I thank Jacq Kelly for her presentation and Stephan Thomson for highlighting some of his personal difficulties and experiences with his house. Do members have any questions?

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning. I fully support your petition. Should local authorities play a greater role when replacing existing council housing with accessible new builds? I will give you an example from Fife Council. When new council houses were built in Kirkcaldy recently, they were all designed to be disabled friendly. When local authorities build new council houses, should they ensure that accessible houses make up a bigger proportion of them?

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

Definitely. We are finding that councils need to be compelled to do that, because they are not doing it.

There are two things to mention. First, we have found that a lot of local authorities do not even know how many accessible homes they have in their housing stock. Secondly, we were asked by an MSP—I think that it was Michael McMahon or Ken Macintosh—whether there is regional variation in the number of people who are waiting to get an accessible house and cannot get one, but we do not know, because local authorities do not know. They do not know how many accessible houses they have or how many people are waiting for accessible houses, which is a problem. Even finding out those two things, for a start, would be a big help. The Glasgow Centre for Inclusive Living started a register of accessible homes in Glasgow so that people would know where the accessible homes are, and it would be nice to see that replicated throughout the country.

Local authorities definitely need to be compelled, because they are not providing what we think is a very reasonable solution to the problem. People do not have to be disabled to live in a lifetime-standards home—anybody could live in one, and it could even work for families who have kids in buggies, who need to be able to get into the hallway with a buggy.

This is the most practical long-term solution, as it would allow people to stay in their homes. It is unacceptable that folk are having to go into residential care when they would prefer to stay in their own home but simply cannot.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Good morning. Ms Kelly, you mentioned accessible homes, but the definition of accessible can vary widely. Stephan Thomson gave a good example. His house would be classified as accessible because he can get his wheelchair through the front door, although he cannot get it around the house.

How can we ensure that accessible homes are properly accessible? On Saturday, I visited a constituent who lives in a new-build council house. Like Stephan Thomson, my constituent has a problem in moving her wheelchair from the living room to the kitchen without scraping the bottom of the door leading into the kitchen. Although such houses were designed primarily for people with disability issues, the designers clearly had not thought about adding a couple of inches to the width of the doorways to allow a wheelchair to go through.

How can we get a clear definition of accessible? The Glasgow Centre for Inclusive Living has individuals who go round and check properties. Can we get a common standard for accessibility and include lifetime accessibility in that?

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

In the campaign that we at Leonard Cheshire are running, we have spoken about disabled-friendly houses, which are different from accessible homes. Stephan Thomson’s home would be considered to be disabled friendly but not accessible. If a property is going to be marketed as a properly accessible home, it must be designed in consultation with disabled people.

When we came into Edinburgh on the train yesterday, we discussed the point that not much mind is paid to the fact that not all disabled people are the same. Stephan has one kind of chair and his friend David has a much bigger one than him, so there is not a one-size-fits-all answer to accessibility. Even accessible toilets are often not accessible. I wonder whether people really consult disability organisations and disabled people on their needs and how best to meet them.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Have you had any discussions with house builders? In such debates, we usually end up talking about council or housing association provision but not getting into private provision. The petition is clear that at least 10 per cent of all new homes should be built to fully wheelchair-accessible standards, but what discussions have taken place with private house builders about that?

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

We have had no such discussions yet, but we have pinpointed two private house builders that are building disabled-friendly homes out of choice because they see it as a great marketing point for the future. One in Glasgow and another in Fife have decided that it is a good selling point for people who want to stay in their homes if something happens to them and they become a bit less mobile.

It costs the house builders little to put in reinforced walls early, and they can market the properties as homes for the future. I know somebody who recently bought a home particularly because the bathroom was designed so that, in the future, it could easily be transformed into a wet room.

You make a really good point. We are starting to look into whether we can talk to private contractors and talk about positive cases as well as the negative ones.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

The petition strikes me as one of the most commonsense petitions to have come before the committee since I joined it. I was interested to hear the comments about changes to building regulations that could result in even smaller bathrooms. I have visited some new-build properties recently and I find it hard to believe that bathrooms could be even smaller than those that are being built.

According to the building standards technical handbook, the Scottish Government has taken cognisance of housing for varying needs and the lifetime homes concept that the Joseph Rowntree Foundation developed. Can Jacq Kelly or Stephan Thomson give us any examples of good practice? I presume that Margaret Blackwood Housing Association has properties that you consider ideal, but are you aware of any other examples of good practice?

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

We are not falling over those examples, to be honest with you.

On your point about the building standards, I was looking at the handbook this morning. It is 650 pages long, so I have not read the entire thing, but I read the section to which you refer. It includes some of the lifetime standards, but it focuses more on floor space than on having reinforced walls for grab rails. However, grab rails are one of the things that can make the biggest difference, particularly for older people. Not everyone ends up being a wheelchair user, but a lot of folk would benefit from a grab rail later in life. However, that is not possible, because grab rails are not included in the building regulations.

The floor space in a bathroom must be 3.6m2. Under the proposals, that would be reduced to 2.5m2, which seems tiny to me, never mind wheelchair users, who have to get into the bathroom, shut the door, turn around and do whatever. That seems impossible.

We are not tripping over good examples. If anyone has any, we would love to hear them, because we would love to promote good cases and encourage other housing associations to do the same thing.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I see that there are no other questions from members. In that case, what action is the committee prepared to take?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

We should write to the Government. As Angus MacDonald said, a lot of this is common sense. If action was taken to ensure that walls are capable of taking grab rails, that would not require every wall to be brick, concrete or whatever. The issues must be considered.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I agree. It was mentioned that two companies—one in Fife and one in Glasgow—are building disabled-friendly homes. We should write to them, as it would be interesting to hear their views. I know that Fife Council has built new disabled-friendly council housing, so we should also write to it to see what it is doing.

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

Stephan Thomson wants to make a point about good practice that he knows about.

Stephan Thomson
link

A friend of mine has a house that is designed for wheelchairs. I have been into her home, which is an absolutely amazing house. All the kitchen units and worktops are lowered, the bathroom has more than enough space in it and she even has a piece of equipment in her cupboards that comes down like steps, so that she can reach things. In that way, she does not have to depend on other people getting things for her. She has her independence; she can do stuff by herself rather than having to depend on others.

Before the council gave my friend her house, it took her into the home to begin with and decided how to design the house around her from scratch. When I was given my house, I was told, “This is the only house we’ve got, so you can take it or you’re stuck, because we’ve got nowhere else for you to stay.” That would have put pressure on family members.

My friend has visited my home. She cannot understand how the council has managed to say that the house is suitable for wheelchairs, and her wheelchair is smaller than mine. She thinks that it is appalling that the council can say that my house is suitable for wheelchairs. As I said, her house was designed for her from the beginning.

Councils should look at housing from the view of the disabled. They should have the wheelchair user go in first and then have talks with OTs. They should start from scratch when building the housing. That will be cheaper in the long run, rather than making adaptations once a person is in the home.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Could we write to all the local authorities to see what percentage of new-build housing is disabled friendly?

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Yes. Before we return to the action points, I have a question for Jacq Kelly. What is the least disabled-friendly housing? Is it new builds or old housing, or are they both the same?

11:15

Jacq Kelly Leonard Cheshire Disability
link

They are probably both still the same, although that might depend on where people are. I imagine that, in an old city such as Edinburgh, the old builds are pretty inaccessible. I find that to be the case when I am visiting friends.

I have seen no evidence of a huge increase in the number of accessible new builds. I know of a woman in Edinburgh who is registered homeless. She is a wheelchair user and she is having to be put into an inaccessible home temporarily because no accessible home is being built for her. I do not have any data to hand, but I am not getting any impression that there will be a massive improvement with the coming new builds.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Colleagues, do we agree to write to the Scottish Government, Local Authority Building Standards Scotland, the Lifetime Homes foundation and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities to seek their views?

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we also write to Homes for Scotland, as the trade body for house builders, and to the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations, as the body that incorporates the majority of housing associations and co-ops, to ask for their views on the petition. Unfortunately, the landlords that are asked to make the greatest provision are in the social rented sector. It would be useful to get their views, too. As the trade body, Homes for Scotland must be asked what its members are doing to address the accessible housing issue.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I have just been advised that, if we write to all the local authorities, there will be no requirement to write to COSLA. Do colleagues agree to take the approach outlined?

Members indicated agreement.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I thank Jacq Kelly and Stephan Thomson for attending.

Meeting closed at 11:16.

  1. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  4. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  5. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 23
  6. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 30
  7. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 26

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.