It might be helpful if we use the Scottish rate of income tax as an example, given that it is the area that we have worked through the furthest.
There is now an agreement in progress among the UK Government, the Scottish Government and HMRC about how the implementation will be achieved. In future, the Scottish Fiscal Commission will comment on the forecasts for the Scottish rate of income tax proceeds in the same way as the OBR does for UK forecasts. Our formal interest will start at the point at which that sum of money is transferred from HMRC to the Scottish Government’s consolidated fund bank account. We will be auditing that in the Scottish Government’s financial statements, whatever form they take at that stage.
The memorandum of understanding that committee members have in front of them in draft form today attempts to move a bit further than that in saying that the Scottish Parliament also has an interest in ensuring that the amount that is transferred properly reflects the amount that is collected from Scottish taxpayers under the agreement that has been made. HMRC is a UK body that is audited by the NAO and will continue to be so, but we are agreeing a mechanism by which HMRC will discuss with us its audit work in so far as it relates to the Scottish rate of income tax proceeds. We will have the power to comment on its reports to this committee and to this Parliament if we think that there are issues that need to be drawn to your attention.
That model can be extended to other sources of income or expenditure that are administered by UK bodies on behalf of the Scottish Parliament. For some of the new taxes that are to be raised in Scotland, such as air passenger duty and the aggregates levy, the focus will be much more clearly on what is done by the Scottish Government, and we will therefore have a direct audit relationship.
We are looking at a more nuanced landscape and set of arrangements in future, and it is helpful to have the chance to talk to you now about your priorities and the areas of interest or uncertainty on which you may need assurance in future.