Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Commonwealth Games 2014: Third report”

Wednesday 25 March 2015 Public Audit Committee About 10:30–11:15 Evidence session 63 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

63 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Under item 3, we will take evidence from Audit Scotland on the Auditor General for Scotland’s Commonwealth games report. I welcome Caroline Gardner, Auditor General for Scotland. From Audit Scotland are Angela Cullen, assistant director; Tricia Meldrum, senior manager; and Michael Oliphant, project manager. The Auditor General has a brief opening statement.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The report is the third in a series of reports looking at the Commonwealth games, which took place in Glasgow last summer. As the committee will know, we published two earlier reports on planning for the games in November 2009 and March 2012. Those reports focused on whether the strategic partners—the Scottish Government, Glasgow City Council and Glasgow 2014, which made up the organising committee, and Commonwealth Games Scotland—were on track to deliver the games on time and on budget. Both reports considered the main risks at that time and how well the partners were managing them.

Today’s report is our first following the games. It focuses on the overall cost of the games and how that compares with the budget that was set, including the financial contribution from the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council. The report also considers the plans of the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council for tracking, monitoring and reporting on the expected legacy benefits, which were an important feature of Glasgow’s successful bid to host the games.

I will summarise our findings under three areas, the first of which is the overall success of the games. We found good evidence that the games were successful for Glasgow and Scotland. That included higher-than-expected ticket sales, positive feedback from spectators, high visitor numbers to Scotland, a record number of participants and a high level of international media coverage.

The main reasons for the success of the games were early planning, a strong commitment from the strategic partners to delivering a successful games and good partnership working from all the organisations involved. That example of good partnership working could be spread more widely to other parts of the public sector, since partnership working is becoming increasingly important.

We found that the overall cost of the games was £543 million, which was £32 million less than the £575 million budget that was set. Importantly, the public sector contribution was £37.2 million less than expected, with the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council together spending £424.5 million of the £461.7 million that they had set aside to fund the games. The remaining costs of the games were met by income received from private sources such as ticket sales, sponsorship and broadcasting rights.

The overall cost included £88.3 million spent on delivering the safety and security operation, which was overseen by Police Scotland. The games passed without major safety or security concerns, and Police Scotland delivered the operation within its final budget of £90 million.

Finally, we found that the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council have developed clear plans for delivering legacy benefits from the games. The games legacy covers sporting participation, together with wider impacts on healthier lifestyles, the environment and the economy. The Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council are leading on a range of national and local programmes and projects that are designed to contribute to legacy outcomes. Those outcomes will be measured using a variety of methods, including tracking 58 indicators, an economic evaluation assessment and a longitudinal study focusing on the impact of housing and neighbourhood regeneration on the health and wellbeing of communities in the east end of Glasgow.

Our report makes recommendations for the Scottish Government and Glasgow City Council to help them to continue building on the good legacy work so far. For example, we have recommended that they ensure that the evaluation, which is due this spring, assesses the impact of their investment on legacy outcomes. Looking ahead, the Scottish Government plans to report on the legacy each year up to 2019. We will continue to monitor progress.

As always, convener, my colleagues and I are happy to answer questions from the committee.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Thank you. I have a technical point to ask about. Who on Glasgow City Council will carry out the evaluation?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that the evaluation, which is planned to be published this spring, is being carried out by an external partner. Michael Oliphant will pick up that point.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

A group called the Glasgow legacy evaluation working group—or GLEWG, to give it a short and snappy title—has been created. It is made up of partners including the Scottish Government, Glasgow City Council, academics and the national health service.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

An obvious question to ask is whether evaluating its own participation is the normal process for a body to follow. That would not be considered to be an independent evaluation, would it?

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

As there are so many partners involved, including the academics, I think that they will provide the challenge to the statisticians and economists who are involved in the group.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We did not think it unusual for the evaluation to be carried out in such a way by the partners. We will certainly examine all the evaluation that takes place over the coming years to ensure that it is rigorous, as you would expect it to be. That does not necessarily mean that it should be carried out by somebody who is entirely independent of the partners.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Although 98 per cent of tickets were sold, the income was £34 million, which was £6 million less than for the Melbourne games in 2006, where only 85 per cent of tickets were sold. I welcome the fact that the games were accessible to people on a wide range of incomes.

In one of your earlier reports, you mentioned the security budget rising from £27 million to £90 million. That was quite a significant increase—a £63 million increase. On page 22 of your current report, we have the breakdown of the safety and security spending, which came in £2 million under budget, at £88 million. However, 40 per cent of it—£37 million—was spent on equipment. I notice that that included

“perimeter fencing, airport-style security scanners and radio communications.”

Was the £37 million that Police Scotland spent used for equipment that was uniquely and solely for the games, or will it be part of Police Scotland’s investment for future operations?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right that the budget for security increased from £27 million to £90 million. In part, that reflects a recommendation that we made in one of our earlier reports, which suggested that the budget might not be enough to cover the requirements, and it reflects the organising committee’s ability to learn from the experience in the London Olympics in 2012.

The £37 million to which you refer was for required equipment purchase and hire. I ask Michael Oliphant take you through a bit more of what we know about that.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

The equipment that was hired included airport-style security scanners and fencing that was used to fence off some of the venues and the perimeter area. That was not just standard fencing; it was high-technology fencing with security cameras and so forth on it. Some specialist equipment was purchased, including radio communications equipment that can continue to be used for Police Scotland. There was a combination of hire and purchase.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

This is my only issue to raise, so I will drill down into that. How much of the £37 million was an investment only for the games and how much is continued investment for Police Scotland, such as the radio communications equipment?

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

I am afraid that I do not have that detailed information to hand.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I will also ask about security, which Mary Scanlon pursued. I notice that paragraph 52, on page 22, states that the overtime costs for policing amounted to £16.8 million. Did you examine that figure? It seems like a big number, given that the whole security budget was originally £27 million.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Michael Oliphant will give more detail on what we know. The figure for overtime costs includes the overtime that was required for policing the games in Glasgow and for support that was given to other parts of Scotland to reflect the fact that a number of police officers were pulled into that central location.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

The policing costs included the salary costs of the planning and delivery team that existed in the run-up to and during the games. They also covered overtime, travel and various allowances for not only Police Scotland officers but mutual-aid officers from other UK forces who provided specialist support.

That was the bulk of the figure. There was also about £700,000-worth of what was described as business-as-usual costs, which covered overtime payments for policing in other areas of Scotland, to ensure business as usual during the games.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Did other agencies—the Scottish Ambulance Service, the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and other blue-light emergency services—adopt the same strategy? Perhaps I should not use the word “strategy”; that is unfair. Did they adopt the same practice of, as it were, charging the games organisers on exactly the basis that you have described?

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

In paragraph 59, we refer to the Scottish Ambulance Service and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service. Money was not included in the overall games budget for their additional services, so those costs were additional costs to the games, which are outlined in that paragraph. The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service estimated costs of around £2.2 million for providing services, training and support during the games, and the Scottish Ambulance Service estimated costs of around £1.2 million, half of which was provided for in the games budget. I think that those additional costs have been finalised, but we worked with estimates at the time of the audit.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Those costs are quite small in comparison with the police costs. Why was the police’s overtime spend so large? Was it just inevitable that it would be, given the number of police officers who were involved? I take the Auditor General’s point that we called for a budget increase, but the budget rose from £27 million to £90 million, which is a big leap by any standard and, when we hear that the thick end of £17 million was spent on overtime, it sounds as if the costs ran away with themselves.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We would make the point that the £16.8 million for overtime did not cover just the 11-day period of the games; it also covered the planning and preparation period, and there was a lot of real-time updating of plans and responding to issues.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So the money was not for overtime—it was for normal work, but it was charged under the overtime arrangements.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is right. The additional time that was required came from a range of sources. That is how the funding worked. For example, we say in the report that it became clear at one point that, on days when all the major venues were in use, the transport system would not be able to cope. There was a very quick response to planning how that would work, to which the police were central.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

The more proper question is, are you satisfied that the movement in the budget for safety and security from £27 million to £90 million was justified and is fully auditable on that basis?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Yes. As you would expect, we looked closely at that budget heading. It was one of those classic situations—a bit like the year 2000 information technology concerns—where, if something had gone badly wrong and spending had not been in place, it would have been easy to criticise. The fact that everything went smoothly means that the question whether the money was needed is raised. However, we do not have concerns in this case.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I welcome the report, which is really positive. It underscores the success of the games. We already knew that they were successful and it is nice to see you supporting that.

Clearly, one of the important elements is the legacy benefits, which have always been emphasised. On page 25, you say that clear plans and comprehensive sets of indicators are in place. It is encouraging that you say that there are already examples of successful legacy outcomes, although you acknowledge that it is early days.

Is the legacy of the games predicated on public sector funding? Is that an essential element to ensuring that the legacy benefits are achieved?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will kick off by saying that we always try to ensure that our reports are fair and balanced and to give credit for good performance, as well as identifying where there is room for improvement. You are right to say that, in this report, we say that planning for the legacy has been good so far, and we identify challenges with demonstrating that over time.

By its nature, it is difficult to show the link between the investment that is made and the wide-ranging legacy benefits. We have identified a risk that, with the continuing pressure on public sector budgets, other things might happen to make the benefits harder to achieve, such as reduced opening hours for sports facilities or higher ticket prices, for example.

The point that we are making is that the games would not have happened without the £420 million or so of public sector investment from the Government and Glasgow City Council. The bid’s success was based to a large extent on the benefits that were intended to come from that investment.

11:00

Although we recognise that it is not straightforward, continuing the link between the money that was spent and the benefits that are achieved seems to be an important part of the evaluation that is due this spring and the evaluation over a longer period. It is particularly important in the evaluation by GoWell east of the specific benefits for the community in the east end of Glasgow, where the potential to transform people’s lives and their environment exists, but careful attention is required to ensure that that happens in practice.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I will stay on page 25 of the report. You state in the first paragraph that there are

“clear plans for realising legacy benefits from the Games at local, city-wide and national levels.”

I ask out of curiosity about the reference in paragraph 65, on page 27, to three legacy projects in Wales and one in England, which I am surprised about.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I ask Tricia Meldrum and Michael Oliphant to talk you through the background to that.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

Legacy 2014 is a brand, if you like, so a number of projects meet the requirements for classification to use the branding that is associated with the games. They are not specific to Scotland—they have wider benefits across the UK.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

The Big Lottery Fund is a key funder of a lot of those projects. It is a UK organisation, and it has provided funding to projects in Wales and England, too. Those projects have access to the Glasgow legacy logo and so on. I do not know the detail of the projects, but they were designed to increase participation in sport among young people in the areas that were selected, and they are drawing money from the Big Lottery Fund.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That answers what would have been my next question. I was concerned that public funds might be getting used for projects elsewhere, but if the funding comes from lottery money in support of the games, that does not seem unreasonable.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

On one level, the Commonwealth games were a huge success. All credit should go to Glasgow City Council’s previous executive for going for the bid, and to the council and the Scottish Government for pursuing it when circumstances changed. In many ways, the environment for hosting the games became less than ideal following the financial crash.

The Auditor General talks about the effect on the legacy of pressures on public sector budgets. However, the crash also had an impact on people having money in their pocket to buy tickets, on broadcasters being interested in bidding for licences and on money being available for sponsorship. To have pulled off the event in that environment makes for a really encouraging report.

As the report highlights, we can evaluate whether the event’s legacy has represented value for money only over the long term. That is classically the most difficult part to evaluate. How big a risk is the on-going situation with public sector support for projects to achieving the outcome of a legacy?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Our starting point is that the planning for the legacy has been done well. From the original bid, the case for putting the games on and investing public money was that there would be a legacy. The legacy outcomes were well specified at the local level in Glasgow and across Scotland, and that is a good thing.

We outline in part 3 of the report the framework for the outcomes, with the 58 national indicators and the other measures for the legacy. All of that is a great start.

You are right that there is now a risk, either because people take their eye off the ball as we have had such a great games and the event has been such a great success or, more realistically, because there are other pressures on budgets that will continue through the years ahead and might make some of the legacy outcomes tougher to achieve than we might have expected back in 2004. There is no lessening of the commitment from the Government or Glasgow City Council—or from the other 31 councils—to ensuring that the benefits are achieved. That is why the continuing focus by the Government and councils on what they are getting is so important and why we will continue to monitor it.

It is human nature to shift attention from what has been achieved to the next big thing that is coming. We think that it is important for Scotland that the benefits can be demonstrated so that, when future opportunities like the games come up, there is no risk of cynicism in thinking about what we might be able to do if we put the money in. We can demonstrate the achievements that were made and capitalise on the success that was achieved last summer.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

One of the positive things that are continuing is our legacy leads group, which was established in the run-up to the games to consider the legacy across the country. The decision has been made that there is value in that group continuing to exist and continuing to share, roll out and support good practice for what is being done in areas across the country.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

For me, one of the greatest achievements of the games is that they challenge our cynicism about things. I spoke to people in advance of the games, and they said that, if we were planning and going for the event in the current environment, we would not do it—yet the fact is that we were able to persevere with it, and we did it.

Are there any key long-term lessons for us when it comes to thinking about bidding for future international events? The timescales are so large, and there are so many unpredictables ahead. What are the key things to take from our experience?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Some of the things that we say in our report about why the games were a success are important things not to lose sight of. There was a strong, clear, shared vision on the part of the Government and Glasgow City Council about why they wanted to do the games, and that worked all the way through into clarity about what the benefits would be last summer and for a generation to come. That was not just left as a nice, warm feeling; the Government and the council did the hard work of asking who would do what and how they could ensure that their governance arrangements were fit for purpose. The governance arrangements continued to evolve so that issues that came up as the games approached could be responded to quickly.

On planning and financial management, there was a strong response to differences in, for example, venue costs: when venues cost more than had been expected and required money from somewhere else in the budget, as well as when venues cost less, which freed up money to invest in something else. All of that worked very well.

You are right that the circumstances in 2014 were very different from those at the point at which the successful bid was announced. However, things that we had reported on as being risky, such as income from ticket sales and broadcasting rights, came in either at or above the level of expectations. That reflects that really strong partnership working.

For us, the main lesson is that getting the partnership working right can have a huge pay-off. We rely on that model of partnership working for lots of other bits of public policy, including health and social care integration and community planning. What lessons can we learn for those areas, which might not have the same immediate glamour as the games, but which are at least as important in terms of changing the way in which public services operate and the success of Scotland?

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

There is much cause for optimism there.

I have two further questions. The first is on the legacy. You have spoken about the challenge of public budgets. Where is the legacy from the commercial elements of revenue and sponsorship? Perhaps it was not possible to do more, but is that legacy sufficient? Were we able to convince people to become involved in the success of the games and to commit to something bigger than just the games? Did the commercial reality mean that people were only interested in the two weeks in Glasgow?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

At the bid stage, the initial expectation was that the commercial income, and particularly the sponsorship income, would simply be another source of funding for delivering a successful games. Michael Oliphant and Tricia Meldrum might wish to add something about whether the result was different from what was expected.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

Sponsorship was a very positive aspect of the commercial income. From the point of view of bidding for future events in Scotland, rather than from the legacy perspective, that has allowed the commercial partners and all the different sponsors involved to realise that they might possibly wish to get involved in future events. EventScotland has highlighted a number of different world championships that are coming to Scotland over the next year. The success of the Commonwealth games creates that platform for commercial partners to sponsor future events.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

You make a specific recommendation about the GoWell research project. I give you an opportunity to say a bit about why you think that what you recommend is important. I presume that you think that it is deliverable—that it could be fairly easily done and that it would be worth spending the time and money doing it.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Our view is that, as well as the broader benefits for Glasgow and for Scotland from the games, the particular benefits for the community in the east end of Glasgow were a key part of the bid. We had a real opportunity to change lives in a place that has lagged behind the rest of Scotland for a long period, in spite of great efforts over a long time.

The GoWell initiative predates the Commonwealth games bid but, after the successful bid, there was a specific focus on extending the initiative to get more detail about the lives of people in the area and their health and wellbeing. Under current plans, it will end in 2016. We think that that is not long enough for it to be able to demonstrate the changes that are envisaged for people’s lives and for communities, and we have recommended that it should be extended to 2026 to allow much richer information to be provided about what has happened for that group.

Tricia Meldrum might have something to add on the context and our thinking.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

Yes. We think that, because the GoWell evaluation has a number of strands to it, it will give some quite powerful information about the impact for those communities. For example, one aspect of it is face-to-face interviews with around 1,000 people in the communities that have been directly affected by the regeneration for the games. Those interviews will cover issues such as people’s physical activity, their wellbeing and their experience of the neighbourhood and of housing. That will be a rich data source, and indicators and outcomes will be tracked.

However, if the final interviews and the final data collection are carried out in 2016, there will not be much time to look at the impact of all the work that has been done. For example, some people will move into the houses only in 2015.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

I presume that that is a decision for the Scottish Government to make. You have not had a response to the publication of the report that says that the Government is considering your recommendation, so it might be for Parliament to encourage it to do that.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is our recommendation, but it is for the Government and its partners to decide whether to accept it.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I go back to exhibit 6. We note that the military personnel were provided at no cost. I am not suggesting that you would ever have got the Ministry of Defence to give you a cost, but can any value be attached to the involvement of military personnel, which I presume was significant? If they had not been involved in the games, exhibit 6 would have had another entry with a number attached to it. Do we know what the substitute cost was?

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

We do not know what the substitute cost was. The table includes accommodation costs and some logistical costs, but the personnel themselves were provided at no charge. We have no information on what that value would have been.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I suggest that for the record—for the future rather than for the committee’s purposes—you might want to evaluate the number of man hours involved. Maybe the extent of the military’s involvement was insignificant—I do not know; I was not involved—but if a significant number of people were involved for a significant number of hours, the total costs that we have in exhibit 6 might deceive someone who decided to put on such an event in the future as regards expenditure on security. I leave that with you.

I want to pick up on the issue that Drew Smith helpfully brought up about the GoWell programme. I endorse your view and encourage you to make strongly to the Government the point that the research community will be extremely grateful if we have good, rich data and longitudinal studies. The Parliament will discuss health inequalities tomorrow afternoon, and that is precisely the kind of information that we need to enable us to evaluate what is going on. The subject is difficult enough to understand—it is difficult enough even to theorise on—even when we have some data, but if we do not have data, there is a risk that it becomes a lot of hot air. I am sure that the entire research community would encourage you to make that point strongly to the Government.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that the committee’s backing for that recommendation—if you reach that position—would also be a strong encouragement.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I have a comment and a question. My comment is about ticket sales. I am sure that if last year’s Commonwealth games had had a stadium the size of the Melbourne cricket ground—which holds around 90,000 people—we would have sold even more tickets and the ticket sales revenue would have been even greater, but that might be an issue for the future.

11:15

My question is about your opening comments, Auditor General. It has been widely recognised that the Glasgow Commonwealth games was a success—your report certainly states that, too. I want to look at the international perspective. Scotland has organised such a successful games, but it is not very good at saying when it has done something well. Unfortunately, one of its failing is that we do not have—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I ask colleagues to focus on their questions.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Sorry, convener.

How does Scotland tell the wider world about its expertise so that, when other big activities are taking place, it can offer its services and people can look at what happened here and learn from what we did last year?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right about ticket sales—98 per cent of the available tickets were sold. It is hard to see that the sales or income could have been much higher, so I absolutely accept the point.

On the benefits to Scotland from managing a large and complex event, we should not discount the intangible, hard-to-quantify but real benefits that will flow from Scotland having been on the public stage for that fortnight last summer. The evaluation should be looking at how we capture that. We recognise that putting a number on that is not straightforward—there is still a value to it, although a number may not exist

On expertise, a component of the agreement with the Commonwealth Games Federation is that knowledge transfer must take place as part of the wind-down exercise. I think that that has been completed successfully and that the organising committee here has received the payment that was due on successful completion of that work.

Michael Oliphant may be able to tell you more about the bigger picture and what is happening.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

Knowledge transfer is a key point. The Commonwealth Games Federation expects a level of knowledge transfer between host cities, so that lessons learned can be applied on an on-going basis—in this case, to the Gold Coast in Australia.

A tangible example that has been mentioned a few times is the Hampden restructure that took place, where the playing field was raised to include an athletics track. That has become known internationally as the Glasgow solution—sports stadia can be transformed in that way without the need to create the white elephants that we have perhaps seen with previous games. That is a positive aspect of transferring the learning from the Glasgow games to other games, whether they are Commonwealth or Olympic games.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

That was an interesting response, Mr Oliphant. It made me smile because it took me back to when the Stade de France was built. That is a multi-use stadium—it is not used just for one purpose; football, rugby, athletics and other activities take place there. We did not have the opportunity to build a new stadium, but it is heartening to hear about the Glasgow solution.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

My question is about case study 2 on page 29 of the report, which refers to employment and to

“a variety of legacy schemes”

that target

“the unemployed, under-employed and young people”.

Apprenticeships are also mentioned, and the report says that

“203 people have been helped into work.”

Is there a breakdown of the type of employment in that regard? How many apprenticeships were there? Are the jobs short term or long term?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is certainly more detail available than is in our report. I ask Michael Oliphant to talk you through the information that we have and the information that we may be able to provide separately.

Michael Oliphant Audit Scotland
link

We wanted to give a flavour of the activities that were going on in the case study. I do not know whether we have a breakdown of the type of jobs or if we can say whether they are short term or long term. The nature of apprenticeships is that they are short term initially but the hope is that, on completion, the apprentices have the necessary training to seek permanent employment. I do not know the detail behind that.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We would expect the evaluation to pick up that issue and to provide much more detail on the employment that has been created, including how much of it related to the short-term construction of venues and how much of it has been converted into skills that are used much more widely in the economy.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

It would be useful to know how the employment opportunities have expanded and whether they are permanent or semi-permanent solutions or whether they were very short-term facility building opportunities.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Absolutely.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

Glasgow City Council has probably been monitoring that. A lot of the contracts that it awarded for work throughout the games included community benefit clauses, and apprenticeships and jobs were part of those. We reported on the state of play in that regard in our 2012 report. The council should have been monitoring the situation.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I thank the Auditor General and her team for their time this morning.

11:20 Meeting continued in private until 11:50.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 119
  3. 10:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 63

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.