I will make a few comments, some of which relate to the previous point.
First of all, it would be lovely if politicians and in particular the media did not focus on academic league tables as a way of rating schools. I suggest that we introduce a literacy league table to ensure that schools do not let young people leave until they can read, write and spell appropriately—well, perhaps not spell, but at least read. This is a serious matter. Employers genuinely tell me all the time that the issue is basic literacy. Most employers do not want or expect anyone, whether they come from school, college, university or wherever, to be ready to do the job, but they expect them to be ready to work. That is quite a different thing, and I will expand on that in a minute.
As I have said, this is all about positive destinations. Schools, like colleges and universities, should be made to record quite clearly over a period of time what young people’s destinations are to ensure that they can be tracked. Somewhat unbelievably—to me, too—I have been with the Institute of Directors for 12 years now, and in those 12 years, no one has ever knocked on my door and said, “I can’t find a graduate.” It has never happened. However, people have said, “I can’t find a mass spectrometry technician”, “I can’t find an apprentice engineer” or, indeed, “I can’t find engineers of any sort.” I could go on about the whole variety of trades and skills that people want. During the recession, we were particularly concerned about the construction trade, and there are still some challenges to face in that respect.
If I am honest, I think that we focus far too much in this country on going to university. It is not necessarily the be-all and end-all, and it is not necessarily the career for everybody. Many bright young people—indeed, many of the country’s best and most successful people—did not go to university at all or went later in life; I can think of Jim McColl and other such examples. We need to change some of our traditional ways of thinking. Education is not just about going to university; it is a lifelong experience that everyone can keep doing, and employers can help with it once people are employed with them.
I absolutely take your basic point: employers want someone who can literally read, write and count, who will get up in the morning and attend their workplace, and who understands what work is like. That is why the Wood commission report and other such reports are so important. At the moment, young people can leave school in Scotland having done a week of work experience. That is just madness. How does one week’s experience teach them anything about anything? It also depends on where and how they get that work experience. There is a massive job for everyone, including us in the private sector, to engage with schools and perhaps colleges and universities and to change the model of education to engage young people, to ensure that they understand what work is all about and to open their eyes to the opportunities that are out there. Those opportunities are not all about academic achievement, but they are about achieving and doing things.
Finally—and, to be fair, I think that this is happening—schools need to realise that what matters is a pupil’s personal record of achievement, not the number of qualifications that they have when they leave school. The questions that matter are: how many days have they been off school? Are they timeous? Do they turn up on time? Are they consistent? Are they enthusiastic about the things they do, even if they are not good at them? We want all those things in the people who work beside us. Kids do not need to be brain of Britain; what really counts is that they deliver consistently. Schools can and need to record that kind of achievement and attainment, not academic achievement.