I would like to update the chamber on recent developments relating to Longannet and their implications for the future of Scotland’s electricity system.
On Monday, National Grid announced its decision to award a contract for additional voltage support services in 2016-17 to SSE’s Peterhead power station. I welcome the support for Peterhead. I understand that SSE is now progressing investment that will allow the station to operate more efficiently and flexibly. Peterhead is key to efforts to prove the viability of carbon capture and storage, which is a technology that has the potential to unlock future low-carbon thermal generation in Scotland.
For Longannet, however, National Grid’s decision is negative. Scottish Power has stated that “in all likelihood” it will be forced to close Longannet prematurely in 2016. The consequences of that would be profound for direct and indirect employment, for Scottish coal production, for hopes of restoring former opencast sites and, ultimately, for the balance and resilience of Scotland’s electricity supply.
Let me be clear. Although the decision is one for the company to make, we in the Scottish Government are determined to continue to explore any options that may avert the premature closure of Longannet. We believe that the decision that has been taken by National Grid and endorsed by the outgoing United Kingdom Government is flawed and fails to take account of serious flaws in the UK electricity supply system.
My foremost thoughts are for the 270 direct employees at Longannet and those affected in the related supply chain. This is a deeply worrying time for all those whose livelihoods depend most heavily on Longannet. I met the leader and deputy leader of Fife Council on 4 March, and I spoke again with Councillor David Ross earlier this week. We have agreed to work on a joint response. We will co-chair a meeting to co-ordinate our efforts and will invite input from Scottish Power, workforce representatives and other key stakeholders.
The Scottish Government-led partnership action for continuing employment—PACE—has contacted Scottish Power to outline the support that is on offer to affected employees. In addition, I will meet representatives of the Scottish Trades Union Congress and the Longannet unions on Thursday. The Government and all our partners will strain every sinew to secure the best possible outcomes for all those affected and to mitigate the local and national economic impact if closure cannot be averted.
The expected closure of Longannet will be felt throughout the supply chain, particularly in the coal sector. The Scottish coal industry has put forward proposals to the UK Government for restoration coal, which would introduce a carbon price support exemption for opencast coal sites. As well as addressing the environmental liabilities that are associated with unrestored opencast, restoration coal has the potential to reduce Longannet’s running costs. The UK and Scottish Governments are committed to further joint work to implement that proposal, and I have written to the Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury, Priti Patel, to urge swift action.
I turn to the consequences of National Grid’s decision for the balance and resilience of Scotland’s energy supply. A balanced mix of clean thermal generation progressively fitted with CCS operating alongside renewables is and always has been this Government’s objective. Scotland’s comparative advantage in the generation of renewable electricity is huge—it has 90 per cent of the UK’s hydro capacity, 25 per cent of the European Union’s offshore wind and tidal power potential and 10 per cent of its wave power potential. Renewables now supply almost half of Scotland’s electricity consumption. To ignore that massive resource and squander the economic opportunity of a lifetime would be utterly reckless.
Some members believe that the development of renewables has harmed the prospects of thermal stations. Those arguments are false. They might have carried some credibility if we were in a situation of healthy oversupply, but spare capacity in the Great Britain system will fall to as low as 2 per cent by next winter. The fact that we are even debating Longannet’s future at exactly the point when the UK authorities have allowed energy security to dwindle so severely is a national scandal.
The Scottish Government has pushed National Grid to explain in detail the consequences of Longannet’s closure for Scotland’s energy security and black-start planning. We have still to receive the full details despite two letters from the First Minister to the Prime Minister.
I welcome National Grid’s recent commitment to publish a dedicated capacity assessment for Scotland, but surely we should have had that assessment many years ago.
We must also reflect on how we got to this point. The UK authorities have created an environment in which it is increasingly difficult to operate thermal plant in Scotland. Scotland exported 28 per cent of the power that we generated in 2013 and we want to continue to deliver large amounts of electricity across these islands, but our ability to do so is undermined by a UK framework that penalises Scottish generators and discourages investment.
The location-based transmission charging methodology that was introduced to Scotland in 2005 under a Labour UK Government is the single biggest and most pressing issue. There are, of course, other factors that affect the profitability of all coal-fired generation across Britain, but no other factor uniquely disadvantages Longannet. With 12 per cent of GB electricity generation, Scottish generators pay 35 per cent of the charges. Longannet alone pays over £40 million annually to connect to the grid, whereas similar stations in England and Wales pay much less or may even be paid to connect.
We are told that locational grid charging is designed to discourage the siting of energy generation away from major population centres, but it penalises Longannet, which is, of course, close to the city of Edinburgh and all of central Scotland. Longannet is charged £17.15 per kilowatt whereas generators in Cornwall are paid £5.80 per kilowatt. In Somerset, where Hinkley C will connect, generators are paid £3.94 per kilowatt.
We are coming to the nub of the problem. Scotland has an established policy towards its electricity generation that recognises the need to maintain a balanced mix of generation, but our efforts are frustrated by the UK Government’s unwillingness to address Scottish issues properly. For example, the UK capacity market takes no account of location or the flexibility that is provided by pumped storage. We no longer have a say over the revenue support for renewables under the contracts for difference scheme, even for Scotland-based projects. Our ability to meet our renewables ambitions is severely restricted by the lack of clear and consistent commitments by the UK Government under the levy control framework, and the UK Government has refused to address industry concerns regarding degression rates under the hydro feed-in tariff.
We have made some progress on securing a commitment for support for renewables on the Scottish islands, but there is no firm resolution yet. Transmission charging is inhibiting the construction of the new high-efficiency gas station at Cockenzie, which I consented in 2011, and is also restricting the output at Peterhead.
It is clear that, on a wide range of issues, we remain at the mercy of decisions that are taken in Westminster over which the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government have no control. I am Scotland’s energy minister, but energy policy remains largely a reserved matter. That lack of power over key decisions on energy policy should concern all political parties in Scotland and should prompt some deeper reflection on the future of our energy system.
There will be opportunities to review the energy policy landscape post-May, but our immediate priority—ideally supported by a show of unity across the chamber—must be to avert the premature closure of Longannet.