link
The next petition is PE1531, by Ashley Husband Powton, on removing charitable status from private schools. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. I invite contributions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Private Schools (Charitable Status) (PE1531)
link
The next petition is PE1531, by Ashley Husband Powton, on removing charitable status from private schools. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. I invite contributions from members.
It is clear that as this petition has progressed it has generated quite a bit of debate and flagged up a number of issues regarding state schools.
It is interesting to note, for example, that local authorities have discretion to apply rates relief to non-profit-making organisations such as schools. That may be a way forward, perhaps creating a level playing field for both state and private schools. I believe that the figures would be in the region of £150 million for state-funded schools and around £9 million for independent schools. One report that I read—I think that it was in the Sunday Herald—mentioned a figure of £4 million, but I think that it is probably nearer £9 million for independent schools. State schools clearly deliver a social good, so perhaps they should be entitled to rates relief as well.
Much of the debate has centred on whether private schools deliver a social good. There is an argument to ask the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator to carry out some research on the contribution of private schools, on the basis that OSCR must substantiate that they are delivering a social good. I suggest that we write to OSCR asking it to undertake that research.
I agree with those sentiments. What needs to be established is the fact that there is a social good. If the state schools are looking for rates relief, it is appropriate that we should ask OSCR to give us some guidance and to carry out some work so that we can be better placed to make a decision.
I am interested in that observation. My understanding is that OSCR is currently required to investigate whether a social good is delivered and that it already does so. Many independent schools have been found wanting and have had to correct the level of contribution that they are seen to make.
I do not think that it is a case of challenging OSCR. The Government monitors the work that OSCR does; it seems to be content that OSCR is functioning in the way that was intended—that the legislation is actually operating. I am quite happy for OSCR to be invited to produce a report detailing what it has done and where it thinks it has progressed to.
When we took evidence in the first instance, I floated the idea that rates relief might be extended to state schools and I remain in favour of that. It seems to me to be a perfectly equitable thing. I gather that there are some technicalities with the law concerning how it would have to be managed, but I believe that it could be managed.
I also say that I find the correspondence that we are receiving from the petitioner to be intemperate, lacking in respect for the Parliament and for this committee, and to demonstrate a level of immaturity. I regret that—I have not found it constructive. The letter I have before me from the petitioner this morning is not one that encourages me to think warmly of the approach that has been taken.
Angus MacDonald’s suggestion that charitable status should be extended beyond the independent sector was loftily dismissed by the petitioner when evidence was taken on the first occasion. The suggestion that we extend a broader review of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005 is extraordinary. Some 20,000 charities are involved, and the implications in terms of the time cost and the aims and objectives that would underpin it are not clear.
I am happy with Angus MacDonald’s suggestion that we ask for some sort of report. I am sure that OSCR has already had to make a report, and that if such a report was made available to the committee it would satisfy us that the terms of the 2005 act and the regulations under it are being rigorously enforced. There is evidence for that in comments in the public media about a number of schools that have had to adjust the support that they give.
Some of the evidence that we have received for discussion today has been quite interesting, particularly the submission from the independent schools. However, we seem to be pulling two things together—the definition of private schools versus the definition of independent schools.
I have done some calculations, and based on the letter from the independent schools it works out that some 22.26 per cent of pupils attending independent schools in Scotland receive some form of grant support or funding support. However, part of that calculation takes in the schools, such as Donaldson’s, that provide for pupils with additional support needs. There is quite clearly a need for that type of school provision; local authorities themselves feel that it is more valuable to have specialist support provided for some of those pupils.
10:15
If we write to OSCR and the Scottish Government, could we request that they break down what is meant by independent or private schools in Scotland? Unfortunately, what I consider to be the more charitable elements within the independent school system are lumped together with the rest, which mixes up the message about what we are trying to examine. There are a number of schools that make good provision, and we need to separate out the additional support needs provision and understand that the independent or private school sector is not all the same.
It is not that all schools do not provide valuable services, but there are particular schools in what is called the private or independent sector that are providing valuable services by delivering support to pupils with additional support needs in Scotland. We need to recognise that provision as separate from some of the other arguments that Jackson Carlaw has quite rightly identified in relation to the petitioner’s issues regarding private education in Scotland today. We need to make that distinction: there are two elements of the education system included in the definition of the independent schools sector, and I would like to see them separated out.
We need to be clear that there are 600 pupils or students in the sector who are on full means-tested support when they receive education and others who are receiving some form of bursary support or support from the private education sector itself.
I have a slight confusion about that suggestion. OSCR is required to ensure that any school that has charitable status has demonstrated that, irrespective of its founding principles or definition, it is meeting the test.
I am not sure how interesting it would be to have the number of pupils educated in each sector identified. It would not really mitigate the need for every school to be able to demonstrate that it is fulfilling the obligations in order to be eligible for charitable status. Angus MacDonald’s initial request is one that effectively incorporates OSCR’s judgment of its work in ensuring that the charitable test is fulfilled by every school.
It depends who sets the test and how that test is applied. The petitioner quite clearly identifies that, in her view, the test is not currently sufficient to determine whether some of the schools in the private or independent sector should be receiving charitable status. I think that there are schools that genuinely would meet society’s wider concern about charitable status; some other fee-paying schools that exist in Scotland, however, may be run or operated on a profit basis or a not-for-profit distribution system—
Is that not the responsibility of OSCR? It is not the raison d’être of this committee but of OSCR to ensure that the test is adequately applied.
Under guidance from the Government.
link
OSCR assesses school by school and not across the sector; it assesses every individual school for charitable status, as it does any individual group that hands in its accounts at the end of the year.
Is the committee happy to take forward Angus MacDonald’s recommendations?
Members indicated agreement.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.