To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02674)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 8
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
- James Kelly Lab 1
The record
19 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Official figures published yesterday confirmed that the Scottish National Party Government’s most recent oil revenue estimates for next year are more than 10 times greater than those of the Office for Budget Responsibility. Will the First Minister commit to publishing a revised oil and gas bulletin?
Yes. As John Swinney said a few moments ago in general questions, we will take the time to analyse the fiscal changes that the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced in the budget yesterday. When we have done that we will publish an updated oil and gas bulletin, as soon as is feasible.
It is worth pointing out that, when the Scottish Government was projecting an oil price of $110 a barrel, the OBR was projecting an oil price of $100 a barrel and the United Kingdom Government’s Department of Energy and Climate Change was projecting an oil price of upwards of $120 a barrel, so it is fair to say that everybody’s projections about oil were wrong. [Interruption.]
Order.
The most revealing thing about Labour is how it gleefully pounces on anything that it can describe as bad news and how it steadfastly ignores anything that is good news about Scotland’s economic prospects. The fact is that the projected decline in oil revenues over the next few years is dwarfed in every one of those years by the projected growth in our onshore non-oil revenues. In other words, our country’s revenues are increasing and our public finances are improving. I know that that does not suit Labour’s narrative, but it happens to be a fact.
I am pleased that the First Minister has finally run out of excuses and will publish a new oil and gas bulletin. It is not some dry statistical exercise; it is about the SNP’s key general election demand for full fiscal autonomy within the UK: a plan that would scrap the stability of higher public spending through the Barnett formula and replace it with the austerity max of relying on oil revenues, which are projected in the SNP’s current oil and gas bulletin.
The new OBR figures show something quite extraordinary. They show that, even in the SNP’s most pessimistic scenario, oil and gas revenues are £10 billion more than they are in the OBR’s latest forecast. In the SNP’s preferred scenario, the difference is almost £30 billion—nearly the whole Scottish Government budget.
When the SNP Government published its March 2013 oil and gas bulletin, it did so just five days after the publication of the “Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland” figures for that year, so it should not take too long this time. Will the First Minister confirm that the new oil and gas projections will be published before we meet again here next week?
I have just confirmed, as John Swinney confirmed, that we will publish the updated oil and gas bulletin as soon as possible.
When? When?
Order, Mr Kelly.
Kezia Dugdale takes great glee in declining oil revenues. If we look to the year 2019-20, yes we will see that oil revenues are projected to decrease by £3 billion compared with the revenues in 2013-14, but in that same year our onshore non-oil revenues will increase by £15 billion. Our revenues are growing and our public finances are improving; that does not suit Labour but it is good news for Scotland.
On the wider question, here we have, yet again, the two faces of Labour. In England today, Labour is telling people that Westminster cuts are extreme and will take us back to 1930s levels of public spending. In Scotland, Labour is trying to tell people that Westminster is the saviour of our public spending. Is it any wonder that nobody believes a word that Labour says anymore?
The only cuts on the horizon are cuts proposed by the Tories and voted for by Labour. The only alternative to austerity in Scotland is the SNP.
The First Minister talks about two faces, but this week she was in England, telling people to vote Green, a party that wants to shut down the oil and gas industry. I also point out that I take no glee in these figures, because we are talking about thousands of jobs. I find that comment utterly disrespectful.
The SNP’s plans for full fiscal autonomy rest on an oil price of $110 a barrel, but the OBR has revised down its oil price figures and now projects an oil price next year of more than $40 a barrel lower than the SNP’s figures. That makes the case for having a Scottish office for budget responsibility even stronger than it was. To be frank, I think that the Scottish Government’s figures simply cannot be trusted. Will the First Minister support Scottish Labour’s call for an impartial and independent Scottish financial watchdog?
As Labour knows, we already have one, and this Government is taking steps to put it on a statutory footing. I would have thought that Labour would have welcomed that, but yet again Kezia Dugdale steadfastly refuses—[Interruption.]
Order, James Kelly.
—to acknowledge the estimated growth in our onshore revenues, and that is before we have the additional economic and fiscal powers that would allow us to grow our economy even faster. That is the whole point of not letting Westminster continue to control our finances and taking more control ourselves.
As for how people in England should vote, is it any wonder that people are disillusioned with Labour? Just this morning, Ed Balls, the shadow chancellor, said that there was nothing from George Osborne’s budget yesterday that he would reverse if he became chancellor. There is nothing in the budget of a right-wing Tory chancellor that a new Labour chancellor would choose to reverse. Really? Let me tell you—there is plenty that I would choose to reverse, starting with the austerity cuts that are going to be deeper than anything that we have seen before. I think that Ed Balls has just made our case for us: the only alternative to austerity in Scotland is the SNP.
Last week, the First Minister had to correct the Official Report when she did not tell the truth about how the SNP voted on a key austerity vote in the Commons. I am happy to correct the record, too. Last week, I said that scrapping Barnett would cost Scotland £6.5 billion in spending cuts. I was wrong; the OBR’s oil projections confirm that the cost would, in fact, be £7.6 billion. That is a Barnett bombshell that would mean billions of pounds-worth of cuts—[Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear Ms Dugdale.
Presiding Officer, SNP members are laughing about cuts to our schools and our national health service. They are laughing about cuts to thousands of jobs in Scotland.
Scots appreciate straight talking; what we cannot stand is when our Government tries to cover up the truth about the impact of its policies. When will the First Minister do the decent thing and admit that the SNP’s plans to scrap Barnett would be devastating for Scotland?
Let me tell Kezia Dugdale what will come as a bombshell to people across Scotland today: it is the news that Labour will not reverse any of the Tory cuts that were announced in the budget yesterday.
It might also have come as a bombshell to people in Scotland to hear yesterday Rachel Reeves, one of the Labour Party’s shadow Cabinet, saying that Labour no longer stands for people out of work. These are the things that will come as bombshells to people across Scotland.
For the purposes of the record, let me confirm that the SNP did not vote for the Labour cuts put forward in the motion just over a week ago. The only cuts on the horizon for Scotland are the £30 billion of cuts that Labour voted for a few weeks ago—cuts that were proposed by the Tories and which we know as of this morning will not be reversed by Labour. The only alternative to Tory-Labour austerity cuts in Scotland is the SNP.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 19 Mar 2015 →- Scottish Medicines Consortium (Drug Appraisal Process) Questions · 6
- Physical Activity (Teenage Girls) Questions · 4
- South Glasgow University Hospital (Dermatology) Questions · 4
- “Beef 2020 Report” Questions · 4
- Aberdeen City Region Deal Bid Questions · 6
- Homelessness (Benefit Sanctions) Questions · 4
- Oil and Gas Analytical Bulletin Questions · 4
- Cancer Treatment Referral Waiting Times (NHS Fife) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- United Kingdom Budget (Implications for Scotland) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Racial Discrimination First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fiscal Autonomy First Minister’s Questions · 12
- National Health Service Staff (Confidentiality Clauses) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- European Conference for Cold Water Island Tourism Members’ business · 10
- Health and Social Care Integration Debate · 56
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.