Thank you, convener, and good morning, members.
First, I pass on the Auditor General’s apologies for not being able to make the meeting. I am delighted to be here to present, on her behalf, her report on the roll-out of superfast broadband in Scotland.
Access to superfast broadband is hugely important for homes and businesses across Scotland, particularly in some of our more remote and rural communities. The report looks at progress made in developing a superfast broadband network across the country.
The work on building the network started in 2013, when the Scottish Government and Highlands and Islands Enterprise separately employed BT to build and maintain a superfast broadband network. The network will cost around £412 million over an 11-year period, with the Scottish public sector contributing around £165 million of that. BT is contracted to complete the building work by December 2017.
The report assesses whether the Scottish Government and HIE have in place clear plans and arrangements to build the superfast broadband network; it looks at the aims and objectives of the Scottish Government’s investment programme and the targets that have been set; it looks at the procurement and contract management arrangements; and it looks at what has been delivered to date.
I will summarise briefly the findings in the report under three main headings. First of all, we look at the achievement of the programme’s targets, aims and objectives. The Scottish Government’s stated ambition is to develop a superfast broadband network with the capacity to deliver broadband speeds of between 40 and 80 megabits per second to 85 or 90 per cent of premises in Scotland by the interim target of March 2016, and then to extend that to more than 95 per cent of premises by December 2017. We report that the contracts signed with BT do not guarantee that all users will obtain speeds of more than 40Mbps. Indeed, almost a quarter of premises may need to rely on further technological advances or further investment to achieve speeds in excess of 24Mbps. The Scottish Government and HIE are not yet able to state with certainty what broadband speeds they expect the contracts to deliver, as that cannot be determined until the survey work has been completed.
Secondly, we look at procurement and contract management. As the committee will be aware, BT was the only final bidder for each contract, but we are satisfied that both the Scottish Government and HIE project teams used a variety of approaches to assure themselves that BT’s bids were value for money. That included benchmarking BT’s costs against other United Kingdom broadband projects. The teams found that costs in the rest of Scotland are in line with those other projects, but costs in the Highlands and Islands are higher, which is perhaps not surprising. However, it is difficult to conclude definitively whether the Scottish contracts represent value for money, as BT was also the provider for the other projects across the UK. Contract management arrangements for scrutinising progress are good, although we also say that they are complex, and we have highlighted a risk that project teams may struggle to cope in their busier periods when workloads increase as the projects ramp up or when other demands are placed on them.
Thirdly, we look at the progress that has been made towards achieving the interim milestone, which is in March 2016. As at December of last year, BT was ahead of its contractual targets and, based on our calculations, we conclude that the Scottish Government will achieve its interim target to make broadband available to at least 85 per cent of premises across Scotland by March 2016. That calculation takes into account the fact that BT has exceeded its contractual targets up to December 2014, which is the last data that we looked at. It also assumes that BT will continue at least to meet its contractual targets between now and March 2016.
Finally, I will highlight a couple of key recommendations that the report makes. We recommend that the Scottish Government sets out more clearly what it expects the contracts with BT to deliver, not only in terms of both coverage and speed but to help manage the expectations of households and businesses across the country. We also recommend that the Scottish Government and HIE develop clear plans by June 2015 for the additional investment of £42 million in superfast broadband that was announced in February last year. The plans should balance the need to extend coverage to premises that have been excluded from the work and the need to increase broadband speeds in some premises.
As always, my colleagues and I are very happy to take questions.