Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Proposed Cockenzie Energy Park (PE1537)

Tuesday 3 March 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30 Petitions 17 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The next petition is PE1537, by Shona Brash on behalf of the Coastal Regeneration Alliance, on the proposed energy park at Cockenzie. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions.

I welcome Iain Gray to the meeting. He has a constituency interest in the petition.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

Thank you, convener. I appreciate the opportunity to speak briefly to the petition once again.

The committee will see that the marine energy park project is continuing. That is clear from a number of the submissions from stakeholders, not least that from Scottish Enterprise, which makes it clear that it is deciding on the next steps based on an assessment of market interest, the outcome of on-going technical feasibility work and so on. It is clear that the project continues.

The submissions also make it clear that the petitioners do not feel that they have received the assurances that they sought—or assurances that they can accept—regarding consultation in the future. A lot of the submissions try to suggest that consultation has taken place, in spite of the fact that the petitioners and the petition have made it clear to the committee that the community does not accept that.

It is also clear that the petitioners do not believe that there are indications that proper regard will be given to the community’s aspirations for the site—aspirations that are quite well developed and were presented to the committee when it considered the petition at an earlier stage. The truth is that the community around the site, in Cockenzie and Port Seton, remains very much in the dark as to what is happening. That is what led to the campaign and support for the petition in the first place.

I therefore suggest that the committee continues the petition and further interrogates the situation. The committee could help to provide some clarity for the local community by either continuing the petition and seeking evidence or referring the petition to an appropriate committee. My preference is for the former, but obviously it is for members of the committee to decide. However, I strongly request that the committee considers continuing the petition, as the situation has not resolved itself.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

The issue of energy supply has been in the news agenda for a number of days recently, not least because of the possible need for a large combined cycle gas turbine somewhere in Scotland. The major obstacle to that is the transmission charging regime, which discriminates against new electricity generation in Scotland.

The national planning framework 3 is basically a Government wish list, for want of a better term. There are quite a number of projects in my constituency on that wish list that may or may not come to fruition. I take on board Iain Gray’s point that the Cockenzie energy park project seems to be continuing as far as Scottish Power is concerned, and it is clear that the Coastal Regeneration Alliance is not taking any chances regarding NPF3 not moving the project forward.

Given that the issue of energy generation is hotting up, to coin a phrase, it might be an idea to refer the petition to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. I am not definite about this, but I imagine that it will be doing some significant work on energy supply in the future.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I am happy to support Angus MacDonald’s recommendation, mainly because the issue is in the remit of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. It involves the aspects of energy, the local economy, tourism, historic value and environmental impact. I think that that committee could do a far better job than we could, because the petition falls within its remit.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

Because the issue is of such high significance and people are still working on the project and we do not have the full package, it may be premature to send the petition to another committee. I would rather get all the facts before we make that decision. I am minded perhaps to continue the petition at this early stage and wait to see the final case for what we are trying to achieve before we refer the petition on. There is a lot of information still to come—tasks are still going on—and I would like to see the results first so that we can see what the best way forward is. I am happy to continue the petition.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

I think that there is a way between the two options. It seems to be a fluid situation. Iain Gray is quite correct that there has been almost a democratic deficit, and the Government does appear to have a wish list. It seems that Scottish Power and Scottish Enterprise are operating at a level that is perhaps not taking on board the clear views of the local people. Equally, however, I understand that this is a moveable feast.

Am I correct to say that, if it is not today, it will be any day now that the towers are due to be demolished? I think that I saw that somewhere in my constituency, as it affects the vista.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

It is the towers, not the chimneys.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

Yes. Things are moving there.

It seems to me that to refer the petition to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee would be more appropriate, assuming that it would accept it—it could be remitted back. I do not know whether there is a way of satisfying Hanzala Malik’s concern that the petition be kept alive by giving it to a committee that might be more appropriate, given that it is part of a wider issue, as Angus MacDonald correctly said. However, the petition has highlighted that there is a local democratic deficit that needs to be addressed.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The consensus seems to be that we should refer the petition to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. My understanding is that, even though we are referring it, the petition remains open. Is that right?

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

For clarification, if we refer the petition to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee, it will then rest with that committee to make deliberations on it, and the only information that we will get back from that committee will be about what action it has taken. If the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee decides to close the petition, we will have no further jurisdiction over it.

Hanzala Malik Lab Glasgow
link

That is why I suggested that, initially, we should keep it open to see what new information comes in before we decide to send it on. I do not think that the time is right for it to be sent on as it stands. Local concerns need to be addressed. Let us allow that to happen. It will not do any harm to keep it open at this stage.

Iain Gray Lab East Lothian
link

I appreciate that there is a consensus among committee members that the petition should not be closed but should be continued. That is welcome. I said that it is, of course, for the committee to decide how to deal with the petition, but I also said that my preference would be for the committee to take evidence. Perhaps it is worth while for me to explain my reason for that.

The thrust of the petition is about the reluctance of the local community to have an industrial development of such a scale foisted upon them. That is how it feels to them. It is more about what happens to the site and to their community than about the potential importance for Scotland’s energy strategy of an energy park at that site or another site. There seems to be some merit in continuing to explore the nature of the consultation and how things have been taken forward before the petition is referred on. However, I defer to the committee. It is the committee’s decision.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Okay. What action do we want to take, colleagues?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Given the comments by the local member, if there is concern about referring the petition to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee immediately, I would be content to seek further information from Scottish Enterprise and East Lothian Council and to request that the public consultations on the development be extended. However, that would be with the proviso that, ultimately, the petition will be referred to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee for further investigation.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

We might be able to take some informal soundings from the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. Notwithstanding the legitimate comments that Iain Gray made, it appears to me that consideration by that committee would be more appropriate because, although the petition is site specific, it is likely to have more general relevance. We need to balance projects on the Government’s wish list and consider not just the site that concerns the petitioners but other sites in Angus MacDonald’s constituency and elsewhere, so the Economy, Energy and Tourism committee would be more effective than we would.

However, I understand John Wilson’s point that there is no point in us remitting the petition to that committee if it then says that it is too busy to do anything. The worst situation for Iain Gray’s constituents would be for nothing to happen because we had got rid of the petition but the other committee did not accept it.

As Angus MacDonald said, we could seek further information and make some discreet inquiries about the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee. I tend to agree with him that that committee is likely to be looking at energy in the round, and it could consider the petition as a factor within that wider remit, which would be more appropriate than a standalone investigation by us. If we keep the petition going for a few weeks pending a letter to Scottish Enterprise and some informal discussions, that would be a suitable course of action.

10:30

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I agree with Kenny MacAskill that we should keep the petition open and write to East Lothian Council and Scottish Enterprise to find out what is happening.

As Angus MacDonald pointed out, NPF3 is, like NPF1 and NPF2, a wish list developed by the Scottish Government. It has allocated no actual funding to the proposals, and whether they go ahead is down to local circumstances and arrangements. It would therefore be useful to write to those two agencies to get some clarification about exactly where they are in the process. After all, although Scottish Power is the main operator of Cockenzie, it has indicated in its response that it has had no negotiations or discussions about taking forward the power plant in any shape or form or about being involved in the energy park.

In seeking clarification from those two agencies, however, we also need to ask for a clear outline of the consultations that they intend to undertake with the local community in relation to any proposals for the site and to ensure that there are guarantees that the community has the right that it has always had to object to any proposals. I hope that, if the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill goes through in the first half of the year, the community will have greater powers under that legislation to challenge any such proposals and, indeed, to come up with its own, as it did at the end of last year.

I therefore propose that we write to those two agencies. As Kenny MacAskill suggested, our committee clerks could have an informal word with the clerks to the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee to find out whether that committee has time in its calendar to devote to what we think should be considerable consideration of the petition.

John Pentland Lab The Convener · Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Do we agree to write to Scottish Enterprise and East Lothian Council to request that public consultation on the proposed development be extended and to take into account the points that committee members have raised?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 10:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  2. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  3. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 25
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 13
  5. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 26

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.