We recommence with item 4, under which we will take evidence from three experts on borrowing powers. I welcome Professor David Bell, professor of economics at the University of Stirling, Don Peebles, head of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy in Scotland, and Philip Milburn, investment manager at Kames Capital, representing the Investment Association.
We have timed this session to last until about half past 10. To get through things in a structured way, I think that we should look at three aspects: the principles that will underpin the framework to enable borrowing by a subnational Government and any specific challenges around that; further powers on revenue borrowing and capital borrowing and what the appropriate mix would be; and the overall fiscal framework and the institutional bits that will underpin it all. If we concentrate on those three areas, we can probably get through what we need to cover.
Members may direct some questions to an individual witness, but most questions will be addressed to everyone on the panel. I am grateful to the witnesses for coming along today to give us evidence that will help us in coming to our conclusions.
I begin with a general question. The UK command paper containing the draft clauses is relatively silent on the borrowing powers that are to be devolved, indicating that that is a matter for agreement between the UK and Scottish Governments. Do the witnesses consider that legislation should be required in order to devolve powers in that area? In any case, what principles or structures should underpin the devolution of borrowing powers? That is for all three witnesses; I do not mind who kicks off.
