Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Plant Health Fees (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2005 (SSI 2005/555) Less Favoured Area Support Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2005 (SSI 2005/569)

Wednesday 7 December 2005 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 37 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

37 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

For agenda item 3, we have two instruments to consider under the negative procedure. We discussed the instruments last week and the committee decided to defer consideration of them to allow the minister to get back to us on a number of issues that members raised. We have received a response from the minister, which has been circulated.Do members have any comments on the plant health fees instrument? Elaine Smith raised particular questions: are you happy with the minister's response?

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I was able to read it only on the internet last night—I was not able to print it—but I think that it answers most of the questions. I remain slightly concerned about illegal imports, although I believe that that issue has been touched on. However, I accept most of the minister's answers. We should move on with the instrument.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Do any other members wish to comment on the plant health instrument?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The second instrument to be considered under the negative procedure concerns the less favoured area support scheme. Both Rob Gibson and Alasdair Morrison raised issues last week. Are you happy with the minister's response?

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

The last section in Ross Finnie's letter is headed "Information on payments of agricultural subsidies".At least two members of the committee have suggested that such information should be available to the public. The second last sentence in the section is:"Our position is different from that taken by DEFRA because of different views on the requirements of the Data Protection Act".The Data Protection Act 1998 is United Kingdom legislation and is applicable to all parts of the United Kingdom. I am not sure how a sub-state Government can take a different view from the national sovereign Government.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Rob, you also raised the question last week. Do you have any thoughts, having seen the minister's letter?

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Indeed. At our meeting of 12 January, Ross Finnie said: "We have not yet come to a view on what is the most appropriate way in which to do that, as we have not been able to discuss the matter as yet with the relevant people."—Official Report, Environment and Rural Development Committee, 12 January 2005; c 1479. My question on the letter relates to the first paragraph of the section that is headed, "Information on payments of agricultural subsidies", in which the minister says:"I announced last January that we would be releasing subsidy information on the new Single Farm Payment and the new Rural Development Regulation schemes. We expect to be doing that shortly after payments commence, probably early January 2006."Although the LFASS payments seem to fall within the rural development regulation schemes, I would like to have that confirmed. I would also like the minister to confirm that, in the light of what he said last January, publication will be per applicant and not by parish as was the case in the past. Despite the minister's letter, I still do not have a clear answer to the question.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Okay. After we received the letter from the minister, Mark Brough, our clerk, went back to the Executive to ask for further clarification. I ask him to bring us up to speed on the Executive view.

Mark Brough Clerk
link

The explanation that I got from officials is that a distinction is made between past subsidy information and that which will apply to future schemes. The Executive's position is that it is not appropriate to identify subsidy information for individual past claims because applicants were not forewarned that their details would be used in that way.However, officials confirmed that information on individual payments under the new single farm payment scheme and the rural development regulation schemes—which include the land management contracts—will be published from January 2006 when the payments begin. Applicants to those schemes will be forewarned that their details will be used in that way. Officials also said that no decision has yet been taken on how that will apply to the less favoured area support scheme.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In other words, the minister did not answer our question clearly. We are mystified—or at least I am—as to why we are still unable to access individual information a year on from when the minister appeared before the committee. We should find out why. It would be a dereliction of our duty for us to pass this SSI before we have that information. We ought to have the information, especially if DEFRA can release it.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

That reinforces my point. How can the Scottish Executive—a sub-state Government—take a different interpretation of UK legislation? The information that the Executive has given us does not answer the question why the Data Protection Act 1998 is being interpreted and applied in England and Wales differently from in Scotland.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Mark Brough is just whispering in my ear that the freedom of information commissioner has been asked to determine whether information can be released under the LFASS. Is that for past or future schemes?

Mark Brough Clerk
link

We are not 100 per cent sure.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We know that the issue is with the freedom of information commissioner. Ross Finnie's letter does not comment on that, so we do not have the Executive's view on the matter.We are in a difficult position. Today is the last day when we can make our report on the regulations to the Parliament. We stretched out the process to try to get more information from the minister. However, we do not want to stop the passage of the regulations because that would stop payments under the scheme.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

The convener is correct; that is the responsible position to adopt.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Right. It may not be desirable for us to stop the regulations. Mark Brough has just informed me that another LFASS instrument will come before us in the next few weeks, which gives us the potential to return to the issue when that instrument appears on our agenda.I think that members want to record our general sense that the information should be in the public domain. I think that we also want to say that we cannot understand why interpretation of UK legislation should be different in Scotland from interpretation in England and Wales. I propose that we pass those comments to the minister and say that, given that we have been waiting for such a long time for a direct answer on the matter, we hope that it will be clarified before the next LFASS regulations come before the committee. Are colleagues happy with that interpretation of our views?

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

Yes, but with the caveat that the matter might never be determined until there is some case law. Such legislation is subject to interpretation, which is firmed up by court judgments.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

My difficulty with the minister's response is that I do not know why UK legislation is being interpreted differently—

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

Perhaps because it has not been challenged in court there is no case law and therefore no judgment by the courts on which interpretation is correct.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The minister says:"Our position is different from that taken by DEFRA because of different views on the requirements of the Data Protection Act regarding the processing of personal information."What Nora Radcliffe said does not really answer that point.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

I can see how the situation can arise, but I do not know how it can be resolved.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We are talking about a policy issue that centres on how legislation should be interpreted. Any challenge to the interpretation would result in case law. However, the minister seems to be saying that DEFRA and SEERAD hold different views on how the Data Protection Act 1998 should apply in this case.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

But the civil servants who are involved are all members of the same body.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

From what the minister has told us and from what we know of the current position, I do not think that we can interpret anything. We have not received the clarity on the LFASS that we really wanted after what happened last week. The response provides extra information on the single farm payment and new rural development regulation schemes, but we received all that last January. We now know that when payments commence in January 2006, that information will be made public, but we do not have any information on the LFASS.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I wonder whether it would be appropriate to write to the Scottish information commissioner for an estimate of when there will be a determination on the case; if it is made in the next couple of weeks, it might well inform debates on the Scottish statutory instruments that will be laid before Christmas. However, if the determination is some way off, it will be some time before we get the information.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

One fundamental point should be highlighted. We are talking about different interpretations of UK legislation in different parts of the UK. It would be unthinkable for the Treasury and Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs to apply taxation laws differently in Scotland or, indeed, for legislation relating to road traffic offences or the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency to have a different application here. The involvement of the information commissioner is a separate although important issue; the main issue is interpretations of legislation by the same civil service in the UK.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I do not think that we can go much beyond—

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

I am sorry, convener—I wanted to say that you have outlined the correct and responsible approach to take. We should not delay things. The payments have to be made, but we need clarification on Mr Finnie's letter.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is what I have proposed. We can certainly find out from the information commissioner how long any determination is likely to take.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Last January, Ross Finnie said:"we are not entirely clear on the matter, because of the way in which the regulations are worded—indeed, our lawyers are wrestling with that problem."—Official Report, Environment and Rural Development Committee, 12 January 2005; c 1478.We should make it clear to the information commissioner and the minister that the lawyers have been wrestling with the determination for far too long.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That particular interpretation issue, which was more to do with the rural development regulation schemes, has been clarified. The outstanding issue concerns the LFASS.I think that we are all of one mind on the matter: we will raise our points with the minister, and expect responses to them. After all, the issue has been outstanding for an incredibly long time.Notwithstanding those comments on the LFASS, are members content with the instruments and happy to make no recommendation on them to Parliament?

Members indicated agreement.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the minister to come to the table for item 4.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 7 December 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 3
  3. Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 201
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 37
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
  6. Animal Welfare Bill Bill debate · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.