Thank you, cabinet secretary, and thank you, committee, for inviting me to attend today. I welcome the opportunity to explain our position.
Historic Scotland recognises that the Tinkers’ Heart is of significant cultural heritage interest. We have been positive and supportive since the case was brought to our attention in 2012. For example, we have ensured that the site is properly recorded, we have attended local meetings and we have involved Archaeology Scotland’s adopt-a-monument scheme, which we part fund.
The petition calls for the preservation and the restoration of the Heart, with the implication that it should be laid out in good order for visitors as a physical reminder of the important contribution of the Traveller community to Scotland’s history. We would be supportive of such an initiative. However, Historic Scotland can do little to change the situation. We have been called on to schedule the site, but that would not achieve the petition’s aims. Those can be achieved only by constructive dialogue and the co-operation of the site’s owner and the local community. The chair of the local group—Here We Are—says that the community is well aware that the Heart is a special site, but that it and the owner want it to be preserved as it is. The newly installed fence means that the Heart is protected from cattle damage, which was previously a concern. Historic Scotland can and does encourage co-operation, but as the cabinet secretary said, we cannot enforce it.
On scheduling, there are more than 300,000 recorded monuments in Scotland, of which only about 3 to 5 per cent are scheduled, depending on what part of Scotland you are in. We take seriously the strength of concern about our decision not to schedule the Heart, as well as this committee’s strong interest. We are very aware that the monument is associated with, and is especially important to, a marginalised and underrepresented group in Scottish society. Many monuments do not meet scheduling criteria. However, few—if any—have challenged us as this one has.
Just before Christmas, John Finnie MSP asked several questions in Parliament about equalities issues, and asked specifically about whether an equalities impact assessment should have been undertaken when assessing the Tinkers’ Heart for scheduling. In view of the exceptional circumstances that pertain in this case, we consider that an equalities impact assessment of the Tinkers’ Heart decision should have been undertaken. Such assessments should not be carried out retrospectively, so we have decided to set aside our earlier decision and to start again with a fresh team. I cannot prejudge the reassessment’s outcome, and it is important not to raise expectations, but that is the right way forward.
We will inform all those who have an interest in the site of our intention to revisit the case. I would be happy to report back to the committee on progress in that work. We expect the scheduling reassessment to take three to six months, so I will be in a position to provide a progress update in June 2015.
I hope that the committee will agree that that course of action responds to at least some of the public and this committee’s concerns. We remain ready to help in whatever way we can.