We have carried out two surveys, one this year and one two years ago. This year we discovered that we have lost 109 computing teachers over the last two years, so that we are now down to about 650 computing teachers in Scotland for secondary schools. That equates to a 14 per cent drop. In the five years before that, we lost 100 teachers. That is, we have had a drop of 100 teachers over five years and then another 109 teachers over the last two years. That means that 12 per cent of our secondary schools in Scotland do not have a computing teacher at all.
When we asked schools why they do not have a computing teacher and how they are teaching the curriculum if they do not have a computing teacher, many respondents were confused about the difference between ICT and computing. They said that they were teaching ICT across the curriculum. ICT should be taught across the curriculum, but ICT is about how to use the technology and about the use of technology within teaching. It is about how to use iPads or laptops or phones. We are concerned that we are not teaching how to programme those devices. We are not teaching how they work. We are not teaching computational thinking, the core skills of understanding processes, methods and modelling.
In terms of the numbers staying relatively static, we have been hit fairly hard by the changes from standard grades to national 5 qualifications. Pupils were generally taking seven or eight standard grades, but they generally take five or maybe six national 5s. That reduces their subject choices. Their column choices tend to be maths, English, a modern language and a science, and then there is a column of everything else. Although it is a rigorous academic subject, computing science is generally bundled in with practical subjects. For example, at one school it was competing with cake decorating and car mechanics. Those are valid subjects, but they are neither rigorous academic subjects nor scientific subjects.
We are finding that there is a lack of computing teachers in the system. We are not getting enough computing teachers trained up, which is one of our problems. Ten out of 32 local authorities said that they were having problems recruiting computing teachers. Teacher training is happening only in Glasgow now, where the universities of Glasgow and Strathclyde offer professional graduate diplomas in education in computing. We are not reaching our target. This year there are only 21 student teachers training as computing teachers, plus two at the University of Stirling each year. That does not reach our target, and it does not even reach the extended cap that the universities were allowed. We are not getting enough teachers into the system, which is then causing problems with recruitment.
10:45
So far, the numbers have been staying relatively steady for higher computing each year, but we need to train a massive number of further teachers. ScotlandIS, our industry body for information technology in Scotland, is saying that we need to train up more computing teachers, that we need to train up more people in computing and that we need to get more people through university, so that we get more people into the IT industry. If we could get tens of thousands more people into our industry, our economy could boom. At the moment, however, there are not enough people coming through to meet the demands of the industry.
ScotlandIS is carrying out an annual industry survey this month. Seventy per cent of the respondents to last year’s survey said that they were planning on recruiting but were struggling to get staff, or they were having to go outwith Scotland to get new members of staff.