Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I welcome our witnesses and those who have joined us in the public gallery as visitors. I ask that everyone ensure that their mobile phones and other electronic devices are switched off, so that they do not interfere with the broadcasting system.
We have received one apology, from Alison Johnstone.
Agenda item 1 is evidence from business organisations on the Smith commission’s proposals. I will introduce the witnesses from left to right—I hope that I get the details right. Stuart Patrick is the chief executive of Glasgow Chamber of Commerce; Alan Watt is the chief executive of the Civil Engineering Contractors Association; Ross Martin is the chief executive of the Scottish Council for Development and Industry; and David Watt is the regional director for the Institute of Directors. We are very glad that you are here. The focus may not be on the committee this morning given what else is going on, such as the publication of the draft clauses, but we think that you are the most important visitors to Parliament.
I will quickly summarise the meeting’s structure. We will keep the evidence session as informal as we can, although I ask that everyone speak through the chair. We have four witnesses, so I ask that committee members make their questions as concise as possible. It would help if the answers were concise, too. We will start with questions on taxation and borrowing and then move on to welfare questions before we sweep up any other important matters. I will address my questions to all the panellists, and I think that most members will do that, too. If you want to contribute, please indicate that to me. Committee members may want to ask specific questions of specific individuals, but we will see how it goes.
To begin, I will ask a general question. I want to understand the extent to which the Smith commission proposals constitute, in your eyes, a set of powers that should enable the Scottish Government to create conditions that would improve the performance of the Scottish economy and create jobs. Has the Smith commission helped in that regard, or could other things have been done? I do not mind who kicks off. Ross Martin looks like he is ready to go.
