I will come back on that. As you say, one of our functions is to make recommendations to ministers and we have made various recommendations to them about mostly technical aspects of the 2005 act.
The charity test is fit for purpose; it is operable. As you say, a number of the independent schools failed the charity test first time round. The act gave us the power to do something about the situation and we did something about it. The schools complied with the directions that we made. The test works.
As a regulator, we work with the laws that we are given. If there is a wider social and political view that particular institutions should not be charities, there should be specific provision in the test about those. That is a matter for Parliament or for ministers. We can work with the test that we have.
To come back on the wider issue, you talk about all types of organisations and not just schools becoming charities just for the benefits. Yes, that is correct, but it is perhaps worth thinking through what that means. Why do bodies become charities? Some will become charities because it is the difference between being able to operate and not being able to operate. For example, certain funders will give funding only to bodies that are charities, because charitable status gives funders the reassurance about governance and accountability that they want. For others, it may be about reassuring the public that they are not for profit and that they have what people call the charity brand.
We deal with getting on for 1,000 applications for new charities every year. That will be because those bodies regard that as being an advantage rather than a disadvantage to them.