We now move to First Minister’s question time. Question 1 is from Kezia Dugdale. [Applause.]
1.
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
We now move to First Minister’s question time. Question 1 is from Kezia Dugdale. [Applause.]
1.
I take this opportunity to wish the Presiding Officer and all members a merry Christmas and a very happy and prosperous new year.
To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02483)
I congratulate Kezia Dugdale on her election as deputy leader of Scottish Labour. I warmly welcome her to her place and I, too, wish everybody a very merry Christmas.
On a more sombre note, at the end of a week in which we have witnessed horrific acts of terror around the world, I take the opportunity—I am sure on behalf of all of us—to send condolences to the people of Australia and, of course, the people of Pakistan. Our thoughts are very much with them at this time.
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I associate myself with the First Minister’s remarks and think that all members would agree with them. Our condolences go to the people of Pakistan and all those here in Scotland who have family there and are feeling the pain at this time.
There is a crisis in the oil industry. The unions and the companies say so. The Wood Group, Shell, BP and Petrofac are all cutting wages. A thousand jobs have gone and thousands more are on the line. What is the Scottish Government going to do?
I thank Kezia Dugdale for raising an issue that is very important and is of great concern to the people who work in our oil and gas industry. I will answer the question briefly, in two parts.
First, in terms of the Scottish Government’s responsibilities, we will continue to do what we are doing to support innovation—for example, through our £10 million funding for the Oil and Gas Innovation Centre. We will continue to support skills in the industry and have invested an additional £6.5 million in that.
We have, of course, published the energy skills investment plan, and we will look to refresh it and ensure that it is fit for purpose. We will also continue to ring fence 500 modern apprenticeships for the energy sector in each year of the current session of Parliament.
The second part of my answer—I hope that we can achieve some unity in the chamber on this—is that we will support the industry in its calls to the United Kingdom Government for more action. I will highlight three things that it is calling for. It wants bolder action on reducing the supplementary charge, urgent action on the proposed new investment allowance, and support for exploration. That is what the industry wants, and I hope that we can all get behind it.
The First Minister will have Labour’s support when she goes to the UK Government with her calls, but she must be reminded that she has at least six responsibilities to the oil and gas industry in Scotland. She mentioned skills and innovation, but she also has responsibility for onshore business taxes, support in finding new markets, supporting infrastructure and diversifying the industry. Therefore, the same old answers about looking to Westminster for solutions just do not stack up.
The industry is one of Scotland’s key industries. Yesterday, Jake Molloy of the RMT said:
“We’re on the brink of meltdown.”
Robin Allan of Premier Oil said that the North Sea oil industry is “close to collapse”. Of course the UK Government should respond quickly, but the Scottish Government has to work with unions and the industry to find ways to maintain employment levels right now. What assurances can the First Minister give oil workers and their families about their jobs? Some 300,000 jobs across Scotland and the UK are reliant on the industry. What security do they have this Christmas from the Government?
I hope that the words that we have been hearing from Kezia Dugdale and her colleagues in recent days about a new consensual approach can survive beyond her first First Minister’s questions. [Interruption.]
Order.
I have said at every FMQs that I am keen to work across party boundaries. Kezia Dugdale is correct that this is an important issue. She asked specifically about actions that we will take and I gave her some of the specifics. We will continue to support the industry in every way that we can. I will meet Malcolm Webb of Oil & Gas UK on 14 January. Some of what I called on the UK Government to do did not come simply from the Scottish Government or the Scottish National Party—I cited some things from a letter to me from Oil & Gas UK. I should say that, in that same letter, Oil & Gas UK talks about its good relationship with ministers in the Scottish Government. That good relationship and the determination to support the industry will continue strongly in my time as First Minister.
In the interests of the consensus that I am genuinely keen to build, if there are specific proposals that any other party wants to bring forward, it should do so, but it should make them specific so that we can give them the serious consideration that we would want to give.
The First Minister mentioned Oil & Gas UK, which told her that production and prices were falling, yet she persisted with her predictions on oil prices. [Interruption.]
Order.
This week, oil dropped to below $60 a barrel. In today’s papers, John Swinney says that it will be back up to $110 a barrel by next year, while Professor Ronald MacDonald says that a fall to $40 is “not ... unreasonable”. Just imagine for a second that the world-leading economist Ronald MacDonald knows more about the issue than John Swinney does. That fall would be catastrophic for the North Sea oil industry.
Here we go. Same old, same old.
Mr Swinney!
Let us look to the future. Has the Scottish Government done an assessment of the long-term impact of the falling oil price and, if so, will it be published?
We will continue to work with the industry and to do the work that is required to support it. [Interruption.]
Order! Ms Marra!
Probably not a week goes by in which Fergus Ewing does not meet companies that are active in the North Sea oil and gas sector. Perhaps fairly early in Kezia Dugdale’s tenure as deputy leader of Scottish Labour, she will also take time to meet those companies.
I have.
I am glad to hear it. In that case, we can try to build some consensus on the things that they want us to do.
On the comments about John Swinney and oil experts, I point out to Kezia Dugdale that the price of $110 a barrel comes from the recently published “World Oil Outlook” by the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, which projects a nominal price of $110 until the year 2020. That is where the prediction comes from. [Interruption.]
Order.
I repeat the point that, in the weeks, months and perhaps years to come, we can, and I am pretty sure we will, have vigorous political debates across the chamber about this and other issues, but I thought that Kezia Dugdale started in the right tone today when she rightly put the focus on jobs and the future of an important industry. I want to work with that industry and with members across the chamber—if they are willing to support the industry. I invite others to be part of that effort.
This is the First Minister who is so in touch with the oil industry that she was in Shetland four months ago promising a second oil boom. Four days ago, her energy minister was in Aberdeen rightly pleading with oil companies not to pay off their workers this Christmas. Two weeks ago, I was in Aberdeen talking to the ASET International Oil & Gas Training Academy, which is desperate for support from the Government in order to invest in skills and ensure that if the oil price rises again we will still have the people to make the most of that.
Is it not the truth that the Scottish Government just did not see this crisis coming, because it believed its own wishful thinking about oil prices? Surely we cannot have a First Minister who is so unprepared and unsighted on such a key industry. Will she initiate an inquiry into why her Government was so wrong in the past, so that we can get this right in the future? [Interruption.]
Order.
There are tens of thousands of jobs on the line. The First Minister needs to be able to tell the Scottish public why she got it so wrong in the past, so that she can get it right in the future, does she not?
I think that it was at least two years ago that we re-established the energy skills academy, so determined were we to support skills in the sector. In my—I think—first answer to Kezia Dugdale, I outlined the support that we are giving for skills development in the sector. The industry will get the support that it needs from the Scottish Government for skills development, as it will do for innovation.
Let me come back to what I think is the central issue. I will keep trying to find this note of consensus. The industry wants us to unite to call on the UK Government to accelerate action around the new investment allowance and it wants us to unite to call on the UK Government to increase support for exploration. I think that we should also call on the UK Government to take more action around reducing the supplementary charge. A couple of weeks ago, Danny Alexander talked about reducing it from 32 per cent to 30 per cent, which is welcome. What he did not talk quite so much about was the fact that it was, in the first place, he who increased it from 20 per cent to 32 per cent.
Let us come together to call for the sensible action that the people in the industry want. Those whose jobs are under threat right now will want to see us coming together in that way, and not having a party-political ding-dong.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.