Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll (PE1523)

Tuesday 9 December 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 11:30–12:00 Petitions 20 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

20 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The next petition is PE1523, by Jess Smith, on giving the Tinkers’ Heart of Argyll back to Travelling people. Members will have a note by the clerk and the submissions, including the recent letter that we received from Ms Ramsay.

I welcome to the meeting Mike Russell, the constituency MSP, who has taken great interest in the petition, and I ask him to make a brief opening statement to the committee.

12:00

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Convener, I am sorry that Jess Smith is not here. She is otherwise engaged but she is grateful for the interest that the committee has shown and the work that has been done. However, I should also say that she is disappointed with the progress that has been made to date, as am I.

I will quote from a letter that I received last week. I am not at liberty to say from whom I received it, but it was somebody in the heritage sector. The letter, which really gets to the nub of the problem, states:

“Although no one knows the origins of Scottish Travellers for sure, they have been part of Scotland’s history and story for hundreds of years, playing an important role as armourers to the clans, as bringers of news and useful items to rural communities across Scotland and today as the keepers of oral traditions that were once all of ours, but which have become largely lost in our world so dominated by technology. Their story is an important one within the story of Scotland. As Historic Scotland aims to preserve historic sites that help to tell the story of the people who have lived in Scotland over the past 10,000 years, by leaving Travellers out of this history the story of Scotland cannot be complete and an opportunity to recognise the contribution of this community is missed. It also adds to the cycle of discrimination in which Travellers are not visible within the telling of our history and this vacuum allows negative attitudes to this community to flourish unchecked.”

Regrettably, that is what lies at the heart of Historic Scotland’s response. It has not grasped the importance of the issue. If its procedures are such that it cannot properly recognise the only site associated with the Travelling people across Scotland, those procedures need to change.

I am also disappointed because I am unaware of any substantive response from the landowner. Am I correct in assuming that?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There has been nothing at all.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

That is extremely disappointing. As a public body, Historic Scotland is bound to respond, even if it does not do so adequately. For the landowner to ignore this Parliament, just as she has ignored the petitioners, is disgraceful. In the circumstances, there is much unfinished business with the petition, which has received more than 1,000 signatures and generated an enormous amount of public interest. I shall certainly continue to back Jess Smith and those who work with her to ensure that that tiny spot of ground is given proper recognition and that we can include the Travelling people of Scotland as we tell our story and move forward as a nation.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that submission. What would be useful in taking the petition on to the next stage?

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Three things would be helpful. The first thing is to remind the landowner that, whatever her view, she is not above the democratically elected representatives of the Scottish people. The second thing is to return to Historic Scotland and the minister to question their position on the intangible cultural heritage, to question the procedures that they are following for scheduling monuments, and to see from them a solution to the issue. There might be solutions other than scheduling, but we need a solution that achieves the end that is sought, which is the site’s proper preservation. At the moment, the site is not properly preserved; when I drove past it this morning, in the grey, wet light of an Argyll dawn, I saw that it had a metal container around it and nothing else. It needs proper signage and proper parking, and it needs to have attention drawn to it.

The third thing is something that I know Jess Smith would welcome, although it might not be possible for the whole committee. If the convener, as a Highlands and Islands MSP, were to visit the Heart, I am sure that Jess Smith would be there to welcome him to it, and such a visit would also draw attention to the fact that the Parliament is determined to do something to recognise the heritage of the Travelling people of Scotland.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The clerk has advised me that the landowner rang the clerks to speak to them. She knows that she has been invited to write to the committee, but she has not done so yet, and I hope that we will get a written submission.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I will suspend my criticism until we see the letter, but if the letter went to her, as it did, timeously at the end of September or beginning of October, she must be gey busy if she cannot reply in that time.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I welcome Mr Russell’s contribution to the discussion. The Travelling people and tinkers have made an important contribution to the history of Scotland, and the Tinkers’ Heart plays an important role in that heritage.

For me, the issue goes back to the issue of land ownership. We received a useful submission from Councillor Robert Macintyre. In the third paragraph of his submission, he says:

“I can confirm that in a minute of a meeting of Argyll County Council held in April 1969 there is record of a decision made that an area of ground at this location shall cease to be a highway within the meaning and for the purpose of Section 42 of the Roads and Bridges (Scotland) Act 1878.”

Would it be possible to get clarification of the question of whether that means that the land reverted back to the private landowner? If the site was part of a public highway, why the land reverted back to a private landowner is beyond me. That raises issues about the suggestion that, as Jess Smith indicated previously, the site of the Heart and the access route to the Heart were public-access land. There is an issue about land ownership and whether the landowner who now claims ownership of the land has title to the land.

I think that, if possible, every committee member should act on Michael Russell’s suggestion that they visit the site. It is not only this site that is under threat; the issue affects a number of sites across Scotland.

The submission from Historic Scotland of 3 November says:

“under the terms of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979, scheduling does not provide any specific onus on an owner to care for or provide interpretation for a monument”.

I hope that the committee will write to Historic Scotland to ask whether there needs to be a change to the act to ensure that the appropriate protection of these sites is put in place, particularly with regard to monuments that are on private land. As Jess Smith says, the landowner can do whatever she wants with the land, and has been doing so, up until recently, when the fence was erected around the site. We need to ensure that monuments such as this one are protected and we need to state that we see the value in protecting them.

We should write to Historic Scotland to ask whether it intends to introduce legislation that would amend the 1979 act to ensure that we get appropriate protection for sites that are on private land.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I believe that Mr Wilson’s suggestions are competent. With regard to the first one, about roads, we should write to Argyll and Bute Council and ask for a comment on that from its director of legal services.

Do members have views?

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I thank Mr Russell for his presentation, and I would also like to take up the offer to see the Tinkers’ Heart. However, I am concerned about Historic Scotland’s reply. It worries me that, although this is Scotland’s only site of this nature, the issue does not seem to be being taken seriously. Can we meet representatives of Historic Scotland to discuss the matter further?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We can certainly invite representatives from Historic Scotland to appear before us in the new year, if the committee is willing. I am sure that we can invite Mr Russell to come along on that day, too. That will make for an interesting meeting.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

If we are going to invite Historic Scotland, could we invite the Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Europe and External Affairs to the same meeting, so that we get the Government and Historic Scotland speaking from the same page?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I am happy to go with the recommendations that have been made so far.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh Eastern
link

I think that there are two issues. The first is land ownership. Land ownership brings rights, but it also brings responsibilities. It is therefore disappointing that the landowner has not taken the opportunity to write to us. We should perhaps pursue the roads issue with Argyll and Bute Council, but it seems to me that someone owns the land, and that those who have a vested interest in the site, whether through their statutory responsibilities or their ownership of it, should do that bit more in relation to the site.

Equally, on the historical aspect, I think that it is appropriate to push Historic Scotland on the issue. The community that we are dealing with might be marginal, but it is part of Scotland’s historical tapestry, as Michael Russell said.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As you have heard, Mr Russell, we are very enthusiastic about the petition. We are going to invite Historic Scotland and the cabinet secretary to appear before us, and we will write to Argyll and Bute Council to check out the legalities involved. We will also send a gentle reminder to the owner to give us a written submission. In addition, we will write to Historic Scotland to try to get the heritage criteria correct, because they currently do not seem fit for purpose. Are members happy with that comprehensive approach?

Members indicated agreement.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

Those will be excellent developments. I should have mentioned my gratitude to Argyll and Bute Council for responding positively. Historic Scotland is of course going into a new incarnation and, with new management, it might have a more comprehensive view of what Scotland’s heritage is, which would be great.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Mike Russell for coming along today.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 2
  2. 10:00 Deputy Convener Procedure · 3
  3. 10:00 Current Petition Petitions · 58
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 33
  5. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 34
  6. 11:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  7. 11:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 20
  8. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 12:00 Tackling Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Committee business · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.