I welcome Mr Russell’s contribution to the discussion. The Travelling people and tinkers have made an important contribution to the history of Scotland, and the Tinkers’ Heart plays an important role in that heritage.
For me, the issue goes back to the issue of land ownership. We received a useful submission from Councillor Robert Macintyre. In the third paragraph of his submission, he says:
“I can confirm that in a minute of a meeting of Argyll County Council held in April 1969 there is record of a decision made that an area of ground at this location shall cease to be a highway within the meaning and for the purpose of Section 42 of the Roads and Bridges (Scotland) Act 1878.”
Would it be possible to get clarification of the question of whether that means that the land reverted back to the private landowner? If the site was part of a public highway, why the land reverted back to a private landowner is beyond me. That raises issues about the suggestion that, as Jess Smith indicated previously, the site of the Heart and the access route to the Heart were public-access land. There is an issue about land ownership and whether the landowner who now claims ownership of the land has title to the land.
I think that, if possible, every committee member should act on Michael Russell’s suggestion that they visit the site. It is not only this site that is under threat; the issue affects a number of sites across Scotland.
The submission from Historic Scotland of 3 November says:
“under the terms of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979, scheduling does not provide any specific onus on an owner to care for or provide interpretation for a monument”.
I hope that the committee will write to Historic Scotland to ask whether there needs to be a change to the act to ensure that the appropriate protection of these sites is put in place, particularly with regard to monuments that are on private land. As Jess Smith says, the landowner can do whatever she wants with the land, and has been doing so, up until recently, when the fence was erected around the site. We need to ensure that monuments such as this one are protected and we need to state that we see the value in protecting them.
We should write to Historic Scotland to ask whether it intends to introduce legislation that would amend the 1979 act to ensure that we get appropriate protection for sites that are on private land.