Good morning and a very warm welcome to everyone to the sixth meeting of the Devolution (Further Powers) Committee.
We have an apology from Stewart Maxwell; Bill Kidd is his substitute. Tavish Scott is running a little behind schedule, but I know that he is coming.
I am delighted to welcome such an esteemed panel of witnesses this morning: professors—I will not read out all your titles—David Bell, David Heald, Charlie Jeffery, Michael Keating and Nicola McEwen. Thank you for coming along to help us in our deliberations about the Smith commission proposals.
I will try to run the meeting a bit like a round-table discussion—although we have not set things up in that way—to get the conversation flowing. That means that there is a need for a bit of discipline on the part of all of us; members should keep their questions tight and panellists should be as concise as they can be. I will try to pull the conversation back if I feel that it is going off in a direction that it should not be taking. We will start with general questions before moving on to tax, welfare and probably some of the constitutional stuff around all that. The witnesses should assume that members’ questions are for all of you, although of course you do not all need to contribute on every question.
I will kick off. To what extent do the Smith commission proposals and recommendations represent a coherent package of powers for the Scottish Parliament? How implementable are they? What challenges might we expect? Those are broad questions, but they will get us started and I am sure that members will ask supplementary questions.
