link
To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02465)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02465)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
link
Can the First Minister tell us whether fuel poverty has gone up or down in the past year?’
Jackie Baillie will have read the same report that I read earlier in the week, which shows that fuel poverty has increased to levels that are, in my opinion, completely unacceptable. The report is clear that the increase is being driven by an increase in fuel prices. It is quite instructive to consider the fact that, if fuel prices had simply risen in line with inflation rather than by 7 per cent, the fuel poverty rate for 2013 would have been only 11 per cent. Fuel prices are behind the increase, which demonstrates a fundamental failure of the United Kingdom-regulated energy market.
Jackie Baillie will also be aware of the fact that the report is clear that energy efficiency measures for which this Government has a responsibility have operated to mitigate the increase in fuel poverty. The increase, unacceptable though it is, would have been even higher but for the energy efficiency measures that we have taken. We will continue to focus on that as well as continuing to argue strongly for measures that are under the control of the United Kingdom Government to be used to mitigate the increases for people who are finding energy bills difficult to deal with.
link
There may be a different First Minister, but we hear the same tired old tune about who is to blame. It is always someone else’s fault.
Let me be helpful to the First Minister. Margaret Burgess changed the methodology in an attempt to mask the scale of the increase. It is not a 100,000-household increase, as the Government has claimed. By the Scottish Government’s own figures, the number of households living in fuel poverty in Scotland increased by almost 300,000. That is the size of the populations of Livingston, Hamilton, Cumbernauld, Dunfermline, Kirkcaldy and Ayr put together.
Today, the number in fuel poverty is nearly 1 million households. The reality is that that is more than 2 million men, women and children in Scotland who will be freezing this winter. Those are real people: pensioners, disabled people and children whose parents are having to make the choice between heating and eating. Nicola Sturgeon should be ashamed. Can she tell us what her Government has done to tackle fuel poverty in Scotland?
I will begin on a note of agreement with Jackie Baillie: we are talking about real people. That is important to say, because that puts more of a burden on all of us to deal in accurate statistics, and not in politically motivated distortion.
I will take one point that Jackie Baillie made. She said—I think that this is a direct quote—that the change in methodology has masked the increase. Actually, the reverse is true. The change in methodology has increased the scale of the increase in fuel poverty. However, as the report shows—I trust that Jackie Baillie has read the report in as much detail as I have—when we compare like with like, we see that there has been a 4 per cent increase in fuel poverty. That takes the figure to more than 900,000, and Jackie Baillie is absolutely right that there are many people who think that, if that survey were done today, the figure would be closer to, or perhaps more than, 1 million. However, let us not try to distort the figures. In an energy-rich country, those figures are appalling, and we should all unite in making that clear.
The report is also absolutely abundantly and explicitly clear that responsibility for the increase lies with increases in fuel prices—the 7 per cent rise in fuel prices has driven the increase in fuel poverty. It also makes it clear that that increase would have been higher but for the energy efficiency measures for which this Government has been partly responsible.
Jackie Baillie asked me what the Government has been doing, so I will give her some specific information. Since 2009, we have invested more than £300 million on a raft of fuel poverty and energy efficiency programmes, and we will spend a further £94 million this year and a further £94 million next year. Nearly one in three households—about 700,000 households in Scotland—has now received energy efficiency support. Experts in the field acknowledge that the Scottish Government is providing more publicly funded support for energy efficiency than any of our counterparts anywhere else in these islands are providing.
I am in no way complacent about the matter. It is shameful—for all of us—that we live in an energy-rich country where nearly 1 million people are living in fuel poverty. Perhaps we can all, therefore, unite in calling on the UK Government to do more about fuel prices. Jackie Baillie has previously called for a freeze in energy prices. Will she join me today in calling on the UK Government to go further than that and to restructure energy bills so that we take the burden of energy efficiency off energy bills and deliver a cut?
link
I listened very carefully to what the First Minister said. She claimed that independent experts think that she is doing a tremendous job, but those independent experts tell a different story. Energy Action Scotland says that the Scottish Government
“can and should ... do more”,
and that the levels of funding that are being provided mean that the promise to abolish fuel poverty by 2016 “will not be met”. The Existing Homes Alliance says that the current budget is “well below” what is needed “to tackle fuel poverty”. Yet, last year, the SNP’s own budget for fuel poverty was underspent by £10 million at a time when the need to spend it was self-evident. The First Minister is shaking her head, but that is the truth. I suggest that she go away and check what her budget was.
The Scottish Federation of Housing Associations says that
“fuel poverty is at crisis levels”,
and even the Minister for Housing and Welfare has called the situation “scandalous”. I could not agree more with her. Why is the First Minister letting down poor people in Scotland?
I question whether Jackie Baillie really did, as she claims, listen to my answer. In an attempt—again—to find some consensus, I do not dispute the experts’ analysis of the problem. I do not want to live in an energy-rich country that has so many people living in fuel poverty, and I hope that we all agree on that. Nor do I take issue with those who put pressure on the Scottish Government to do more. That is exactly what they should be doing, and I accept the responsibility for doing as much as we possibly can. I undertake to Parliament and the public out there that we will strive to do as much as we can within our resources and within our powers.
Jackie Baillie mentioned Energy Action Scotland. I readily concede that Energy Action Scotland will be among the organisations that are pushing the Scottish Government to do more. However, I will quote Norman Kerr of Energy Action Scotland speaking on BBC Radio Scotland on 6 November. He said:
“there is a marked difference ... between Scotland and England. Scotland ... still retains energy efficiency fuel poverty programmes paid for out of the public purse. ... We are certainly streets ahead of what is happening in England.”
I accept the responsibility constantly to challenge the Government to do more. However, surely Jackie Baillie can accept two things. First, unlike the UK Government, we continue to fund energy efficiency measures out of the public purse. That is why one in three households has now received energy efficiency support. Secondly, surely Jackie Baillie can accept that, much as I wish it were different, I do not have powers over regulation of the energy market or powers over fuel prices. Let us come together to ask the UK Government to do more to deal with the issue. I note that she did not join me in calling on the UK Government to take the cost of the energy companies obligation out of energy bills so that we can deliver a cut in people’s energy bills, so I give her another opportunity to do so. Will she join me in making that call?
link
Do you know, what I cannot get over is that the First Minister is content—[Interruption.]
Order.
link
The First Minister is content in her ambition simply to compare fuel poverty in Scotland with fuel poverty in England and to say, “It’s so much better here”, when we are heading for fuel poverty in Scotland in 1 million households and for 2 million people. What a lack of ambition that represents.
I can honestly say—-[Interruption.]
Order.
link
I can honestly say that, although it is wonderful to hear the First Minister call for consensus, she and her Government have, over the past seven years, rejected all the suggestions that members on the Labour side of the chamber have made on fuel poverty.
I know that the First Minister does not like to hear the truth, but she was responsible for tackling fuel poverty for the past two years, and in each of those years, on her watch, fuel poverty levels went up. That is happening in Scotland today, because of decisions that her Government made.
The buck stops—[Interruption.]
Order.
link
The buck stops with the First Minister. For the second week running, I remind her that it was she who said that
“a party that is now in its second term of office cannot avoid taking responsibility for its own failings”—[Official Report, 12 December 2001; c 4711.]
Politics has always been about difficult choices. Labour will freeze gas and electricity bills, reform the energy market and improve housing stock in order to tackle fuel poverty. The First Minister and her party want to give the energy companies a massive tax cut. That is the difference.
The truth is that, as winter begins to bite, fuel poverty is up and millions of people throughout Scotland will be freezing. When the fuel poverty forum meets this afternoon, will the First Minister be there to apologise for abandoning the poor people in Scotland this winter?
Right, okay. I will try to take that step by step. First, I welcome Labour’s commitment to reform of the energy market. I merely point out that it was Labour that established the current energy market.
Secondly, I welcome the commitment to an energy price freeze, but I do not think that a freeze goes far enough. We should be coming up with action to reduce people’s energy bills, not to freeze them.
Thirdly, I think that it is a bit rich, on the day that Ed Miliband is plastered over the front of The Independent newspaper saying that he is about to “wield the axe” on public spending, for Jackie Baillie to come to the chamber and lecture me about public spending.
I have just a few more facts—[Interruption.]
Order.
I have just a few more facts, which might be uncomfortable for Jackie Baillie to hear, but I hope that she will bear with me.
Between 2002 and 2007, under a Lib Dem-Labour Administration, the fuel poverty rate in Scotland more than doubled. I expect that Jackie Baillie would have said then much of what I am saying right now: we have had to concentrate on energy efficiency, but we need action on fuel prices.
Jackie Baillie comes to the chamber and calls for more money on the day that Miliband is wielding the axe on public spending, but not once has Labour come to John Swinney in a budget negotiation and asked for more money for fuel poverty. It is fine for Jackie Baillie to come here—[Interruption.]
link
He did.—[Interruption.]
Order.
Who is Jackie Baillie pointing at? Is it Patrick Harvie?
Aye, he did, but not her.
Order.
Jackie Baillie is apparently defending herself by saying that someone in another party did ask for more money, while Labour did not—[Interruption.]
Order.
The real point that I want to make is this. I have now been in this job for almost a month, and already I have come to the conclusion that it does not actually matter what the Scottish National Party does or says: Labour will oppose it, because Labour has stopped being the Labour Party and has become the anti-SNP party. That is probably why one of the candidates for Labour’s deputy leadership emailed all of us last week, looking for our votes, and said that nobody trusts Labour anymore.
I will tell members what I am going to do: I will leave to Labour the job of opposition, and I will continue with the job of governing in the interests of this country and doing everything that we can to tackle the scandal of fuel poverty.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.