I welcome the Rt Hon Alistair Carmichael, Secretary of State for Scotland, to our deliberations this morning. I also welcome Chris Platt, the secretary of state’s principal private secretary—I hope that I got that title right. Thank you, Alistair, for agreeing to appear in front of the committee so quickly after the Smith commission report came out. It is very helpful for us and will enable us to begin to get an understanding of the perspectives of both the United Kingdom Government and the Scottish Government.
We will ask some general questions at the beginning and will go through some of the tax and welfare issues. We will perhaps address constitutional matters towards the end. I will begin by bringing us back to an issue that we discussed with Lord Smith. Paragraph 21 of the Smith commission’s report seeks to entrench the constitutional position of the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government as “permanent institutions”. Lord Smith said to us on Tuesday morning:
“If you know a way of making the institution permanent, tell me, because that is the Scottish people’s will.”—Official Report, Devolution (Further Powers) Committee, 2 December 2014; c 31.
I think that we all recognise the challenge here, but I wonder what measures you might be aware of that could be taken to entrench the concept of permanence and enhance the autonomy of the institutions of the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government beyond merely stating it in primary legislation. Has any consideration been given to alternative models that might exist in other jurisdictions?

