Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 4 December 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02445)

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Who was it who said, when talking about the national health service:

“a party that is now in its second term of office cannot avoid taking responsibility for its own failings”?—[Official Report, 12 December 2001; c 4711.]

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

If Jackie Baillie is talking about me, let me say very clearly that I will never avoid taking responsibility for the NHS. It is one of the most sacred responsibilities that any Government has. I am very proud of our national health service, but I will never shy away from facing up to the challenges in it. My job and the job of the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport is to work with the front-line staff in our NHS to ensure that we help them to address those challenges. That is why we are committing extra resources to our national health service. John Swinney had already announced £80 million more than planned for next year; yesterday, he announced £125 million of extra funding.

I have given a commitment that if the Government is re-elected, for each and every year of the next session we will commit to above-inflation increases in health spending. Labour has not yet committed to that. Perhaps Jackie Baillie will do so today.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I am delighted that Nicola Sturgeon, who is not normally coy about recalling her own words, recognises that those words were hers.

I will rise to the challenge. We will match the commitment on all consequentials going to health and the commitment to protect the revenue budget, but we will go further: our mansion tax will, in fact, increase funding for health.

Yesterday’s debate flew in the face of the comments that the First Minister has just made. There seemed to be a denial of the problems and the challenges. Indeed, last month, Alex Neil said that there was “no crisis” at NHS Grampian. In the past week alone, we have seen the crisis laid bare. Consultant shortages are so severe that doctors are being flown in from Jamaica and India. Accident and emergency treatment times and cancer treatment waiting times have been missed. There have been fewer nurses to beds than in other hospitals in Scotland. Bed-blocking targets have been missed. There has been a failing care-of-the-elderly service and, most damning of all, patient safety has been at risk. Things have been saved only by the dedication of staff who are working under extreme pressure.

The Royal College of Nursing told us that it had raised “serious concerns” about the NHS for quite some time, in particular in NHS Grampian. In fact, it raised those concerns directly with the Scottish National Party Government.

In any case, surely the Scottish Government should have noticed that there was a problem. Is there anyone in Government who has a clue about what was going on?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Jackie Baillie strikes entirely the wrong tone when it comes to our national health service. We should try to find common ground across the chamber. All of us accept that our NHS does great work, but it needs our support—the support of all of us—to do even better work.

As Jackie Baillie is well aware, Grampian NHS Board has in place a new chief executive, who has accepted all the recommendations of the reports that were published earlier this week. The health secretary will oversee the implementation plan very closely. All of us are now absolutely focused on ensuring that the failings that were identified in NHS Grampian by the inspection regime that this Government put in place can now be fixed in the interests of all the patients who rely on NHS Grampian. I hope that Jackie Baillie and Labour, too, can find it within themselves to get behind the efforts of the new management and the staff of NHS Grampian as they decide how to move forward.

I will pick up on a couple of the points that Jackie Baillie made.

I do not for a second deny that we still have work to do on waiting times, but they are now considerably shorter than they were when Labour left office.

Jackie Baillie mentioned consultants. NHS consultants are now at a record high number—up 36.8 per cent since the Government took office. Overall, the number of staff in the health service is up since the Government took office, as we saw in figures that were released earlier this week. The Government is acting.

Let us look at delayed discharge, which I consider to be one of the most significant challenges in our NHS today as it is a problem that then creates problems in other parts of the system. The number of delayed discharges is too high right now and I want it to come down, but it is significantly lower than it was in 2006 and when the previous Government left office. So we are making progress and we will continue to seek to make progress. It would fit Labour better to stop criticising those who are working so hard in our NHS and get behind them.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

We support the efforts of all at NHS Grampian, and we thank them for doing the work that they should not have had to do but had to do because the Government let them down. They were under extreme pressure. The efforts of those staff are the only reason why patient safety is as it is. Therefore, I will take no lessons from Nicola Sturgeon about praising NHS staff. The difference is that we would support them.

Patient care should be at the centre of all our considerations, yet patient safety was put at risk in Aberdeen. Healthcare Improvement Scotland issued a stark warning. It said:

“We found a number of issues relating to leadership and culture which reduce the quality and safety of care.”

The General Medical Council said that the evidence that patient safety and care could have been compromised was overwhelming. The Royal College of Nursing said that, without a patient assurance system, managers were

“not able to assure themselves or their Board about the quality and safety of patient care.”

We should again thank the staff for putting patients first, despite the challenges that they faced. The Scottish Government was warned about the issues, which date back to the First Minister’s time as health secretary. Does the First Minister agree that the concerns about patient safety show a failure not just at NHS Grampian but in the Scottish Government health department, which she led?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

Despite the provocation, I am not going to stand here and engage in a party-political bun fight, because I believe that the NHS is too important for that. However, Jackie Baillie should reflect on some of what she has said. In her desperation to throw as much dirt at the Scottish National Party Government as she can, she was in danger of misquoting the report that was published on Aberdeen royal infirmary earlier this week. Although I do not defend anything that the report points out, it was careful to say that patient safety had not been compromised. Of course, given the failings that were identified, patient safety could have been compromised, which is inexcusable, but Jackie Baillie should be very careful not to suggest that something happened that the inspectors said did not happen.

I repeat that I am proud of the NHS and of the progress that the Government is making on it. Waiting times are lower and our hospitals are cleaner although, as we see in the report published on Glasgow royal infirmary today, there is still work to be done on that. Infection rates are at an all-time low and rates of Clostridium difficile are down by more than 80 per cent among the over-65 population.

The Government is making significant progress and, unlike Labour, we do not have to be dragged kicking and screaming into making financial commitments to our NHS. A couple of weeks ago, I watched each and every one of the Labour leadership candidates refuse to give that financial commitment to the NHS. When Richard Simpson was asked yesterday in the chamber whether the Labour Party would give increases to the NHS budget, his answer was, “We will see.” Then, the next day, Jackie Baillie has come up with the commitment. We give that commitment freely to the NHS, because we put our money where our mouth is and we will always defend our national health service.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

It is the First Minister who does a bit too much kicking and screaming. There was nothing desperate about our commitments, and I hope that she will welcome them. I remind her that, from 2007 to 2010, when Labour was in charge at United Kingdom level, it gave the Scottish Government more in health consequentials than she passed on to the health service, so I will take no lessons from her on that.

The First Minister, like Alex Neil, seems to be in denial about the scale of the problem that is facing Scotland’s health service. NHS Grampian is not alone. Even today, we have seen a damning report about the cleanliness of basic equipment at Glasgow royal infirmary, with instances of blood and body fluids contaminating beds and equipment being highlighted not once but twice, and with problems remaining. Does she take any responsibility for that, or for consultant vacancies having more than doubled, leading to a record £82 million being spent on hiring temporary doctors? Does she take any responsibility for bed numbers being slashed? For accident and emergency departments being in crisis? For delayed discharge increasing?

The Scottish National Party Government has failed patients not only in Aberdeen but across Scotland. The First Minister cannot duck responsibility for that, because for five years she was the health secretary. It was Nicola Sturgeon who said:

“a party that is now in its second term of office cannot avoid taking responsibility for its own failings”.

Will the First Minister tell us when she is going to take responsibility?

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Southside
link

I used to ask the questions from the Opposition benches. I know that Jackie Baillie has only one First Minister’s question time left before she hands over to the new leader, but it might be a good idea if she actually listened to the answers.

I started by saying something that I will now say again, not for the benefit of Jackie Baillie but for the benefit of people watching. I, as First Minister of this country, take responsibility for the NHS. I will never shy away from that, and I and my Government will be judged by the progress that we are making and will continue to make in the NHS.

Jackie Baillie talked about the fact that there are more staff vacancies in the NHS. That is true, and we need to confront that challenge. However, there are more staff vacancies because there are more staff working in the NHS—there are significantly increased numbers of people working across our NHS.

Jackie Baillie also mentioned the number of beds. There has actually been a small increase in the number of beds in the past year. I point Jackie Baillie to the fact that—she can correct me if I am wrong—acute bed numbers fell in each and every year of the last Labour Administration. That was the reality.

On the Glasgow royal infirmary, this is another example of a time when Jackie Baillie might have benefited from actually listening to what I said. I mentioned the GRI report in answer to her second question. That report is unacceptable, and the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport has already spoken this morning to the chair of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. However, let me just put this into context. Since this Government took office, as I have already mentioned, rates of C diff have fallen by more than 80 per cent across Scotland—they have fallen by more than 84.7 per cent in Glasgow.

I will never shy away from addressing the problems that need to be confronted in our NHS, but I am also not going to stand by and let Labour trash the record of our NHS, because it does not deserve it.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Living Wage (Public Contracts) Questions · 4
  2. Construction Industry (Rogue Traders) Questions · 4
  3. Local Authorities (Care Home Provision) Questions · 4
  4. NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 6
  5. Disabled People (Access to Rail Services) Questions · 6
  6. Listed Buildings (Changes) Questions · 4
  7. Temporary Accommodation (Minimum Standards) Questions · 4
  8. RAF Leuchars Questions · 4
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  10. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  11. Autumn Statement (Impact on Scottish Budget) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  12. In-work Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (Health Services) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Crime Statistics (Reporting) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Food Train (Meal Makers Project) Members’ business · 12
  16. Scotland’s National Action Plan for Human Rights Debate · 23
  17. Violence against Women Debate · 34
  18. Decision Time Decision time · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.