Under the current complaints process, independent monitors—visiting committee members—must investigate complaints from prisoners and try to resolve them, after which they must go back and tell the prisoner what the outcome is. That process was deleted in its entirety from the previous version of the order, and it has been replaced in the current version by a provision that says that independent monitors “may” investigate matters brought to them by prisoners. Therefore, investigation will not be an absolute requirement, nor will there be a requirement to go back and tell the prisoner what the outcome is.
10:15
Prisoners will have a very old-fashioned means of access to the independent monitor—that should have been updated in the legislation. Prisoners will have to approach a Scottish Prison Service staff member and make a request to see an independent monitor. Alternatively, they will have to ask to write to an independent monitor, for which purpose the governor must provide paper. There is nothing that says that any of that is a confidential process, which it should be, and it will rely entirely on the SPS passing on the request.
We know from prisoners that, in the internal SPS system, they occasionally suffer reprisals for making a complaint. If they ask to see a member of the visiting committee, prison staff will sometimes make life a bit difficult for them. For example, if they want to go to the gym, they will find that the list is somehow full, or if they want to use the phone, they will find that that is not convenient. A prisoner in a prison that I visited recently referred to that practice as being “bammed up”, which means being treated like an idiot. If a prisoner asks to see a member of the visiting committee or makes a formal complaint through the SPS system, there are consequences. Further, prison staff will routinely ask a prisoner who requests to see a member of the visiting committee why they want to do so, although they are not entitled to ask that.
At Polmont prison, we operate a confidential process in which a sealed envelope with the prisoner’s request is put into a locked box and the sealed envelope comes directly to the visiting committee. That is similar to the system in England, where it is called the applications process. The order ought to make provision for such a system, but for some reason the Government has chosen not to do that.
The order proposes that, if a prisoner so requests, independent monitors should assist them with the SPS internal complaints system. We have no idea what that would amount to. There are 6,000 complaints in the SPS system every year—we know that only from a BBC freedom of information request, because the SPS does not publish those statistics. It is impossible to say in how many of those 6,000 complaints a prisoner would ask the independent monitor for help. It is entirely likely that there are prisoners in the system who do not use the complaints system because they have literacy problems. We do not know by how much the figure of 6,000 could grow, but the proposal could involve a considerable amount of work. Apart from the possible workload, it is also very worrying that prisoners might begin to view independent monitors as being somehow part of the SPS system. There is no doubt that that would undermine the monitors’ independence.