Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Creationism (Schools) (PE1530)

Tuesday 11 November 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 09:45–10:15 Petitions 89 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

89 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I welcome you all to today’s meeting of the Public Petitions Committee. As always, I ask everyone to switch off electronic devices, because they interfere with the sound system.

No apologies have been received. Please note that the meeting will be suspended at about 10:45 to allow those who wish to do so to go to the remembrance day commemoration in the garden lobby at 11:00. The meeting will resume once the commemoration has concluded. People in the gallery are also welcome to attend the commemoration.

The first item of business is consideration of four new petitions. The committee agreed to invite petitioners to speak to three of the petitions. The first new petition is PE1530, by Spencer Fildes, on behalf of the Scottish Secular Society, on guidance on how creationism is presented in schools. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing, the petition and a submission.

I welcome to the meeting the petitioner—thank you very much for coming along—and Professor Paul Braterman, who is a board member of, and scientific adviser to, the Scottish Secular Society. Please speak for about five minutes, after which I will ask some questions and then ask my colleagues to come in.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Good morning, and thank you for giving us the opportunity to speak to our petition.

Our petition has attracted international attention because of the issues that are involved. Scotland’s future depends on science, especially the life sciences—a topic that the convener has addressed in the chamber. Signatories who endorse the petition, including teachers, ministers of religion and three Nobel prize-winning scientists, have written messages of support.

Evolution and the unity of life are central concepts to modern biology, just as the existence of atoms is central to the concept of modern chemistry. The objections to a common ancestry, such as those that are put forward by the Centre for Intelligent Design, and objections to an old earth, such as those that are put forward by so-called creationist scientists, lack all intellectual merit.

If the committee disagrees with what I just said, you should dismiss our petition and give your reasons for doing so. However, if in your assessment you agree with us, with the overwhelming scientific evidence—a sample of which we have sent to the committee—with the science that is outlined in the curriculum for excellence and with the massive stated consensus among the world’s scientific communities, the only remaining question for us to answer is how we best protect our children from this campaign of misinformation.

The issue is not about religion; it is about science. Despite some reports, the Scottish Secular Society is neutral on matters of faith and has a faith-diverse membership. As the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing shows, we have no wish to restrict discussion of any religious or philosophical viewpoint; indeed, there is across the faith spectrum a strong tradition of welcoming evolution as a manifestation of divine creativity. In view of what we have seen recently—from the challenge from People With A Mission Ministries, to the plain declaration of intent by the Centre for Intelligent Design, to other evidence that we can present—it is no longer credible to ignore the fact that there are organisations that are attempting, with some success, to penetrate our schools in order to present creationism and young earth doctrines as valid alternatives to established science.

Why cannot we, as the Government suggests, just leave the matter to the good judgment of our teachers? First, some teachers—let us hope not many—may well be creationists. I have come across that through interactions with my child’s nursery nurse. Secondly, there are places where teachers, although they may not be creationists, might experience pressure from the community to introduce creationism and ignore teaching evolution.

Thirdly, teachers might feel unprepared to teach about evolution, especially if they expect a creationist challenge from the local chaplain. That will be especially true at primary school level, through religious, moral and philosophical education that is rarely taught by science graduates.

Finally, and most important, it is rarely the teachers who are the problem; it is volunteer visitors and externally funded chaplains whose offerings are often gratefully accepted by schools that are currently coping with many other pressures. That is why our petition refers to materials being “presented” rather than taught. In the absence of the guidance that we seek, any teacher who would want to object to any particular creationist activity might well find themselves in an impossible position.

I hope that you are all familiar with the scandal at Kirktonholme primary school. What was most alarming about that incident was that the chaplain who was responsible had been in post and assisted by volunteers from his church for eight years undetected. The material that was distributed there beggars belief, which is why we have prepared copies for the committee to peruse. Such material is typical of so-called creation science, which is a mid-20th century development, as my colleague Professor Paul Braterman will possibly explain later.

The Perth-based “Challenger” bus regularly visits many schools throughout Scotland. Visiting the bus is incorporated into the school day and children are strongly urged to take part. Parents who have given permission are not normally told that the bus is provided by People With A Mission Ministries, which is an organisation that features materials from Ken Ham’s Answers in Genesis, which is a notorious United States-based young earth creationist organisation that has attacked this petition twice now.

Other creationist organisations also distribute materials or offer speakers to schools. Numerous schools are known to have creationist chaplains and creationist denominations, including US-inspired extreme creationist sects. They are often represented on school chaplaincy boards; we can supply details for councils. Some local authorities’ education committees, for example in South Lanarkshire, Clackmannanshire and Falkirk have members from churches that hold extreme creationist young earth views and could make things difficult for teachers in their employ. The organisation Truth in Science, which is young earth creationist, has sent to every school copies of a creationist pseudo-text, which is misnamed “Explore Evolution”. That book is a production of the Seattle-based Discovery Institute, with which the Centre for Intelligent Design is closely associated.

The Creation Research Institute, which promotes creation science among creationist groups, also offers speakers to schools. One school in the Highlands has seen the Genesis story being taught as literal truth and has, in the past, designated a corner of a classroom as the “creation corner”.

To our knowledge, at least three schools have hosted debates between creationists and defenders of mainstream science; in respect of two such cases, the councils denied, in responses to freedom of information requests, that such a thing had ever happened. In the words of one of the schools:

“Last session our Higher RMPS class attended a Q & A with a creationist and this was then followed up with a similar session with an evolutionist as part of their course, but this was part of their studies and not advocating one set of beliefs.”

That is absurd. It is almost like having a question-and-answer session with a flat earther and, for the sake of balance, a sphericalist. The fact that the debate was even staged implies an intellectual parity that does not exist.

Given those facts, it is no longer credible to deny that this is a problem that is in need of official attention. The first step in solving any problem is to recognise that Scotland has a problem.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I have a couple of questions on the other bits of evidence that the committee has had. One argument was that what you are suggesting might breach the European convention on human rights, which contains the right for parents to have their children educated in line with their religious and philosophical views. What is your response to that?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I do not think what I suggest would breach ECHR rights. If those rights were implemented as those people see it, we would be teaching the majority of pupils that the earth is 6,000 to 10,000 years old, which would clearly contravene many areas of the curriculum for excellence.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The other criticism is that your petition does not recognise the difference between creationism and intelligent design. How do you respond to that?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I will let the professor answer that question, if that is okay.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I take it from the fact that you whistled there that you do not agree with that, professor.

Professor Paul Braterman Scottish Secular Society
link

That is right.

It is a magnificent sight to see the director of the Centre for Intelligent Design asserting, while turning purple in the face, that intelligent design and creationism have nothing to do with each other. However, as I said in my response to paragraph 1.7 of his submission, the essence of his case is to cast serious doubt on the idea that natural processes, primarily evolution, have given rise to the diversity of life, which he does by pretending that there is serious doubt about what he calls macro-evolution—which most of us would call evolution—as part of the overall unity of life.

I am sure that he is sincere, but I believe that he is a bit muddled. Although he believes that intelligent design is not creationism, it incorporates as part of its rhetorical structure a questioning of what is, we submit—we believe that the committee should also regard it so—the established science of the common descent of living things. Nearly all advocates of intelligent design deny what they call macro-evolution, and in doing that they are going against the evidence. Indeed, one of the web organs for the intelligent design community is called “Uncommon Dissent” in order to emphasise that common descent, which we consider to be part of the absolutely established science, is in their view not established science. By our definition, they are definitely creationist.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. As I am sure you are aware, the petition is about a very large area; I suspect that we could debate it all day, but unfortunately we have only 20 minutes. I am sure that my colleagues will focus on the practicalities of education policy, because that is the crucial issue for us.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Good morning. Mr Fildes, I heard your evidence on the role of teachers, and that you are not dissembling in terms of what they should or should not teach, so why should they not be allowed to present intelligent design or creationism to pupils, if they so choose?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

It is not a case of whether they should or should not be allowed; it is about the context and how it is presented. For example, my son was in the woods and asked a question about fauna. The teacher was unable to give a scientific or biological answer, but immediately referred to “God makes all things and we’re all from Adam and Eve.” My son came home and asked me more questions about that. I am an atheist, so I was not happy about it. I went back to the school to—

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Forgive me, but the petition says that you want to

“bar the presentation in Scottish publicly funded schools of separate creation and of Young Earth doctrines”—

Professor Braterman
link

—as valid

“alternatives to the established science”,

which is important. If you think that they are valid alternatives to the established science, you should say so and you should throw us out.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

That validity is surely underpinned by the fact that—according to the point that Mr Fildes made—it should be down to teachers to determine the curriculum and how they present it.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

If it is down to teachers, my experience is that that is not being implemented fairly and—

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

The evidence that I have for that comes from many areas. I have just given you my personal experience, so you have had it from the top and—

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Yes—but what wider experience is there? Your frame of reference is quite particular.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Of course.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

What wider evidence do you have that the case is as you say it is?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I have the evidence that we get through the Scottish Secular Society. We are basically a medium; we offer platforms for people from all walks of life and all faiths to report to us and discuss matters. They can do so through an open-debate platform and privately through email. Many of the concerns that are raised with us come through as private matters, unfortunately. The people concerned wish the information to remain confidential and do not want to be named, but nevertheless make a complaint. However, they are quite happy for us to refer their statements to the committee. One such statement of evidence of the discussion of creationism taking place comes from a concerned Highland parent who wishes to remain anonymous. I will quickly read out a paragraph from her statement:

“A couple of years ago, I went to an open afternoon in the school to view children’s work on display. A banner in the corner of the classroom said ‘Creation Corner’. Intrigued, I went over to investigate, and in my naivety thought it was going to be an art display. No, it was exactly what it said, a big, handmade wallchart with flipping pages ... detailing how the world had been created in seven days ... ‘in the beginning there was light and dark’ ... I was pretty horrified and seem to remember asking one of the teachers where evolution corner was”,

for which she was met with only “dirty looks” from the teacher.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

What debate have you had with the main bodies for, or perpetrators of, intelligent design and creationism? It seems that you are throwing bricks at each other without even having had that discussion before coming here.

10:00

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

That is because we are not seeking compromise with them.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

There cannot be compromise with creationism in a science class.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Good morning. I am something of an atheist, too, albeit that I am an unconvinced and unhappy one. You said that your petition had attracted international interest and support, although I note that it has no signatories attached to it. Perhaps you can explain that.

I was struck by how Charles Darwin might recognise your predicament. At one point, the role was completely reversed, in that it was the science that was being challenged, rather than the alternative.

I was not present at the creation of the planet.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Likewise.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am sceptical about most things, although I tend towards the evolutionary scientific theory that you espouse. I would really like to know what you think is the worst that can happen.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

The worst that can happen is distortion of learning in the classroom. The life sciences and biomedical industries in Scotland are flourishing at the moment and we have some of the greatest stars and some of the most creative minds coming through. I would be horrified to think that there was any potential for those minds from a young age to be in any way distorted by suffering any form of cognitive dissonance regarding young-earth doctrines or creationism, and what is actual science and what is real. That is not a case of philosophising over science; it is about teaching the facts.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

Do we not live in a slightly more real environment? For example, my mother’s mother told her that she was delivered by a stork. She then went to a biology class and heard that there was a more scientific way she was delivered. She went home, where her mother told her that, although that might be how people do things in Scotland, it was certainly not how they do them in England.

My point is that parents have a role in education. Young people are impressionable, but education is a very rounded thing. Would seeking to drive underground what you and I both, I think, regard as a ridiculous notion serve any particular purpose? I am not persuaded that any real harm is being done in all this. In the wider context of education, parental involvement and the school, do you not think that the evolutionary model will prevail?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Yes—it will prevail in all matters. What you are doing is diluting the argument somewhat.

As regards your mother being told about storks, that is pretty much still the case in Scotland, so we have an issue with sex education.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

My point is that people, through a form of education, come to understand that the truth is somewhat different, without it necessarily having been emphasised in the way that you might have wished.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I will pass that point to Paul Braterman, but before I do so, I ask this: why should we assert such untruths to our children in an educational establishment, in particular in the science class? That is not a whole-world view.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I have gone through life with children being taught about socialism, which is equally discredited, but it does not do any great harm for them to be told what it is all about. I wonder what you think the damage to the intellect of a child will be overall. Do you just have a concern that such teaching might lead to something more sinister, or can you point to anything that has actually been damaged in the development of children into adults as a result of their having been exposed to the theory in the midst of all the real science?

Professor Braterman
link

Yes. There have been cases reported in the press—not in Scotland, I am glad to say—of students walking out of university lectures that are based on evolution. There is concern in the scientific community about the effect of evolution rejection on subject choice at university level.

My colleague Roger Downie, who is now emeritus professor of biology at the University of Glasgow, has carried out interesting research into the effects of creationist belief on subject choice among students. He is certainly one of the people, if I may presume to say so, with whom the committee should communicate.

I know that Jackson Carlaw is a strong believer in individual choice and freedom and in the individual making up their own mind. I agree with you on all of that. Nonetheless, if you tell children untruths at a stage when they will believe you, that will affect their outlook on life indefinitely, especially considering that most of them will not study science at university.

Professor Braterman
link

We tell children that Santa Claus exists in inverted commas, as it were.

Professor Braterman
link

We do not tell children that Santa Claus exists and that their eternal salvation depends on believing that Santa Claus exists.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I ask witnesses and members to speak through the chair, otherwise it becomes a rammy, as they would call it in Glasgow.

Before I bring John Wilson in, I state for the record that nearly 700 people have signed the petition.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Good morning, Mr Fildes. You mentioned the issues that have been identified in Clackmannanshire, Falkirk and South Lanarkshire. Can you expand on what those issues are? They go to the heart of your petition, and I would like you to expand on the reasons why you think that it was necessary to bring the petition to the committee and the Parliament.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

We have to present an evidence base to illustrate that this is going on—that is a primary concern—so we have made freedom of information requests asking specific local authorities whether they have invited anyone to talk on or debate creationism.

An example of how some education authorities are unaware that that is taking place comes from East Renfrewshire Council’s response to our freedom of information request. We asked:

“Within the past three years, have any of East Renfrewshire’s publicly funded schools been addressed by speakers from Creation Ministries International, or by any other speakers who claim that macro-evolution is speculative, or that the evidence supports separate creation over evolution, or a young Earth over an ancient Earth?”

The answer was no. However, our friends in the Scottish Secular Society were made aware that that was not the case and reported that back to us.

I have here a statement that was forwarded to us—it is from a conversation that took place with one of the reverends who had, indeed, been in a school. The reverend says:

“I went to Williamwood High School yesterday, at the request of an RE teaching friend, to discussion creation with his Higher Class. I had a great time. They were very nice and all left claiming to take the Creationist position more seriously. The basic message was ‘I believe the bible, you believe the scientists’ theories, neither of us can prove our positions—but I have a hopeful view of life and ... God who will do right in the end and a saviour who will give me everlasting life’. Like I say, I had a great time.”

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Thank you for that response.

The issue, which is picked up in some of the evidence, is concern that pastors, preachers, ministers, reverends or whoever from particular organisations—especially from the creationist/intelligent design side of the argument—are going into schools and presenting their arguments outwith RE lessons, and that they are bringing volunteers to assist them in schools. What evidence do you have of that? The current guidance that is issued by the Scottish Government says that teachers are responsible for what is taught in the classroom. If—as you said—someone says to a teacher, “I’ve got three people who are prepared to come and work with your class on a particular issue,” what is wrong with that?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

There is absolutely nothing wrong with it as long as they operate within the rules of the curriculum for excellence. Unfortunately, some come in with alternative agendas—as in the case of Kirktonholme primary school last year. I have mentioned one instance in East Renfrewshire that has gone unnoticed, but such things went unnoticed in East Kilbride for eight years. There is no real mechanism in place—no reporting structure or audit trail. Forgive me, but I do not know how the school inspectors deal with the issue. There is no reference point or guide such as we are seeking—something that anyone could refer to—on recording such matters or incidents. That is what we are asking for.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

To expand on that slightly, in the Scottish education system we have three types of education. We have the private sector—

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Yes—public schools.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

In Scotland, we talk about private education. We also have denominational education and non-denominational schools. We know the religious affiliation of denominational schools. In non-denominational schools, some teaching staff have a particular faith. Is it wrong for those teachers to impose that faith on the pupils who attend those non-denominational schools?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Yes.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

I have no further questions, convener.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Sorry, but can I just say that it is pronounced “files”—pretend that the d is not there.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

Sorry.

You have mentioned on several occasions that something went unnoticed in an area—I think that it was Hamilton—for eight years. How could such things be rectified?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

It could be rectified by this committee asking the Education and Culture Committee to seek evidence from different groups to get their considerations and opinion on whether guidance is needed. We believe that it is needed.

Another issue that was raised with us was a six-day mural in a school in Kirkcaldy—I have a photograph of it here. The mural was placed in a school corridor for all the school to see. Someone commissioned that—they asked for it to be produced. I sent an email to the authorities in Fife to ask about the matter, and my email was referred directly to the school. The school phoned me and the head denied that the mural was on the wall. However, I have photographic evidence that was sent by an anonymous parent that the mural was on the wall, but it has since been taken down.

Those kinds of things go on, but as soon as they are challenged, people tend to contend that they do not go on. We do not want that conflict. That is what we are trying to avoid by asking for clear and explicit guidance.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Just for the record, if you are referring to an item that we have not seen, could you leave it with the clerks?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I have a copy for you.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Could you leave it with the clerks, for reference purposes?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

I thought that I had included it, so apologies for that.

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

It is not a case of satisfying us; it is about satisfying teachers and parents. They are at the root of the petition, which seeks to ensure that they have the knowledge that their children will go through primary and secondary school with their scientific knowledge and exposure to science unhindered. That is all that this is about. We are not asking for a massive change in legislation. We are not asking for much—we are just asking for guidance to be issued to get rid of any ambiguity on the issue.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

You mentioned that you have not been in contact with any other agency with regard to the petition. Will you explain why?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

First and foremost, we are a secular society and, as I said, we are of many faiths and none. We have a discussion among our members on our Facebook open group, which is sometimes one of the most hotly debated areas on Facebook, I think. We also consult with our administration board. We hold monthly administrative meetings. On the board, we have pagans, Muslims, Christians, ex-Muslims and so on.

However, the most important people who we speak to are the parents who directly contact us regarding the matter. It is because of those consultations and complaints that we are here today. They are the ones who have written to us with the complaints and distressed emails telling us that they want something to be done. The problem with the system is that they want to remain anonymous. They do not want their names to be out in the open, for fear of reprisals from the school. If we have guidance that says that people cannot do such things, that would make it much easier for all bodies.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are short of time, but we have time for a quick final question from Chic Brodie, after which we will go to the summation.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Leaving the subject aside for a minute, do you have any idea of where in Scottish publicly funded schools we should bar talk about alternatives?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Such as?

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Do you have any idea whether it should be barred in other areas of science, English or what have you?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

When you are in art, you do not teach maths, and when you are in biology, you do not teach chemistry. I think that that is fairly self-explanatory. I do not think that we should bar anything else; we should merely make a clear distinction that creationism is incompatible with science. That is it.

Professor Braterman
link

If people wanted to go into schools to deny the reality of atoms, we would be here talking about that, too. That does not happen with atoms, but it does with the fact of evolution.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

That is healthy if there is a compromise and on-going discussion. Is that not the case?

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

The compromise is that parents and children and people of faith have their church and their home, and they have religious and moral education and philosophy. They have many avenues for discussing the issue; it just should not be discussed in the science class.

10:15

Professor Braterman
link

If you were talking about compromise within the biology community—I think that you were—of course there is on-going discussion about the mechanics of evolution, just as there is on-going discussion about the ultimate causes of gravity, but there is no dispute that if you drop something, it falls. Equally, there is no dispute within the scientific community—apart from synthesised disputes—about the fact that you and a monkey are second cousins, you and a monkey are fourth cousins, and you and a mushroom are fourth cousins. That is how it is, and the record shows it. To deny that is to deny established science.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am not sure whether that is unparliamentary language. Laughter.

Thank you very much for taking part in the debate. I suspect that we could have debated the petition for several hours. We now move to the summation phase, so there will be no further questions for the witnesses.

The committee needs to consider its next steps. Members will be aware that we could write to the Scottish Government, which is in charge of education policy, or a variety of other groups. Another option is that we could refer the petition to the Education and Culture Committee, which has as its raison d’être consideration of such issues. Members could come up with a variety of other options. I seek a steer—

Spencer Fildes Scottish Secular Society
link

Can we make one last statement?

Professor Braterman
link

There is no such thing as doing nothing at this stage, because to do nothing is to send a signal that you are happy with how things are. I respectfully suggest that among the people you should write to are the Association for Science Education, which is—

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry—I should have made it clearer that we have stopped taking contributions from witnesses; we are at the summation stage.

Professor Braterman
link

I am sorry.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

To summarise: we could write to the Scottish Government, which is in charge of education policy; we could refer the petition to the Education and Culture Committee; we could choose from a variety of options that members come up with; or we could, of course, close the petition, which is always an option.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I subscribe to the view that we take that final option. As recently as August, we had a statement from the Government that spoke about continuing the tradition that politicians should not determine the curriculum, which it said was a matter for educationists. It does not seem to me to be particularly constructive to write to the Government to get the same answer.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

My view is that we should write to the Scottish Government to seek clarification on the situation, particularly in light of the examples that the petitioners have given. There is an issue on which it is necessary for the Scottish Government to provide clarity. We are clearly not in the situation that we read about in the headlines, in which allegations were made against a particular religious grouping that was trying to influence what was taught in the school curriculum in Birmingham. In light of that, it would be useful to get an up-to-date view from the Scottish Government.

I also suggest that we should write to the Educational Institute of Scotland, because the petitioners have made reference to its views, the Scottish Secondary Teachers Association and the Association of Headteachers and Deputes in Scotland. In my view, a clear steer needs to be given to teaching staff about what it is permissible to teach in lessons. I know that my colleagues will not be particularly happy with that suggestion, but I think that a steer needs to be given so that we do not find ourselves in a situation in which a group or individuals have the resources to go into an educational facility and teach something that may conflict with current views and current science. We need to be very careful about what is taught in the classroom. Like one of the witnesses, I have experience—at my daughter’s primary school—of a headteacher who came from a particular faith background imposing that faith background on religious education classes and not widening out the curriculum to bring other faiths and beliefs into what was taught in the classroom.

We need to get a clear steer from the Scottish Government, and it is important that we contact the other organisations that I mentioned, because they need guidance.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I am happy to go along with John Wilson’s recommendations.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I am not happy to go along with John Wilson’s suggestions. On 31 August, a Scottish Government spokesman stated:

“Teachers, head teachers and professional educationalists decide what is taught in Scotland’s schools.”

As Chic Brodie said, the tradition

“that politicians should not determine the curriculum is highly valued and remains a cornerstone of Scottish education.”

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Does that mean that you are going for closure of the petition?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I think that there is an argument for referring the petition to the Education and Culture Committee but, at this early stage, I feel that it is only fair that we should get an up-to-date response from the Scottish Government, despite the fact that it made a statement to the Sunday Herald as recently as 31 August, in which it said:

“This longstanding tradition that politicians should not determine the curriculum is highly valued and remains a cornerstone of Scottish education.”

I think that it would be unfair to close the petition at this stage. We should give the petitioners the benefit of the doubt and get an up-to-date response from the Scottish Government.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

It is because of the statement to which Angus MacDonald has referred that I am slightly terrified by John Wilson’s suggestion that we should become highly prescriptive about what is taught in schools.

I am not in favour of closing the petition at this stage but, in light of what the Government has already said, I would be in favour of writing to it to ask it to confirm its view that the present system—and the discretion that it provides for—is robust enough to ensure that, in the round, children come out of school with the broadest possible education, which should be based on rational common sense; there should be no need to interfere in the content of that.

When I asked what harm had been done, the witnesses gave some anecdotal examples of things that might have occurred at international universities. That seemed very distant and far removed from the experience in primary schools in Scotland today. We should check that the Government believes that robust enough systems exist for it to cope with any curious views that might emerge and that, if it ever felt that that was under threat at some stage in the future, it would review the issue in the light of those changed circumstances.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

All members have now spoken. It is clear that a majority of members support the suggestion that we write to the Scottish Government. Can I just confirm that members are also happy that we write to the various educational institutions that John Wilson referred to?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So a majority of members are in favour of writing to the Scottish Government.

I ask members to indicate whether they are in favour of John Wilson’s suggestion that we also write to the EIS, the Scottish Secondary Teachers Association and the Association of Headteachers and Deputes in Scotland.

For

MacDonald, Angus (Falkirk East) (SNP)

Stewart, David (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)

Torrance, David (Kirkcaldy) (SNP)

Wilson, John (Central Scotland) (Ind)

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a majority.

Do members have any other issues that they want to raise before we move on?

We will write to all the organisations that we have agreed to write to and will discuss the petition again at a future meeting. The clerks will keep the petitioners up to date—you are welcome to sit in the public gallery at that meeting; you can check with the clerks when it will take place. Thank you both for coming along and giving evidence to us.

10:23 Meeting suspended.

10:25 On resuming—

  1. 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 89
  2. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 60
  3. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 40
  4. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  7. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  8. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
  9. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 18
  10. 12:15 Current Petitions Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.