link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02376)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02376)
I am told that this is my 215th session of First Minister’s question time. Later today, I will be proud to meet a group of young carers who have designed the young carers tartan, which I am proudly wearing. They have experience in care and have designed the tartan with Black Cherry Studio, which is a Scottish print design company. The design has been registered with the Scottish register of tartans and is available to anyone who has been in care. It is hoped that that will encourage more people with experience of care to claim their identity positively. I am proud to wear that tartan today.
link
Today is, of course, Alex Salmond’s last appearance at First Minister’s question time. His time as Scotland’s longest-serving First Minister will be properly acknowledged next Tuesday. In the meantime, I invite him just once to astound us all and actually answer a question—but briefly. Can I ask the First Minister, if he could describe himself in just one word, what would that be?
No. [Laughter.]
One word seems hardly adequate for that task, although I say to Fergus Ewing that his words might have been better addressed to the coming First Minister rather than the departing one.
link
As ever, the First Minister is in denial. I asked for one word, but I got a whole dictionary full.
There are many words that I could have used to describe the First Minister, such as “humble”, “sensitive”, “modest”, “meek” or perhaps even “bashful”.
It is interesting that the First Minister did not use the word “proud”. If I were him, I would not be entirely proud of the Government’s record, either. Teacher numbers, college places and national health service bed numbers are down, and waiting lists are up. [Interruption.]
Order.
link
This week, the First Minister has been giving advice to Nicola Sturgeon about who should be in her Cabinet. He knows that I always like to be helpful, so let me offer suggestions on perhaps who to keep out. How about Mike Russell for failing Scotland’s young people, Alex Neil for failing Scotland’s patients, or perhaps even Kenny MacAskill, who has been relegated today to the second row, for the many failings that appear on his charge sheet? Given their record of failure, which members of the First Minister’s Cabinet would he recommend should keep their jobs when his deputy takes over?
If there is a mood to miss, Jackie Baillie has an unerring ability to miss it.
I have been doing some research on these matters. Over the years, the Labour Party has called for the resignation of each and every one of my cabinet secretaries. The only person it has not called on to resign is me—and I am the one who is resigning. Does that not represent the Labour Party’s unerring ability to miss the target on each and every occasion?
link
First Minister, I think that I have captured the mood—you are going anyway.
The First Minister usually heaps such praise on his ministers. Clearly, they are in exceptionally good company. That admiration is usually reserved for Vladimir Putin or Rupert Murdoch.
The First Minister says that he is resigning because he lost the referendum campaign and believes that somebody has to take responsibility for that defeat. The referendum was his life’s ambition. He spent millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money on the referendum. He put Scotland on pause and, despite a derided United Kingdom coalition, he still lost by 400,000 votes.
The First Minister is going and the person who actually ran the yes campaign, Nicola Sturgeon, gets the keys to Bute house. However, Nicola Sturgeon’s record in government is not too clever, either. Child poverty and fuel poverty are growing, and house building is at its lowest level since the second world war.
We are told that the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister are joined at the hip. Is it not therefore the case that changing the First Minister will make very little difference?
I do not think that talking about changing leaders is the Labour Party’s strongest suit. Jackie Baillie is actually the 10th leader or caretaker leader I have faced over the dispatch box, and all of them have had the grace and charity with which she addresses the chamber. Nicola Sturgeon should be assured that, on the track record, once she becomes First Minister, the Labour Party will not ask for her resignation, because it only asks for the resignation of the Deputy First Minister and other cabinet secretaries.
The Administration has a substantial record of achievement over the past seven years. However, in many ways, it does not matter what I think about it—surely the issue is what the people of Scotland think about it. I remind Jackie Baillie that the Government was re-elected with an overall majority in a proportional Parliament. If we believe the more recent indications, that support seems to be growing, not diminishing. All in all, I think that I would rather stand here as First Minister, albeit departing, than as the 10th leader or caretaker leader who has faced me over the dispatch box.
link
I noticed the praise that the First Minister heaped on the Deputy First Minister, although perhaps he meant to do so only
“in terms of the debate”,
which might be a useful title for his autobiography.
I say genuinely that today marks the end of an era. No one can deny Alex Salmond’s passion for Scotland or his love of his country, but the tragedy is that he was so blinkered by his passion for independence that the powers that he already had to tackle poverty, reduce inequality and deliver social justice were pushed into second place. For the past seven years, the First Minister has used his age-old excuse that, somehow, it was Westminster’s fault. However, we hear that he wants to go back there and that he even believes that he could be the Deputy Prime Minister. He has gone from urging Scots to vote for Nick Clegg to wanting to be Nick Clegg.
Is it not the case that the First Minister’s real legacy is leaving Scotland more divided than ever? Before he answers, I know from his first response that brevity is not his strong point, so let me offer one final word to the First Minister: cheerio!
How can I break the mood? I say to Jackie Baillie that whoever stands for the Scottish National Party in the Westminster Parliament would seem, according to the present polls, to have a reasonable chance of success.
There have been substantial achievements, and I will name but two. The reintroduction of free education in Scotland strikes me as one. Looking forward, there is the introduction of free school meals in primary 1 to 3, again in the teeth of Labour opposition. I think that that is a substantial move forward in Scottish society.
Despite all the leaders I have faced from the Labour Party, there is a continuing failure of that party to address the decline or collapse in its fortunes. I will add a final piece of advice to Jackie Baillie, which she can translate to her leader, whoever it may be. People in Scotland no longer know what the Labour Party stands for, but they know who it stood with in the referendum campaign. Any political party that is in alliance with the Tory party is destined for destruction in Scotland, and that is exactly what is happening to the branch office that is before us now.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.