My adjectives were chosen to attract attention to the issue. One of the things that we have to think about is that we cannot change the system of the government of Scotland within the United Kingdom without thinking about the UK.
I spent 21 years as a specialist adviser to the Treasury Committee of the House of Commons and, at the end of those 21 years, became more and more depressed about the way that the UK runs its public finances. Budget day is a completely artificial occasion whereby the chancellor has to find some rabbit to pull out the hat to catch the Opposition off guard, and the things that catch people off guard are sometimes the ones that go spectacularly wrong in the longer term. One that I remember is Gordon Brown’s zero starter rate of corporation tax, which encouraged a lot of dubious incorporations.
If one is going to get a stable system working in which Scotland has significant policy control over income tax, the UK Government will have to bring its budget forward from March or April to November and engage the UK Parliament much more seriously in discussions about the budget. Basically, the Treasury Committee of the House of Commons does not fulfil its role as a tax and spend committee. It is heavily involved in other worthy things but does not act as a budget committee.
Under Calman, the Scottish Government has to notify by 30 November what the Scottish rate of income tax will be. In March or April, the UK Government can change rates and tax bands and control how much money will be brought in by the decisions that the Scottish Parliament took earlier. Therefore, one has to make sure that there is a basis for co-ordination of income tax. It is crucial that, once the Scottish Parliament gets beyond Calman-type income tax powers, there is some mechanism for co-ordination between the UK level and the Scottish level. As with broader issues such as monetary policy and control of the Bank of England, it is not obvious to me that the UK Government has even thought these things through.
10:30
The point about malign neglect relates to the question about resourcing of HM Revenue and Customs in the context of residence. Professor Kay made the point that residence matters, and it is fundamentally more important once income tax starts to be devolved than it was before. Previously, whether somebody was a Scottish income tax payer or other UK income tax payer might have been important in certain statistical analyses but it did not affect what tax people paid. One has to be careful to ensure that the Treasury-controlled HMRC puts enough resources into making sure that people’s residence decisions are truthfully declared.
I emphasised earlier that, with 42,000 people contributing a large or at least significant proportion of Scottish income tax revenues, that tax base is at risk. The UK Government could, if it wanted, attract tax payers by making changes in UK income tax.