Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Current Petitions

Organ Donation (Opt-out System) (PE1453)

Tuesday 28 October 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30 Petitions 26 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

26 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The next petition is PE1453, by Caroline Wilson, on behalf of the Evening Times and Kidney Research UK (Scotland), on an opt-out system for organ donation in Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk.

Again, I am sure that all members will wish to thank Caroline Wilson and the Evening Times for all their work. The committee has also done a lot of work on the matter. This is a first-class petition, and I note that Anne McTaggart has lodged a proposal for a member’s bill on the issue.

On the basis that the Scottish Government has made its position very clear and that there is a proposal for a member’s bill, the committee may now close the petition, as we have probably gone as far as we can. I am, as always, open to contrary views from members.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I will say what I am about to say with the best intentions. When we went through the petition and discussed it, we talked to the Welsh Government. As I have sympathy for the petition, I had hoped that we could have ensured that the required change was made once we had all the information. I am not sure—as I have said, I am saying this with the best intentions—that the member’s bill will not create dissension, certainly given the Government’s position; in fact, it might impact on or damage the outputs from the position that we basically all shared. I just wish that we had waited until we had more information.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will bring in Anne McTaggart, but before I do so I point out that the committee needs to decide what it can do and that we do not have a particular locus in what individual members do. The member happens to be here, but what she is doing is secondary to her role on the committee.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

First of all, convener, I declare an interest.

Now that the consultation period on the proposal for a bill has closed, I can share with the committee the information that there were 556 responses, around 80 per cent of which were for a change in the law. As a result, I would be quite concerned if we closed the petition. I hear what the convener says about the committee having done all that it can do, but there is still more to be done. More is happening out there. I am aware, for example, that the petitioner attended the Scottish Kidney Federation forum at the weekend. I simply think that there is still more to be done by the committee.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I cannot speak for all members, but it was clear during the debate on the petition that all members appreciated the great work done by the petitioner and the Evening Times. There is a lot of sympathy and good will.

However, my question about how we manage the petition is: what else can the committee do? If another practical next step could be taken, I would be the first on the barricades to demand it. I would like some practical managerial advice on the matter.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I very much sympathise with the view that you promote, convener. The practical next step is, in fact, the member’s bill that Anne McTaggart is taking forward. I have my own views on where the balance of evidence currently lies, but given that a member’s bill is being taken forward, I find it difficult to know what the committee would seek to do to advance the petition further. On that basis, I am content that its future progress will be through the member’s bill rather than through the committee.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I agree with Jackson Carlaw and Chic Brodie that there seems little purpose in keeping the petition open, given that a member’s bill is in progress, and with the comments that have been made.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am delighted that Anne McTaggart is taking forward a member’s bill. That might not have happened if we had not received the petition and the committee had not had the debate.

I note that if we close the petition but the member’s bill proposal does not go forward, there is nothing to stop the petition being reintroduced in the current session; indeed, I am sure that the committee will want to look at the issue again. There is tremendous good will among committee members in relation to the principle behind the petition. I am merely looking at our practical next steps; after all, we do not want to duplicate the parliamentary work that the member’s bill will rightly do.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I am aware that we have done loads of work on the issue, but given that there is on-going work in which the committee should remain involved, we should keep the petition open. For example, a poll commissioned by the British Heart Foundation Scotland from Ipsos MORI on the introduction of a soft opt-out system is due to be published in the next few weeks, and it is important that the committee looks at the figures and the poll’s outcome.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

No one questions the motivation behind Anne McTaggart’s bill proposal. However, I agree with Jackson Carlaw and Angus MacDonald. What would we do if the bill fell but we had kept open the petition, for which there is a degree of sympathy? The bill just about hits the petition on the head, and there would be a difficult recovery situation if the bill fell—although I am not saying that it will fall. We should close the petition and let the member’s bill go ahead.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I add a caveat to what I said. I have sympathy with any committee member who has a strong personal interest in a petition being kept open. I have expressed such an interest before and fellow committee members have sometimes supported me. Although I do not think that we are being invited to take additional formal practical action, and although I think that the arguments are more in line with closing the petition, if our keeping the petition open would assist Anne McTaggart, I would be happy for us to do so until a subsequent meeting, at which we could look at the matter again in light of what might have happened by then.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

If members think that we should defer closing the petition until a future meeting, at which point we will likely have had an update on the bill proposal, I am comfortable with such an approach.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I am happy to do that. It is just that in the course of debates on the bill most of the points that the petition raises will be considered. However, rather than kill it stone dead, we could keep the petition open.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

As the convener has said, we can close the petition, but if Anne McTaggart’s bill is not progressed the petitioner has the right to come back to the committee and we can reopen it. I am content to close the petition, with the proviso that the petitioner is made aware that they can come back if things do not go well with the member’s bill.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that Jackson Carlaw was suggesting that we keep the petition open pro tem and consider it at a future date.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

But at what future date do we consider it, given the time that it might take for the member’s bill to go through Parliament and reach an outcome? Does the petition stay on the committee’s books until an outcome is reached?

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I do not think that I would support such an approach. I thought that Anne McTaggart was saying that further information will become available in the immediate future, which will help us to judge whether we need to ask further questions. If the information did not prompt further questions, I would not suggest that the petition simply stay open for the duration of consideration of the member’s bill. It is only because our colleague feels strongly that we should keep the petition open that I am happy to facilitate such an approach for two or three months.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. We are perhaps talking about a deadline of early spring. If no further action was required, we could close the petition then.

John Wilson Ind Central Scotland
link

Might I seek clarification, convener? As I understand it, the member’s bill would be referred to the Health and Sport Committee, which means that the Public Petitions Committee could have a live petition while a bill was being considered by another committee. My question is: at what stage can we reconsider the petition? We need to think about that. When we refer a petition to another committee, it becomes that committee’s property. We need to be clear that if the member’s bill is referred to the Health and Sport Committee, it will become that committee’s property to deal with as it sees fit and will not lie within this committee’s jurisdiction.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

John Wilson is probably sensibly suggesting that as a compromise we refer the petition to the Health and Sport Committee, on the basis that that committee will look at Anne McTaggart’s bill. That way, all the evidence and the work that we have done will be considered by our colleagues who will consider the bill.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are other members content?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank John Wilson—also known as Henry Kissinger—who is very good at these kinds of compromises.

Again, I thank Caroline Wilson and the Evening Times, and I thank Anne McTaggart for the work that she has done on her member’s bill.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 99
  3. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  4. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. 10:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 26
  7. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 16
  8. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  9. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  11. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  12. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  14. 11:00 Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Evidence session · 8
  15. 11:15 Scotland’s National Action Plan on Human Rights Committee business · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.