Thank you, convener. Today, I am bringing to the committee a report on an issue arising from the audit of the Scottish Government consolidated accounts. The report is about the common agricultural policy—or CAP—futures programme, which is a five-year business change process to deliver CAP reform in Scotland.
The programme is currently expected to cost £137.3 million. It has two elements: first, the redesign of working practices to focus on the customer and generate efficiencies; and, secondly, the development of a new information technology system to deliver the new CAP and improved ways of working.
The programme is a significant one for the Government. Each year, it distributes approximately £700 million of European funding, through the CAP, to Scottish farmers and rural businesses, and any failure to meet the new European Commission regulations could lead to significant costs for the Scottish Government.
The purpose of my report is to highlight the significant risks that the programme is carrying. The Government recognises that risk in the governance statement that is included in its 2013-14 accounts. My report is based on a high-level review of progress in the first 18 months of the programme. We are undertaking more detailed work and will report on that as the programme reaches its critical milestones over the months ahead.
Overall, my report highlights that the programme has so far proved significantly more complex and challenging than the Government anticipated. The programme team has recognised that, and it has recognised that there is significant risk to the programme arising from the potential late delivery of milestones and also from increasing costs.
The business case for the programme was approved in December 2012. At that stage, detailed information on the EC requirements was not known. The programme has experienced continuing difficulties since then, and total forecast costs have increased from £88 million to £137 million as the team has had more detail on the EC requirements and the IT that is needed to deliver on them.
It is important to note that the programme is working to fixed regulatory timescales. Within the next three months, the team will have to make critical decisions about whether the new IT system will be ready to manage the payments application process or whether it needs to implement contingency plans.
In a bid to meet the timescales, the programme team has had to scale back some of the original scope of the business case, changing plans for the IT component to map registered land and removing some of the wider business change elements that were originally included.
Management acknowledge the difficulties and are taking action. The most recent independent assurance review, which was in May 2014, concluded that significant changes to the programme were required immediately if successful delivery was to be achieved, and as a result the programme board established a corrective action plan. There is evidence of progress against the plan, but it is too early to see whether the actions will increase the confidence in successful delivery by the required milestones.
I have concluded that the futures programme will carry significant risk right up until implementation and beyond. The purpose of my report is to bring that to the Parliament’s attention together with the continuing risks to successful delivery of the programme and overall value for money.
As always, convener, my colleagues and I are happy to answer questions from the committee.