link
Our second item of business is evidence from Professor David Bell and David Eiser from the University of Stirling’s division of economics, on their recently published paper, “Scotland’s Fiscal Future in the UK”.
The paper was circulated to members in advance of today’s meeting, so we will go straight to questions from the committee. As usual, I will start the questioning process.
Before we start, I point out that we have a full agenda today and are likely to be pressed for time. I therefore have to restrict each member’s questioning to no more than 10 minutes. I will also try to adhere to that timescale. I say to John Mason that that means no meandering when it comes to his turn. Either or both of our witnesses may answer questions that are put. It is completely up to them.
On options for further fiscal devolution, the third paragraph of page 5 of the paper says:
“The Labour Party’s proposals are somewhat more modest, amounting to an extension to the Scotland Act, so that the devolved part of income tax increases from 10p at each rate to 15p. The proposals also allow the Scottish Government to vary the progressivity of income tax, albeit in a fairly restrictive way”.
Any variation, of course, would be done so as not to reduce that progressivity. How would those proposals advantage or disadvantage Scotland?
