Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Landfill Allowances Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2005 (Draft)

Wednesday 2 March 2005 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

59 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I remind people to turn off their mobile phones, if they have not already done so, as it avoids embarrassment later.I welcome colleagues, members of the press and members of the public to our meeting. We have received apologies from Alasdair Morrison. Some visiting members are here this morning: John Home Robertson, Alasdair Morgan and Andrew Welsh. They are not required to come to the meeting, so they have come out of interest. We will come to the topic that they are interested in later.Agenda item 1 is subordinate legislation. We have one instrument to consider under the affirmative procedure: the draft Landfill Allowances Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2005. Parliament must approve the draft instrument before it can be formally made. The motion that is in front of the committee from the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Lewis Macdonald, invites us to recommend to the Parliament that we approve the instrument. I welcome the minister, who is here to move the motion, and his officials.The Subordinate Legislation Committee drew to our attention a couple of points of clarification that it sought, which have been provided by the Executive. Members have an extract of that committee's report.Our usual practice is to have a session to clarify any technical matters or to allow an explanation of detail while the minister's officials are at the table with him. When we reach the debate, the minister will be on his own. I invite the minister to make opening remarks on the purpose of the instrument.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you, convener. Like you, I am pleased that the ever-rising profile of environmental issues in the Parliament is attracting ever-greater attendance from members who are not on the committee. I hope that that is a sign of things to come.The regulations make an important contribution to our proposals for dealing with waste. They are part and parcel of our efforts to modernise waste management in Scotland in line with the national waste plan, which the committee considered last year. Members are aware that, through the strategic waste plan, we have provided indicative resources of almost £1 billion through to 2020 to assist local authorities to increase recycling and to develop new ways of treating waste. The landfill allowance scheme, to which the regulations relate, is closely linked to that and sets clear limits on the amount of biodegradable municipal waste that local authorities can send to landfill, so that they are in no doubt about their targets.The regulations come at the end of a very long process. The convener will recall, from her involvement, the consultation on the measures that led to the Waste and Emissions Trading Bill. Other members who were in the Parliament in November 2001 will remember the debate in the Parliament on that United Kingdom bill.The proposals are driven by our own ambitions, but part of the context is set by the European landfill directive, which places an obligation on member states to reduce dependence on landfill for the disposal of municipal waste. In the past, we have landfilled more than 90 per cent of our municipal waste. The landfill directive is targeted at biodegradable waste in order to reduce methane emissions—it is clear that that has wider significance in the context of greenhouse gases.The Waste and Emissions Trading Act 2003 provides that the limits on landfilling in that respect should be allocated among the four countries of the United Kingdom: England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The act allows ministers in those four countries to allocate landfill allowances to individual local authorities in a way that is consistent with the targets and which places a duty on local authorities not to landfill in excess of their holding of landfill allowances. That, in essence, is what is before the committee today.The regulations have been developed through two stages of consultation and further contacts with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on behalf of local government. In essence, the regulations provide for a register of allowances and an allocation to each local authority. They allow local authorities to bank, borrow or trade their allowances to meet their targets flexibly—trading will be introduced in 2008. They provide for the Scottish Environment Protection Agency to collect data to monitor the scheme and to calculate the landfill of biodegradable municipal waste from the data. They allow for the calculation of liability to penalties, should landfill in any year exceed the permitted allowance—taking account of borrowing, banking and trading—and they allow ministers to assess the level of any penalty to notify for payment.The penalties, which are clearly an important part of the regulations, are required by section 9 of the Waste and Emissions Trading Act 2003. We have introduced penalties in a phased way. The penalties are based on an assessment of tonnage of excess landfill multiplied by £10 per tonne in the first year—2005-06; £25 per tonne in the following year; £50 per tonne in the year after that—2007-08; and £150 per tonne from 2008-09.Provision is made for liability to supplementary penalties should the UK fail to meet its target. We hope that that will not happen, but provision for the possibility must be made. Before any penalty for which the regulations provide is imposed, ministers will consult the local authority in question and consider representations from the authority before proceeding to the next stage. The 2003 act, which governs the regulations, allows ministers to waive liability to penalties, including liability to interest on the penalties.The provision in regulations for liability to substantial penalties is a serious matter. However, of course it is not our intention that the powers should ever be required; our intention is that the targets should act, along with the very substantial grant support that we are providing, to ensure that local authorities are enabled and encouraged to meet their obligations. The provision for liability to penalties signals to everyone that the targets have great importance. It is for all of us to work together to reach the targets and our intention is that the regulations should underpin a partnership approach, whereby the Scottish Executive works with the UK Government and local authorities work with the Scottish Executive to achieve our objectives.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I invite members to ask questions or raise matters for clarification.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to ask about equity across local authorities. Correct me if I am wrong, but I understand that local authorities in areas in which the recycling and composting of biodegradable municipal waste can be done at low cost will perform quite well and will be able to build up credits that they can trade with local authorities that are doing less well, because the cost of recycling and composting is high in their areas. Will that create environmental justice problems in that some local authorities, in particular in rural areas, will be unable to recycle and compost as much as other authorities can do, so landfill sites in their areas will be open for longer? Such an approach would create an imbalance in the performance of different local authorities.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

We acknowledge the importance of your point. I do not think that there is a particular urban/rural aspect to the matter, but I acknowledge that some authorities—in urban and in rural areas—will be in a better position than others will be to meet the targets. We chose the option that involves banking, borrowing and eventually trading in allowances so that we could put into the system the flexibility that we think will allow authorities that have a built-in advantage to press ahead and authorities that will inevitably need longer to make the investments to engage in trading and other mechanisms, so that they are not unduly penalised before they are in a position to meet their targets.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Year-on-year targets will apply to each local authority. Will targets be set at different levels for different authorities? Will there be a cap-and-trade system, whereby allowances will eventually start to be reduced year on year?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

In essence, the overall target is set to decline over the period in question. The target of 1.8 million tonnes in 2005-06—the figure is broadly the same as the amount of biodegradable municipal waste that went to landfill in the last full year for which we have figures—is set to fall to 1.32 million tonnes by 2009-10.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is the Scotland target. Within that target, each local authority will be given an allocation, as was set out in the consultation document. The targets will have the force of the regulations for each local authority, but we will encourage local authorities to trade if that helps them. In other words, the targets are clear and firm, but they are not targets within which there is no flexibility or room for manoeuvre.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Will you clarify a couple of matters? First, allowances are set to achieve the Scottish target. Is the Scottish target a contribution towards the UK target?

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Did the UK Government therefore have an influence over the extent of the Scottish target?

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I assume that the UK set a target, after which Scotland had to negotiate its target as part of that?

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Secondly, as I am sure that the minister is aware, COSLA contacted the committee to indicate its opposition to the proposed scheme. In its briefing to the committee, COSLA says:"the proposed scheme has the potential to increase the risk of the targets not being met."It goes on to say:"Levels of waste growth are, in most cases, outwith the control of local authorities".If COSLA, which represents most of our councils, is opposed to the regulations, what was the response of the other consultees?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

The general thrust of the consultation responses was recognition of the need to take measures to reach the targets that have been set. We consulted individual local authorities, COSLA and other interested parties, including the landfill operators. The general response to the consultation was that action needs to be taken to make progress in that regard. Charles Stewart Roper might like to give some detail on the responses.

Charles Stewart Roper Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

Most of the responses that we received were from the local authority sector and they broadly reflect the concerns that COSLA raised.We received a few responses from industry representatives who, in general, are strongly in favour of the scheme and want us to press ahead with it quickly. They said that they are in favour of high levels of penalties at an early stage and of getting the scheme up and running quickly. That was the flavour of the responses from the industry.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Given the relationship between our target and the UK targets, how do our projected percentage decreases compare with those in the rest of the UK?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I am not familiar with the figures for England and Wales. Charles Stewart Roper might have the information, however.

Charles Stewart Roper Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

The basic figure for the landfill directive target year—the 2009-10 figure—is based on our share of the data in the 1995 baseline year, which is the landfill directive baseline year. The basic target—the landfill directive target—was divvied out between the different parts of the United Kingdom purely on the basis of data that were available for 1995. In a sense therefore, no discretion was available to us.Our track from now to 2009-10—the shape of our line between now and the landfill directive target deadline—is based on a decision of the Scottish ministers. The figures appear in a UK statutory instrument, but that is how the WET act works. The figures were set by Scottish ministers and communicated to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, where they were built into its regulation.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

What will the effect of the penalties be on the voluntary environmental groups that have been contracted by local authorities to recycle or facilitate the reuse of furniture, for example? Highland Council has contracted a certain amount of tonnage from such organisations, yet the necessary recycling centres have not been set up to collect the materials. I am anxious that the penalties are not passed on to voluntary groups who, through no fault of their own, are unable to meet the targets.The voluntary groups tell me that the council told them that they must speak to the Executive on the matter. However, the Executive told the groups that they must speak to the council. I have been in touch with Ross Finnie's office, but I would appreciate the minister saying something on the subject.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I am happy to comment. I am familiar with the specifics of the matter that the member has raised; I think that I am right in saying that it concerns Lochaber environmental group and Homemade Caithness, both of which are in the category that the member described. We will meet those groups shortly to discuss how their issues might be addressed.It is important to distinguish between the strategic waste fund and the funding that it provides for specific projects to go forward and the targets. In a sense, the regulations are a response to a failure to meet targets. They set limits on the amounts that can go to landfill, whereas the strategic waste fund promotes alternatives. If projects are in difficulty in relation to funding from the strategic waste fund, there may be other methods by which funding could be provided to allow them to continue dealing with waste issues in ways that help us to meet our overall target.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Can the minister enlighten us on the subject of voluntary recycling as an activity in other areas of Scotland? Does Highland have fewer contracted voluntary recycling projects such as those that Maureen Macmillan described? I would like to get a flavour of the predicament in which Highland finds itself now that it has those targets to meet.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

All local authorities face targets. In any case, there would be no point in setting targets if we did not think that they would make a difference. Of course, local authorities will regard the targets as demanding; that will be as true for Highland Council as it will be for every other council. The combination of measures from the council and from voluntary bodies will vary from area to area, but the general pattern is that, although councils are taking forward a lot of their own work, they are engaging with providers in the voluntary sector—and, in some cases, in the private sector—where appropriate and where such actions support their efforts to meet targets.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I hear what the minister has said, but there has been no indication of percentages. At the moment, it might be too difficult to secure an answer to that question from other local authority areas. Problems with the on-going transportation of landfill waste to Peterhead and Perth from Highland show that, because of issues such as sparsity, the council still has a long way to go to catch up. I wonder whether your allocations take into account the long period of underinvestment that has brought Highland Council to this position.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

They certainly should do so. For example, the consultation document shows that, in 2005-06, Highland Council's BMW to landfill allowance is 86,216 tonnes. That figure is derived from the status quo. By 2009-10, Highland should have reduced landfilling of BMW to 60,817 tonnes, and that also broadly reflects its share of the overall allowance.The process by which councils will get from where they are today to where we want them to be by the end of the period will vary from area to area and will be tougher for some. Some will face the challenges earlier and others later. As a result, the banking, borrowing and trading allowances have been designed to help councils that have to meet particularly difficult challenges while ensuring that every council works towards meeting these demanding targets.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

The baseline assumption is that 63 per cent by weight of the municipal waste that is collected is biodegradable, and I presume that councils receive brownie points for whatever is extracted from that. If a council can encourage its residents to compost at home, is there any way of measuring that contribution to its overall effort?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I do not know whether Charles Stewart Roper can provide a technical answer to that question. I admit that no such answer immediately occurs to me.

Charles Stewart Roper Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

I am afraid to say that, although much thought has been given to that matter, no full conclusion has been reached. Obviously, stimulating a tonne of home composting would mean a tonne less municipal waste—of which, as you said, 63 per cent would be biodegradable. As a result, the council in question would not receive any credit for the other element that you mentioned, because all material from home composting is biodegradable.It is very difficult to capture and measure such amounts. That said, it is still worth stimulating such activity, because we need to reduce waste arisings generally. As for measuring the content of municipal waste, we hope that more home composting will mean a lower proportion of such waste. As a result, that 63 per cent figure might fall or might not rise as much as it would otherwise. Although there is a mechanism for feeding back information, there is no immediate way of capturing the full volume of home composting. It is simply a very difficult thing to measure.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I am glad that I am not the only one who does not have a full technical answer to that question. However, the general answer is that councils should not be penalised under this system for being more successful than they are required to be.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

Would a voluntary scheme have enabled us to meet our targets?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

If we had introduced a scheme that did not have regulatory requirements, we would have run a greater risk of missing our targets. We were required to establish a mechanism to make it as likely as possible that we would meet those targets in time.I do not need to tell members that the consequences of failing to hit the targets—which would result in fines of up to €500,000 a day—would be a most regrettable failure to achieve our environmental objectives and would have a regrettable impact on Scottish public expenditure. Therefore, the scheme is designed to make it more likely that we will hit our targets by assigning responsibility to local authorities for the areas for which they are responsible and providing them with a degree of flexibility that will, we hope, make it equally easy for councils in different parts of the country to make their contribution over the period in question.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We have given the points of clarification a bit of a going over, so we move to formal consideration of the motion.

Motion moved,

That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Landfill Allowances Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2005 be approved.—Lewis Macdonald.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Everyone in the committee is in favour of reducing the amount of waste that goes to landfill, which has been a big issue in recent years. The debate is not about whether there should be regulations to achieve that objective—there is probably quite a good case for such regulations—but about what the nature of those regulations should be. I am slightly concerned about that. The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, which has contacted us, says:"This power introduces a degree of uncertainty that is unlikely to assist in long term planning or to promote the establishment of an effective trading regime."It might be worth while inviting some of the local authorities and SEPA to give evidence to the committee before we take a decision on the motion, rather than just rubber-stamping the regulations.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We could put back the decision to next week if necessary, but I would be happy to take it today, because we have COSLA's representations and we have been able to question the minister on the matter. Unless you want to propose formally that we put our decision back to next week, I would be keen to take it today.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The clerk has advised me that, if you had wanted to do that, you should have made that proposal before the minister moved the motion. We are now considering the motion, so we have to address it.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

How can I do that without hearing the minister's response to the debate?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

You will not be able to do that. You should have made your proposal earlier. We are now in the middle of a debate, the motion has been moved and I have opened the discussion to arguments for and against the motion. You would have to vote against the motion and, if it was not agreed to, the Executive would have to decide whether to bring it back to the committee.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

What is the point of giving members the opportunity to get points of clarification from the minister if they are not allowed to respond to them?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

You should have made your point before we began the formal debate. That is the point of the clarification process.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

If you have such strong feelings that you would rather not agree to the motion without having a lengthier discussion with other representations and more evidence, your only option is to vote against the motion. I realise that that is not an easy situation, but we have procedures to follow, which is partly to be fair to everybody.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

I will make a more positive contribution. It is good to see a phased introduction of a response to a European directive; I have been on the receiving end on occasions on which we have ignored a European directive until we are right up against infraction procedures, which is not a happy place to be. It is entirely right to introduce measures that we have to take in response to European directives in the time that we are given, which is given to us to enable such phased introduction. I welcome the regulations.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am minded to support the motion, but I would like reassurance from the minister that he will target the strategic waste fund at those local authorities that have particular difficulties and which incur particularly high costs in diverting compostable waste from the waste stream. I would not like us to be in a situation in a few years' time in which those local authorities that have great difficulties are using the tradable quota credit system to buy their way out of dealing with the problems that they face.Nora Radcliffe's point about the contribution of domestic composting was well made. I would like the committee to hear about a mechanism for bringing that into the system—whether it is part of the trading system or whatever. Composting must be factored in.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

I am minded to support the motion, but I have concerns about what Mark Ruskell said. I do not want matters to be skewed too much one way. Some authorities have taken difficult decisions, which have had consequences, to have landfill in their areas. Some authorities have diverted landfill to other areas, but they should not be rewarded when other authorities have had to take hard decisions for which they have been unpopular.It will not be easy for any local authority to meet the targets, but if the nation is to meet its targets, we must encourage each local authority to do its bit and, in turn, each household to do its bit. Some local authorities can do far more to encourage recycling and reuse, rather than simply stuffing waste in a bag and sending it to the dump.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It is positive to examine how the scheme will be applied. We will have to review how it works in practice. It is all very well to say that the instrument is positive, but it is a fact that people started with handicaps that have never been caught up with. Mark Ruskell talked about what makes it difficult for Highland Council and other authorities to meet the conditions, whether or not they take hard decisions. COSLA has suggested that the scheme is probably not the best way in which to proceed.What I am saying is not negative; I am just unhappy with the suggestion that some people are not pulling their weight. Members should respect the fact that local knowledge suggests that we must be careful about what we say, so that the whole country is taken along. I am unhappy about the tone that has developed, because not enough understanding has been shown of the difficulties that are faced in some areas.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The scheme is positive in the sense that it is clear. I read the Executive's statement of the options that were available to it and the fines of €500,000 a day should concentrate everybody's minds. We all agree that we should send less waste to landfill and that we should recycle more, but without a stick to concentrate the mind, it is difficult for local authorities to prioritise expenditure and staff time. The strategic waste fund gives authorities an opportunity to plan.I am glad that ministers have developed a phased implementation scheme. The situation will have to be monitored, but after examining the alternatives, I think that the scheme provides room for flexibility while setting a clear target. The Executive needs to talk more to local authorities to ensure that everybody is engaged and is on target to implement the scheme.I agree with Karen Gillon's comments about what local authorities do by way of campaigns to communicate with the public. Edinburgh has a waste awareness campaign to encourage people to use resources more wisely and to create less waste. Nora Radcliffe's points about composting were bang on. Over time, it would be useful to capture that. I hope that the Executive will commit to considering that.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

It is important to recognise COSLA's concerns, which have been mentioned. COSLA has worked closely with us and has been fully involved in the consultation process. The scheme differs in several respects from that which applies elsewhere in the UK, largely as a result of the effectiveness of that consultation process. For instance, we have adopted a phased approach, which means that the penalties in the first three years will be less severe than they will be in succeeding years. I think that I am right in saying that that is unique in the UK: Scotland is the only country that has taken such an approach. That will meet some of the concerns that local authorities have.To meet our obligations, the regulations must be in place by 1 April, so I am glad that the committee is discussing them today. That is important. We are keen to ensure that the concerns that local government has expressed continue to be addressed. It is important that that should be the case. To achieve our objectives, we need stick and carrot. We would not expect the stick to be as popular as the carrot. What we are proposing is proportionate to the objectives that we have set. Broadly, Scotland's local authorities are willing partners in the process of reducing landfill, so I expect that they will work with us closely on that.An issue that councils have raised is what factors will be considered when penalties are applied. I re-emphasise that the regulations give ministers discretion in the application of penalties. We would want to consider such matters as whether a local authority had received grants for tackling waste issues or had experienced unexpected growth in waste that might have made a difference to its ability to achieve the targets. A perfectly legitimate reason for not quite meeting a target might be unforeseen delays in commissioning plant. In such circumstances, we would want to know what the council had done about any deficiency on its part. We have designed the trading scheme to allow councils collectively to address such deficiencies and to reduce their impact on any one council.The strategic waste fund must be cost effective. We have discussed with local authorities and others whether allowances might be redistributed as we proceed, to reflect the fact that different councils face different difficulties. If some councils obtain better support from the strategic waste fund that allows them to provide more low-cost solutions, we might want to talk to them about the redistribution of their allowances. In any case, the opportunity for trading will mean that councils will be able to reduce their costs. Concerns have been raised about the provision for ministers to suspend trading but, again, we would take into account all the different factors.The regulations are about working with councils to achieve agreed objectives. We are all signed up to the achievement of those objectives and the regulations provide the proper basis for us, together with local authorities, to make progress on them in the future.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The question is, that motion S2M-2405, in the name of Lewis Macdonald, be agreed to.

Motion agreed to.

That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Landfill Allowances Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2005 be approved.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I thank Lewis Macdonald and his officials. I ask the deputy minister to stay in his place for item 2.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 2 March 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 59
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 120
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
  5. Climate Change Inquiry Committee business · 108

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.