To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02303)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Johann Lamont Lab 4
- Tricia Marwick 2
- George Adam SNP 1
- Neil Findlay Lab 1
The record
14 contributionsWith your permission, Presiding Officer, the Government will make an announcement this afternoon, and I want to give the chamber notice of it.
It is over 20 years since the poll tax came to an end, and I believe that the expanded electoral roll should not be used to collect poll tax debts. It is, of course, within the law for councils to use current information to assess current council tax liability and, given that the council tax reduction scheme protects 500,000 of our poorest citizens, the tax is being applied in a proper and fair way. However, the relevance of information from the current electoral register to the position of debts from 25 years ago is difficult to fathom except through some misguided political intention. The total amount of poll tax debt that was collected around Scotland last year was £396,000. I therefore announce today that it is the Government’s intention to bring forward legislation to ensure that councils can take no further action to recover ancient poll tax debts. After 25 years, it is about time that the poll tax was dead and buried in Scotland. [Applause.]
It would have been helpful, First Minister, if I had had some indication that you intended to make an announcement. The Parliament might have been better served by a statement at some point during today’s business.
I look forward to the First Minister’s legislative programme and to his ending the underfunding of local government full stop.
Let us get back to First Minister’s question time. This week, we learned that the Scottish Government is failing to meet its targets for cancer treatment waiting times and that we are flying in consultants from India to cover weekend staffing shortages. The health service that the First Minister made front and centre of his failed referendum campaign is facing £0.5 billion of cuts that his Government refuses to acknowledge. Against that backdrop, how is the First Minister’s golf handicap coming along?
Two things: the performance against the 31-day cancer treatment target is 96.3 per cent in Scotland, which is above the 95 per cent target, and the performance against the 62-day target is 92.9 per cent, which is below the target but a significant improvement not just on the previous quarter but on any figure that was achieved when the Labour Party was in power. Johann Lamont will remember that the target was never met in any quarter over the entire time that the Labour Party was in power. The figure of 92.9 per cent is short of the target but significantly higher than the achievements in both England and Wales. Nonetheless, we must strive to meet our cancer targets in full, because they are hugely important for the Scottish people.
The national health service budget will increase in real terms next year. Mr Swinney will announce budget proposals for the following year in his announcement next week. Johann Lamont can be absolutely certain that the Government will honour its commitment to ensure that the front-line national health service budget continues to increase in real terms—something that was not promised by the Labour Party either in 2007 or in the run-up to the 2011 election. I suspect that that is one of the key reasons why the Government is trusted on the national health service and the coalition of Opposition parties is not.
link
The First Minister might not be aware of this, but Dr Peter Bennie, the chair of the British Medical Association Scotland, has asked for “an honest, public debate”. The First Minister’s response fails on every single count and reveals a degree of complacency that even I am astonished by.
Just weeks before Scotland made the decision to vote no, the chief executives of our health boards held crisis talks with Scottish Government officials about the future of the NHS. They warned that £0.5 billion of cuts were coming down the line. After two years of dismissing the daily warnings of staffing shortages, missed targets and failures in patient care, is the First Minister now willing to have the real debate about the future of our NHS that the health boards are asking for, or is he going to concentrate his time on the golf course while we wait for Nicola Sturgeon’s coronation before getting back to work?
I will respond on those two specific points. The 92.9 per cent performance figure, which we are not complacent about, which is why we are working to bring it up to 95 per cent and beyond, compares with 84.5 per cent, which was the figure for the last quarter when the Labour Party was in office.
Johann Lamont seems surprised and perplexed that I should mention that. I merely say—quite rightly in my view—to the Labour Party and the Opposition in general that while the 92.9 per cent achievement of the target is not good enough, it seems relevant to point out that the figure was 84.5 per cent when Labour left office. Of course, the health minister of the day hailed the cancer and accident and emergency target performances as great achievements of the Labour Party in office. If 84.5 per cent was a great achievement, how come 92.9 per cent is totally inadequate? We work to improve the figures all the time.
The real-terms budget of the front-line NHS will continue to increase. That is not a commitment that was made by the Labour Party in opposition, never mind when it was in government in 2007. It is also not a commitment that has been redeemed by the Labour Party in office in Wales, which is facing the same political and economic pressures from the Westminster Government.
Let me repeat: Scotland’s national health service real-terms budget will continue to increase on the front line.
If anyone is “surprised and perplexed”, it will be the people across this country and the staff and the patients who listened to that answer and wonder whether the First Minister ever understands what is going on in the real world. His own leaked papers say:
“There is collective agreement from the leadership across all the professional management and clinical groups that planning for immediate transformational change is necessary and difficult; but radical and urgent decisions need to be made ... The status quo and preservation of existing models of care are no longer an option given the pressing challenges we face.”
Let me recap: “immediate”, “necessary”, “urgent” and “pressing”—those are not my words but those of the people running our NHS. After two years of dismissing the problems in our health service, how long must the people of Scotland wait before the Government accepts the scale of the challenge and gets round to fixing our NHS?
Let us look at the pressures on the national health service. There is the revaluation of pensions through a Westminster Government decision; there is the withdrawal of the national insurance rebate, which is another Westminster Government decision; and there are staff costs identified as a pressure. What are the staff costs that are particular to the Scottish national health service? It was our decision to increase the pay of nurses and other staff—that pay increase was not reflected south of the border, where strike action is faced as a result of the betrayal of national health service staff. All that indicates to me and, I suspect, to the people of Scotland, that, in order to protect and preserve our national health service, we have to control its finances, not just the administration.
The pressures—and there are pressures—on our health service are coming as a consequence of Westminster Government decisions, which is why it makes the Labour Party’s incredible decision to campaign hand in glove and shoulder to shoulder with the Conservative Party something that it will pay a heavy price for in the coming weeks and months.
Scotland’s doctors and NHS managers agree that we need action to fix an NHS that was described by the BMA as a “car crash”. For two years, Scotland has been on pause while Alex Salmond fought his referendum. Now he has gone part time and there is no programme for government.
What we see here is a rerunning of the referendum argument, with the First Minister blaming Westminster rather than taking responsibility and running the country. We deserve better from the First Minister of Scotland than simply that response. There can be no doubt that our health service will come under even further pressure this winter and action is needed. When will the Government get back to work and fix our NHS?
The national health service budget has risen by 3 per cent in real terms over the Government’s term of office—an increase in the front-line budget over and above inflation. In Wales, the national health service budget has fallen 3.6 per cent in real terms under a Labour Administration.
This is Scotland.
Mr Findlay!
Johann Lamont seems to shrug away the many indications that the Labour Party’s decision to campaign shoulder to shoulder with the Conservative Party will cost it dear. The BBC says that
“It was right to join Tories”
according to Johann Lamont. Unfortunately for her, that is not the view of Labour Party supporters in Scotland—or should I say former Labour Party supporters? I have just been handed the indications from the latest Panelbase poll, to be released today. [Interruption.] Well, I will not read out the whole thing for Alex Johnstone’s benefit, because it is very bad news for the Conservative Party as well. However, there is a 15-point lead for the Scottish National Party, which is ahead at Westminster.
Modesty forbids me from mentioning the trust ratings for the various political leaders—mine in particular—but let me say that all of the unionist party coalition are negative on trust. That does not surprise me. Nicola Sturgeon emerges with glowing trust ratings, and I am sure that she will take up the cudgels in the future.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 Oct 2014 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Craighouse Development (Planning Application) Questions · 8
- Barnett Formula Questions · 8
- National Resilience Centre (Role of Dumfries and Galloway Council) Questions · 4
- United Kingdom Government Debt (Implications) Questions · 6
- Looked-after Children (Educational Outcomes) Questions · 4
- Ebola Questions · 4
- Dumfries Hospital Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Welfare Reform First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Armed Police (Convention of Scottish Local Authorities Position) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Employment First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Universal Postal Service (Competition) Members’ business · 13
- Food (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 46
- Food (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.