Less than 1 per cent of health board expenditure goes to the private sector in Scotland. The figure in England is already 6 per cent. According to the Labour Party, it is heading towards 20 per cent. To describe a software or an IT system as an example of privatisation when, incidentally, the company already provides such systems to the health boards in Scotland and has done so since 1998, is—[Interruption.]
Well—this is what has happened to the Labour Party. I have said before that The Telegraph has become its house journal. If the Daily Mail has become the source material for the Labour Party, we can see why its questions get ever more ridiculous. [Interruption.]
Tricia MarwickThe Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
MSD Informatics, the company concerned, has supplied software to the national health service across the United Kingdom since 1998, which means by definition that Tony Blair must have been privatising the health service in 1998. Actually, I think that he started the process of privatisation when the Labour Party pushed through foundation hospitals in the NHS in England.
Scottish health boards were involved in the design and management of existing systems to calculate payments to GP practices across Scotland. An IT system does not represent privatisation of the national health service, nor does a £450 million cost pressure over the next two years—[Interruption.]
The cost pressures are caused both by pensions and by the ending of the national insurance rebate, which involve decisions that were taken by the Westminster Government. Does that not exemplify the position of the Scottish Government, which is that cost pressures originating from Westminster have a huge impact on the Scottish national health service? [Interruption.]
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
The position for the Scottish health service is simple: if there is a move to privatisation and the introduction of charging—and therefore a lowering of public spending—south of the border, it impacts on the finances of the Scottish health service. That is why if we are to keep our national health service in public hands we have to control both the finances and the administration. That is what we should do, that is what we intend to do, and that is what is supported by the overwhelming majority of the Scottish people.
Tricia MarwickThe Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
There has been a huge increase in private spending on the First Minister’s watch—and he knows it.
Perhaps the First Minister can break the habits of a lifetime and indulge in a little truthmongering. He claimed—and now appears to continue to claim—that the NHS would be privatised if there was a no vote, but as he said that, he was increasing the amount of public money that is being spent on private health providers. Six weeks before the referendum, the First Minister privatised the health records of every person in Scotland. Will he just admit that he has done more to privatise the NHS in Scotland than any other politician in history?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
I am delighted to confirm to Parliament that we have increased health service spending on the front line in real terms, and that we will continue to do so. I am delighted to tell Parliament that the vast majority of people in Scotland understand why we have to control the finances of this country and our health service, as well as the administration, if we are to be protected from Tory and Labour attempts to privatise our health service.
Johann Lamont says that she will retain her current position. I hope that she continues to behave as she has done and continues to lead the Opposition in this Parliament for a considerable time. If she does, however, it will not be because of the enthusiastic support of her colleagues. I quote:
“The catastrophic thing would be for her to go and not to have Jim”
Murphy
“as leader. If we end up with an MSP or Anas Sarwar, we might as well all go home in 2016.”
I am not as pessimistic about the Labour Party’s prospects as the Labour Party is. I am sure that Johann Lamont will put up an excellent fight in the coming election and will end up exactly where she is now, as the Scottish National Party continues to keep the national health service in public hands.
Getting an IT system and the use of a computer system from a company that already provides IT systems to general practitioners across Scotland does not constitute privatisation of the national health service. What it constitutes is having a better IT system than we have at present.
Johann Lamont has argued that I should beware of my anointed successor, but I have read in the papers that there seems to be a number of anointed successors for her. [Laughter.] However, she can be confident in having the support of the members of Parliament whom she leads at Westminster. The Herald quotes one MP, when
“asked if Ms Lamont was under threat”
as saying:
“‘Yes. People will rally round but the sharks will be circling.’”
I say to Johann Lamont that one leadership election in the political parties in Scotland is enough at any one time—[Interruption.]
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
I know that the Parliament will allow me to note that today is the funeral of Iain MacCormick, the late member of Parliament for Argyll. Mr Swinney is attending on behalf of the Scottish Government. Iain was the brother of Neil MacCormick and the son of John MacCormick, the greater home ruler. He was a fine member of Parliament for Argyll. He went to vote terminally ill last Thursday, because he wanted to cast his vote in the referendum in person. We will all miss him very much indeed.
Tricia MarwickThe Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
On our side, we of course send our condolences to Iain MacCormick’s family at what is a very sad time.
For the past six weeks, the First Minister has warned the people of Scotland—some might even say that he has misled them—that the national health service would be privatised if there was a no vote. Last week, there was a vote and we now know that it is the sovereign will of the people of Scotland to stay strong in the United Kingdom.
Some weeks before that no vote, the First Minister of Scotland privatised the medical records of every Scot in the country. Why did he keep that quiet until after the referendum? Is not it the case that Alex Salmond has done more to privatise the NHS than anyone else in Scottish history?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
—but we can be absolutely confident that whatever happens, a lot more people will vote in the SNP leadership election than will vote in the Labour Party one.
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
No, that is not the case. The Scottish primary care information resource is an information technology system, which replaces another IT system. To describe a contract for the Scottish primary care information resource as “privatisation” is like saying that this Parliament is being privatised because we use the Windows system in our computers. It is a ridiculous argument to put forward. The SPIRE system gives very substantial advantages in terms of collection and governance of information throughout the national health service. It is right and proper that the Government has sought and received guarantees on the data’s security. That is absolutely the right thing to do.
Johann Lamont, who denied this—indeed, I think that Alistair Darling said that no Government would privatise the NHS—should have a look at what Andy Burnham has been saying at the Labour Party conference, confirming the route for privatisation and charging that the Labour Party believes is going on at Westminster at the present moment. Given that that is now being confirmed by the Labour Party, will there be some acceptance of the knock-on effect that that has in Scotland in terms of finance and the critical importance for Scotland’s future of controlling not just the administration, but the finances of our national health service?
It might be a while since we last had an exchange of questions and answers, but that is no more credible than anything else that the First Minister has said in answers over the past period.
The First Minister, and his anointed successor, Nicola Sturgeon, have increased the number of NHS patients who are treated privately by almost 500 per cent. He spends £100 million of public money on private healthcare. This Government privatised our health records during a campaign in which the First Minister claimed that the health service would be privatised if we did not vote for him and—guess what—he was privatising it anyway. Now that the campaign is over, will the First Minister be honest with the people of Scotland and admit that he is doing more to privatise the NHS than anyone else in Scotland?
Tricia MarwickThe Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
As an optimist, I hope that the coronation of Nicola Sturgeon will ensure that she answers a question or two, which is something that her boss is evidently not able to do.
But, to the serious business of this Government. We now know, because of the courage of a whistleblower, about the £450 million-worth of cuts that the First Minister is planning for the NHS, but decided not to tell us about until after the referendum. During the referendum campaign, the First Minister secretly privatised the health records of every Scot while warning—[Interruption.] It is astonishing that he was privatising the health records of every Scot while warning of the dangers of privatisation. The First Minister has increased spending on private healthcare to £100 million. I ask him: why does he say that he is against privatising the health service when that is exactly what he is doing? When was he planning to tell us about the £100 million spend on private health? When was he going to tell us about the privatisation of our health records? When was he going to tell us, in honesty, about the half a billion pounds-worth of cuts to our precious health service?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.