1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02132)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02132)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Excellent. We are always delighted when the First Minister keeps his eye on the ball.
The Scottish Government has missed its 18-week waiting time target from referral to treatment. Month after month, it still fails to hit its target of treating accident and emergency patients within four hours, even after diluting the target. Bedblocking—which means people left languishing in beds because the care system has nowhere for them to go—has gone up 300 per cent.
The national health service is going backwards on the First Minister’s watch. Can he remind us why he still has confidence in his health secretary, Alex Neil?
The Scottish Government has missed its 18-week waiting time target from referral to treatment. Month after month, it still fails to hit its target of treating accident and emergency patients within four hours, even after diluting the target. Bedblocking—which means people left languishing in beds because the care system has nowhere for them to go—has gone up 300 per cent.
The national health service is going backwards on the First Minister’s watch. Can he remind us why he still has confidence in his health secretary, Alex Neil?
Johann Lamont started off by saying that she is delighted. Somehow, the words “delighted” and “Johann Lamont” do not square at First Minister’s questions.
All of us should agree that the NHS is facing a substantial challenge. It is treating many more patients. I think that all of us agree that the people who work in the NHS are doing a tremendous job for Scotland.
We always want to do better, and a lot of the statistics need to be improved. That is what we intend to ensure happens. However, we should remember two things. First, the satisfaction levels with the NHS in Scotland among the patients—the people who experience treatment in the NHS—are extremely high. Secondly, if we compare the statistics that were released this week with what was happening when Johann Lamont was a minister, we can see substantial improvement. Because she mentioned accident and emergency services in particular, I remind the Labour benches that Andy Kerr, who was then the Minister for Health and Community Care, was delighted with a performance of 87 per cent in the health service. The figure that Johann Lamont is complaining about now is 93 per cent. Yes, there is substantial room for improvement, but it is passing strange that the Labour Party was delighted with 87 per cent when it was in office but condemns 93 per cent when the Scottish National Party is in office.
All of us should agree that the NHS is facing a substantial challenge. It is treating many more patients. I think that all of us agree that the people who work in the NHS are doing a tremendous job for Scotland.
We always want to do better, and a lot of the statistics need to be improved. That is what we intend to ensure happens. However, we should remember two things. First, the satisfaction levels with the NHS in Scotland among the patients—the people who experience treatment in the NHS—are extremely high. Secondly, if we compare the statistics that were released this week with what was happening when Johann Lamont was a minister, we can see substantial improvement. Because she mentioned accident and emergency services in particular, I remind the Labour benches that Andy Kerr, who was then the Minister for Health and Community Care, was delighted with a performance of 87 per cent in the health service. The figure that Johann Lamont is complaining about now is 93 per cent. Yes, there is substantial room for improvement, but it is passing strange that the Labour Party was delighted with 87 per cent when it was in office but condemns 93 per cent when the Scottish National Party is in office.
I promise the First Minister that I will be delighted when he stops displaying such disgraceful complacency about what is happening in the NHS. It is patients and others who are expressing concerns, not simply politicians. It would appear that, although the First Minister says that he is reflecting on the statistics, he does not believe them, because they show that the NHS on his watch is failing. Will he listen, then, to the professionals?
Dr Clifford Mann, the president of the College of Emergency Medicine, said:
“The college has been warning for some time now about extreme pressure in the unscheduled healthcare system. These are most evident in the A&E departments and create sometimes overwhelming challenges”.
The British Medical Association Scotland said:
“Whilst the government is painting a picture of a well-staffed NHS, the reality is that doctors are working under extreme pressure and workforce shortages and high vacancy rates are significant contributing factors to this.”
Last week, we found that only 67 people in this chamber had confidence in the First Minister’s health secretary. Is it not the case that they might be the only 67 people in this country who trust him on health?
Dr Clifford Mann, the president of the College of Emergency Medicine, said:
“The college has been warning for some time now about extreme pressure in the unscheduled healthcare system. These are most evident in the A&E departments and create sometimes overwhelming challenges”.
The British Medical Association Scotland said:
“Whilst the government is painting a picture of a well-staffed NHS, the reality is that doctors are working under extreme pressure and workforce shortages and high vacancy rates are significant contributing factors to this.”
Last week, we found that only 67 people in this chamber had confidence in the First Minister’s health secretary. Is it not the case that they might be the only 67 people in this country who trust him on health?
I regard with great interest the comments of health professionals, wherever they come from. However, when we are looking at emergency medicine, surely the key comments that we should consider are those of Dr Jason Long, who is chair of the College of Emergency Medicine in Scotland. On 28 May this year—so this is a very current quote—he said that the college:
“continues to support the Scottish Government’s investment in and commitment to the specialty of Emergency Medicine and the work of Emergency Departments in Scotland.”
There is a substantial body of opinion that indicates that. Dr Martin McKechnie, the vice-chair of the Scottish board of the College of Emergency Medicine said:
“We have had a lot of support and investment in the last 18 months from the Government and we are beginning, I hope, to feel and to see the effects of some of these changes.”
Those are medical professionals, at the front end of accident and emergency, who are commenting on the emergency care plan that the health secretary implemented. That plan has brought about an improvement in the most recent accident and emergency statistics, so that 93.3 per cent of people are being treated within four hours.
Johann Lamont said that I am complacent about these things. In the first part of my answer, I said that we are looking to improve the statistics. That is our aim and intention for the health service. I dealt with that issue in some measure. It is fair to compare the 93.3 per cent figure for March 2014 with the position in April 2006, when performance of 87.5 per cent was hailed by the then health secretary, Andy Kerr, as showing
“that the vast majority of A & E departments are meeting the four hour target ... Investment and reform in the NHS is paying off”.
If we are looking for complacency, I suggest that the Government of which Johann Lamont was a member was complacent in 2006, whereas the health secretary in this Government is putting in the investment to improve things in 2014.
“continues to support the Scottish Government’s investment in and commitment to the specialty of Emergency Medicine and the work of Emergency Departments in Scotland.”
There is a substantial body of opinion that indicates that. Dr Martin McKechnie, the vice-chair of the Scottish board of the College of Emergency Medicine said:
“We have had a lot of support and investment in the last 18 months from the Government and we are beginning, I hope, to feel and to see the effects of some of these changes.”
Those are medical professionals, at the front end of accident and emergency, who are commenting on the emergency care plan that the health secretary implemented. That plan has brought about an improvement in the most recent accident and emergency statistics, so that 93.3 per cent of people are being treated within four hours.
Johann Lamont said that I am complacent about these things. In the first part of my answer, I said that we are looking to improve the statistics. That is our aim and intention for the health service. I dealt with that issue in some measure. It is fair to compare the 93.3 per cent figure for March 2014 with the position in April 2006, when performance of 87.5 per cent was hailed by the then health secretary, Andy Kerr, as showing
“that the vast majority of A & E departments are meeting the four hour target ... Investment and reform in the NHS is paying off”.
If we are looking for complacency, I suggest that the Government of which Johann Lamont was a member was complacent in 2006, whereas the health secretary in this Government is putting in the investment to improve things in 2014.
Maybe I should remind the First Minister that it took an elderly man, waiting on a trolley, to have his photograph on the front page of the Daily Record to get the emergency care plan put in place.
Again, we have evidence that the First Minister will quote people who agree with him but does not listen to people who tell him that there are real problems. The First Minister can trade statistics and alibis and talk about the past, but he does not seem to realise that this is about real people.
I shall, in confidence, supply the First Minister with the details of a patient whose partner wrote to us and wants her experience to be known—she wishes to remain anonymous, so let us call her Mary. She went to her general practitioner with a lump on her breast. Her GP referred her as a priority to the Royal Alexandra hospital for cancer screening. No appointment came. In pain, and with the lump growing, she went to the accident and emergency unit, only to be told that she could not be treated, because she was on a pathway—or rather, waiting for an appointment. She did not get an appointment within the Government’s target time. The lump grew, and after weeks of worrying she was forced to pay for private healthcare.
That is the distressing reality of what missing targets means for patients. Can the First Minister tell Mary, and all the real people who make up the statistics that he is trying to play down, why they should have confidence in his NHS?
Again, we have evidence that the First Minister will quote people who agree with him but does not listen to people who tell him that there are real problems. The First Minister can trade statistics and alibis and talk about the past, but he does not seem to realise that this is about real people.
I shall, in confidence, supply the First Minister with the details of a patient whose partner wrote to us and wants her experience to be known—she wishes to remain anonymous, so let us call her Mary. She went to her general practitioner with a lump on her breast. Her GP referred her as a priority to the Royal Alexandra hospital for cancer screening. No appointment came. In pain, and with the lump growing, she went to the accident and emergency unit, only to be told that she could not be treated, because she was on a pathway—or rather, waiting for an appointment. She did not get an appointment within the Government’s target time. The lump grew, and after weeks of worrying she was forced to pay for private healthcare.
That is the distressing reality of what missing targets means for patients. Can the First Minister tell Mary, and all the real people who make up the statistics that he is trying to play down, why they should have confidence in his NHS?
Any case that is referred to me or to the health secretary will be treated seriously.
No one has ever claimed that every patient receives ideal treatment from our national health service, or indeed any national health service. However, our national health service in Scotland is something of which we can still be really proud.
If we want to look at patient experience, we should also consider the balance of the patient opinion website, where patient after patient reflects on the excellent treatment that they have received from our national health service. The site is an important innovation, in my estimation, because it is in the nature of human affairs that it is often instances in which people have failed or the health service has failed to deliver excellent treatment that come to public attention. Therefore, it is important that the patient opinion website gives the balance of opinion of the many hundreds of thousands of our fellow citizens who, year on year, receive excellent treatment from our national health service.
Johann Lamont complains when I reflect that the statistics that we see now, although they are not ideal and in some cases have yet to meet the targets to which we aspire, are, in every single case, superior to the statistics when the Labour Party left office in 2007. In its 2007 manifesto, the Labour Party said:
“Health care across Scotland has never been better ... Waiting times are the lowest ever despite a big increase in operations.”
Well, we have had more big increases in operations and attendance since then, and waiting times are better than they were when the Labour Party left office. In political terms, the central question that the Labour Party has to answer is why, when it was patting itself on the back when it was in office, it is attacking the Scottish National Party now, when every part of the health service is performing to higher standards.
No one has ever claimed that every patient receives ideal treatment from our national health service, or indeed any national health service. However, our national health service in Scotland is something of which we can still be really proud.
If we want to look at patient experience, we should also consider the balance of the patient opinion website, where patient after patient reflects on the excellent treatment that they have received from our national health service. The site is an important innovation, in my estimation, because it is in the nature of human affairs that it is often instances in which people have failed or the health service has failed to deliver excellent treatment that come to public attention. Therefore, it is important that the patient opinion website gives the balance of opinion of the many hundreds of thousands of our fellow citizens who, year on year, receive excellent treatment from our national health service.
Johann Lamont complains when I reflect that the statistics that we see now, although they are not ideal and in some cases have yet to meet the targets to which we aspire, are, in every single case, superior to the statistics when the Labour Party left office in 2007. In its 2007 manifesto, the Labour Party said:
“Health care across Scotland has never been better ... Waiting times are the lowest ever despite a big increase in operations.”
Well, we have had more big increases in operations and attendance since then, and waiting times are better than they were when the Labour Party left office. In political terms, the central question that the Labour Party has to answer is why, when it was patting itself on the back when it was in office, it is attacking the Scottish National Party now, when every part of the health service is performing to higher standards.
Like the First Minister, we recognise the good things that are happening in the NHS and we celebrate them—of course we do. However, the problem with the First Minister is that he wants to ignore the problems that are emerging, rather than tackle them. We want to make progress. We want to get better. On his watch, we are going backwards.
The First Minister said that he is not complacent, but he ignores his own statistics and failed targets. He ignores the first-hand views of the experts and professionals. Most damningly, he ignores the lived reality of patients in Scotland. The First Minister is in denial about the pressures on the NHS on his watch, and about the failures in patient care. The fact is that he is more at home in the imagined world after a yes vote than in the real world of life under the SNP Government.
For those who are waiting in accident and emergency, for those who are waiting for treatment, for those who are waiting in pain, will the First Minister admit that he is failing to manage our NHS, and will he get on with the day job that patients across Scotland so desperately need him to do?
The First Minister said that he is not complacent, but he ignores his own statistics and failed targets. He ignores the first-hand views of the experts and professionals. Most damningly, he ignores the lived reality of patients in Scotland. The First Minister is in denial about the pressures on the NHS on his watch, and about the failures in patient care. The fact is that he is more at home in the imagined world after a yes vote than in the real world of life under the SNP Government.
For those who are waiting in accident and emergency, for those who are waiting for treatment, for those who are waiting in pain, will the First Minister admit that he is failing to manage our NHS, and will he get on with the day job that patients across Scotland so desperately need him to do?
As I have pointed out, I could go on to talk about in-patient waits, out-patient waits and referral to treatment waits, as well as accident and emergency. On every single one of those measures, on this Government’s watch, treatment in the national health service has improved. Johann Lamont says that things are getting worse, but every one of those statistics is much better than it was when the Labour Party was in office and Johann Lamont was a Government minister.
Let me tell members what has happened to the national health service on this watch. Despite the Westminster cutbacks, national health service staff have increased under the SNP. Staffing is up by 6.7 per cent. We have protected in real terms the front-line NHS budget, which is something that the Labour Party pledged to do in Scotland and has not done in Wales. On patient satisfaction, real people in the national health service say that 87 per cent of patients are satisfied with their local health service. That figure is up 7 per cent on the SNP’s watch. We have cleaner hospitals. Clostridium difficile in patients aged over 65 has reduced by 83.8 per cent. I remember when Jackie Baillie said that we were going to be the health infection centre of the world, and then discovered that she was talking about what had happened under the Labour Government.
We abolished prescription charges in the national health service from April 2011, which showed that we aspire to the original foundation principle that the health service should be available to all, regardless of their income. All those things have happened under the SNP. Our national health service, a public service, is protected by the SNP while being neglected by Labour in Wales and every single one of those statistics is better than when Johann Lamont was in office.
Let me tell members what has happened to the national health service on this watch. Despite the Westminster cutbacks, national health service staff have increased under the SNP. Staffing is up by 6.7 per cent. We have protected in real terms the front-line NHS budget, which is something that the Labour Party pledged to do in Scotland and has not done in Wales. On patient satisfaction, real people in the national health service say that 87 per cent of patients are satisfied with their local health service. That figure is up 7 per cent on the SNP’s watch. We have cleaner hospitals. Clostridium difficile in patients aged over 65 has reduced by 83.8 per cent. I remember when Jackie Baillie said that we were going to be the health infection centre of the world, and then discovered that she was talking about what had happened under the Labour Government.
We abolished prescription charges in the national health service from April 2011, which showed that we aspire to the original foundation principle that the health service should be available to all, regardless of their income. All those things have happened under the SNP. Our national health service, a public service, is protected by the SNP while being neglected by Labour in Wales and every single one of those statistics is better than when Johann Lamont was in office.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 29 May 2014 →- Help to Buy (Scotland) Scheme Questions · 6
- Marine Protected Areas (Designation) Questions · 8
- Working Group on Supporter Involvement in Football Clubs (Membership) Questions · 4
- Accident and Emergency Treatment Target (Royal Alexandra Hospital) Questions · 4
- Projected Population Decline (Argyll and Bute) Questions · 4
- Management Information and Dental Accounting System (Duplicate Registrations) Questions · 9
- Police Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Porterfield Prison (Replacement) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Royal Mail (Universal Service Obligation) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- “The Land of Scotland and the Common Good” First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Business Rates Incentivisation Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Local Television Members’ business · 11
- Scottish Climate Change Adaptation Programme Statement · 41
- Immigration Policy (Higher Education) Debate · 86
- Decision Time Decision time · 12
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.