Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 6 March 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01927)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Will the First Minister join me in condemning the Tories’ top-rate tax cut for millionaires, or does he agree with George Osborne?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I join Johann Lamont in condemning that. Not only do I do so; I point out that the Scottish National Party led the Opposition in the House of Commons in voting against the measure.

I tend to agree with the points that are now made by the shadow chancellor that, when the deficit is high, it is unfair to place a burden on the ordinary people of this country, and that that burden ought to be shared by those who are better off. Hence we followed that logic in our votes in the House of Commons.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
So will the First Minister back Labour’s policy of reintroducing the 50p tax rate now or after a yes vote?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I look forward to a vote in the House of Commons, which I am confident will come later this month in the budget, and I am also confident about how the SNP will vote on that.

Perhaps Johann Lamont will give us some assurance that the Labour Party will also vote against the cut. As she will remember, on 27 March 2012, when the SNP moved against the measure in the House of Commons, only two Labour MPs—Dennis Skinner and Paul Flynn—voted against the reduction in the top-rate tax.

There were a number of explanations for why that happened. Willie Bain tweeted that Labour did not support the vote on partisan grounds, as there

“is a ... convention that we do not support SNP motions”.

Luckily for Johann Lamont, if it is the Labour Party that moves against the measure later this month, the SNP has no such bar—we will judge the issue based on what is right and proper.

We think that it is wrong, at this time, when the deficit is high, to ask ordinary people to bear burdens and for those burdens not to be shared by those who are better off. I am sure that, with her influence over her Westminster colleagues, Johann Lamont will manage to bring them into line on tax matters.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Of course, we have developed an interesting convention in here that we do not answer the question that we were asked.

In all of that, I do not think that we got an affirmation that the First Minister will back Labour’s policy of reintroducing the 50p tax rate after a yes vote. Indeed, on Monday, he said:

“we certainly are not going to put ourselves at a tax disadvantage with the rest of the UK.”

He says one thing in one place and says absolutely nothing in here. We look forward to hearing the answer to the question that I asked him, which, as the Deputy First Minister is keen to say, is a quite simple yes or no.

There is something curious here. The First Minister says that we should vote for independence to get away from the Tories’ destructive policies, and yet he is committing an independent Scotland to the same tax rates that the Tories set—[Interruption.]

Nicola Sturgeon SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
No, he is not.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Well, he was doing that on Monday—unless he is now recanting that position. The exception, of course, are taxes such as corporation tax, which he wants to cut even further than anything George Osborne sets.

Is it not the case that the First Minister’s vision of an independent Scotland will not get rid of the Tories but will enshrine a tougher tax-cutting agenda than even the Tories have come up with?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
In my first answer, I pointed out that I agree with Ed Balls, the shadow chancellor, who changed Labour’s policy on 25 January and said:

“When the deficit is still high ... it cannot be right ... to give the richest people in the country a huge tax cut.”

That is the right policy. Not only do I think that now; we thought it in 2012 when we led the opposition to the tax cut in the House of Commons.

I was not going to pursue the matter but, since Johann Lamont has offered me the opportunity, I will do so. I said that there were a number of explanations why Labour did not support the SNP motion. Ed Balls’s political adviser, Alex Belardinelli, admitted that

“there was a”—

something that is unmentionable in Parliament—

“up somewhere along the way last night and it wasn’t clear what SNP had called a vote on or how, so we abstained on their vote.”

Alan Gillam, Margaret Curran’s political adviser, then emailed Labour’s Holyrood media team on 27 March 2012:

“I am trying to find out where we went wrong.”

In an earlier email, he hoped that the Scottish media would just ignore the matter, saying:

“We should probably hold off releasing line in Scotland just yet, in the hope that it is ignored”.

I thank Johann Lamont for giving me the opportunity to draw the matter to people’s attention.

In 2012, we fought the tax cut for the richest people in the country. In the circumstances the cut was wrong, so we voted against it; we think that it is wrong now, so we are voting against it; and, in a vote that I expect to take place in the House of Commons later this month, we will vote against it yet again.

I agree with Ed Balls that in the current circumstances, when the deficit is still high, it is wrong to reduce the top-rate tax on those who are better off in this country. That is unfair. I suggest to Johann Lamont that we seem to have followed that policy rather more consistently than she and her colleagues have managed to do over the past two years.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We know what the First Minister will do now, but we do not know what he would do in an independent Scotland—no surprise there.

The First Minister appears to be saying that the tax policies of the Tories restrict growth—I agree with that—but that, somehow, the same policies in an independent Scotland would create growth. That is simply not credible. He owes it to the people to whom he is offering an alternative to the Tories to follow through and answer the simple question that I asked him: does he support Labour’s policy of reintroducing the 50p tax rate after a yes vote? We have heard no answer from the First Minister—nothing new there.

The truth is that, in seven years, we have not seen a single policy from Alex Salmond that has redistributed wealth from the rich to the poor. He talks of Scotland being a progressive beacon, but it turns out to be a beacon that he has never lit. Now the First Minister has committed himself to tax levels that will be set by a Tory Government in what he will have made a foreign country.

In the 1970s, we called the SNP the tartan Tories. Is it not the case that a First Minister who cannot answer a simple question on taxation might still be tartan but is committing himself to out-Torying the Tories on tax in an independent Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The answer to Johann Lamont’s question is “No” on all counts.

Can I just point out the history of this? [Interruption.] Oh, yes—members are going to hear the history. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Labour was in power at Westminster for 13 years but had the 50p top-rate tax for just 36 days of those 13 years in power. Ed Balls has adopted the entirely sensible position that, while the deficit is still high, it is unfair to ask the lower paid and people on average earnings to accept the burden. Under these circumstances, we should not have the cut in the top-rate tax.

Last month, John Swinney set out very clearly and in detail the SNP’s position—what we have done, what we would do and the circumstances of an independent Scotland. He also pointed out that, under the current position of this Parliament, we do not have the power to set taxation. Under the proposals that are coming, we will still not have the powers to vary top-rate taxation.

In an independent Scotland, we will have the ability to vary not just top-rate taxation but all taxation. We will do that to benefit the people of Scotland and the Scottish economy. Under independence, we will also introduce policies such as the transformation of childcare and free schools meals across the country. No doubt we will do that against Labour Party opposition, but we will do so because we are committed to a fairer and better society in Scotland.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Aberdeen Western Peripheral Route Questions · 4
  2. Campaign for a Leith Museum (Support) Questions · 4
  3. Independence (Civil Servants’ Impartiality) Questions · 6
  4. Elected Representatives from France (Meetings) Questions · 4
  5. A83 (Landslip Closures) Questions · 6
  6. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 5
  7. Marine and Islands Renewable Energy (Transmission Charges) Questions · 8
  8. Education Maintenance Allowance Questions · 4
  9. Independence (Defence) Questions · 7
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  11. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Women in Business First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Accident and Emergency Waiting Time Standard First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Rail Network (Upgrading) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  16. Scotland Fair Trade Nation (First Anniversary) Members’ business · 22
  17. District Heating and Decarbonising Heating Debate · 69
  18. Decision Time Decision time · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.