Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Independence (Currency)

Portfolio Question Time Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth

Wednesday 26 February 2014 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 14 contributions · 6 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link


2. To ask the Scottish Government what economic risks an independent Scotland would face if it was to use sterling without being in a formal currency union with the rest of the United Kingdom. (S4O-02928)

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
The fiscal commission working group set out a number of viable currency options for a country of Scotland’s size and economic strength. It concluded that retaining sterling as part of a formal monetary union with the rest of the United Kingdom would be the best option for an independent Scotland and for the rest of the UK. The Scottish Government is clear that an independent Scotland will retain sterling, and we have set out our currency proposals on pages 109 to 117 of “Scotland’s Future”.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfriesshire
link
It was reported in this morning’s press that Alistair Cotton, the head of corporate dealing at Currencies Direct, has said that using a currency without a formal union would leave an independent Scotland

“without the economic levers to support its ... financial sector”

fully. Owen Kelly of Scottish Financial Enterprise believes that using the pound without a formal currency union could threaten Scotland’s membership of the European Union. Is continuing to use the pound, irrespective of currency union, a viable plan B?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
As I said to Dr Murray in my original answer, the fiscal commission working group looked at a number of viable options and it assessed and considered the contents of the different propositions. The Scottish Government is clear that we support and endorse the fiscal commission working group’s preferred option, which is to retain sterling as part of a formal monetary union with the rest of the United Kingdom. The Scottish Government will continue to set out that proposition to the people of our country.

Elaine Smith Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · Coatbridge and Chryston
link
Very briefly, Marco Biagi.

Marco Biagi SNP Edinburgh Central
link
Alistair Darling has been noted as saying that a currency union is “logical” and “desirable”, but added to that now is Jackson Carlaw’s endorsement of such a union as being “rational and sensible”. Does the finance secretary agree that, on a currency union, George Osborne now and George Osborne the day after a yes vote will be very different, not least because it will be in the overwhelming interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK to conclude the deal and to do so swiftly?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
Mr Biagi makes a fair and strong point. The Scottish Government has clearly made the point that businesses south of the border will save on transaction costs as a consequence of a formal currency union. We estimate that those costs would amount to £500 million, which would be significant for businesses in the rest of the United Kingdom.

Another aspect is that, if George Osborne sustained the line of argument that he advanced in his speech in Edinburgh a week past Thursday, he would be arguing for the rest of the UK to assume the entire national debt of the UK. I do not imagine that taxpayers south of the border will want to wrestle with that obligation, which would be greater than what would exist if a formal currency union were to be established between Scotland and the rest of the UK.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link
The cabinet secretary and his colleagues are fond of quoting Nobel prize winning economists. I wonder whether he read the piece in The New York Times on Monday by the Nobel prize winning economist Paul Krugman, who, in relation to what the independence campaign has said about currency, said:

“what it has said on that crucial subject seems deeply muddle-headed ... sharing a common currency without having a shared federal government is very dangerous.”

Is that not a damning verdict on Mr Swinney’s policy?

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
No.

Elaine Smith Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · Coatbridge and Chryston
link
Order.

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
What is worthy of analysis is the comparison between the fiscal commission working group’s report and the speech that was delivered in Edinburgh by the governor of the Bank of England. [Interruption.]

Elaine Smith Lab The Deputy Presiding Officer · Coatbridge and Chryston
link
Order, please.

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
If Murdo Fraser was to go off and do some homework and look at the contents of the fiscal commission working group’s report—the issues it raises and the solutions it offers to some of the issues relating to a currency zone—and compare that with the analysis that was put forward fairly, reasonably and dispassionately by the governor of the Bank of England, he would find that there is a clear and robust relationship between the thinking of what is in the fiscal commission working group’s report and what is in the governor of the Bank of England’s statement to the people whom he addressed in Edinburgh.

That analysis must have struck Alistair Darling as making the case for a currency zone “logical” and “desirable”. I am absolutely delighted that Jackson Carlaw has added his significant influence to that, as part of the discussion that we are having.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth Questions · 1
  2. Glasgow City Council (Meetings) Questions · 4
  3. Independence (Currency) Questions · 14
  4. Scotland Act 2012 (Tax Avoidance) Questions · 12
  5. Public Sector Staff Recruitment and Retention (North-east Scotland) Questions · 6
  6. Chancellor of the Exchequer (Meetings) Questions · 9
  7. Minister for Youth Employment Visits (Stirling) Questions · 5
  8. Innovation (Links Between Key Partners) Questions · 4
  9. Spring Budget Revision 2013-14 Questions · 6
  10. Work Sharing and Work-time Accounts Questions · 6
  11. Local Authorities (Private and Institutional Funding) Questions · 4
  12. Island Areas Ministerial Working Group Questions · 6
  13. “Coping with the cuts? Local government and poorer communities” Questions · 4
  14. Tourism (2014 Priorities) Questions · 4
  15. Scottish Loan Fund Questions · 4
  16. Justice Debate · 93
  17. Scotland’s Children Debate · 92
  18. Business Motions Business motions · 4
  19. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  20. Decision Time Decision time · 16
  21. Eating Disorder Awareness Week 2014 Members’ business · 14

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.