1. To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02011)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 9
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 5
- Elaine Smith Lab 4
The record
18 contributions1. To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02011)
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
With your permission, Deputy Presiding Officer, and, I am sure, on behalf of the entire chamber, I express my sincere condolences to the friends and family of Keane Wallis-Bennett. Keane’s death on Tuesday morning at Liberton high school is a tragedy that has horrified all of us.
A thorough Police Scotland and Health and Safety Executive inquiry is now under way and I am limited in the detail that I can share. However, I spoke this morning to the City of Edinburgh Council’s chief executive, Sue Bruce. She advised me that the council is co-operating fully with the inquiry. In addition, it has convened an incident response team and is conducting inspections of all other schools in its area.
This has been a most difficult time for family, friends, pupils and staff at the school. I am sure that all our thoughts, and indeed the thoughts of people throughout Scotland, are with them today.
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
A thorough Police Scotland and Health and Safety Executive inquiry is now under way and I am limited in the detail that I can share. However, I spoke this morning to the City of Edinburgh Council’s chief executive, Sue Bruce. She advised me that the council is co-operating fully with the inquiry. In addition, it has convened an incident response team and is conducting inspections of all other schools in its area.
This has been a most difficult time for family, friends, pupils and staff at the school. I am sure that all our thoughts, and indeed the thoughts of people throughout Scotland, are with them today.
Later today, I will have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I thank the Deputy First Minister for that statement. Throughout the chamber, we share the sentiments that she expressed, at the saddest of times for the family, the school and all concerned.
Alex Salmond is off to the United States again today. I hope that he has remembered his trews this time—the taxpayer should not have to pay for another pair. I hope, too, that he has left the taxpayers’ credit card behind, because he has still not accounted for his spending on his trip to the Ryder cup in 2012.
I asked the First Minister in January why a freedom of information request about his spending on that trip had not been answered. He said:
“The freedom of information request will be answered as soon as possible.”
He then added:
“It will and why should it not be?”—[Official Report, 23 January 2014; c 26962.]
Nearly three months on, that request has not been answered. Can Nicola Sturgeon tell me now why it should not be?
Alex Salmond is off to the United States again today. I hope that he has remembered his trews this time—the taxpayer should not have to pay for another pair. I hope, too, that he has left the taxpayers’ credit card behind, because he has still not accounted for his spending on his trip to the Ryder cup in 2012.
I asked the First Minister in January why a freedom of information request about his spending on that trip had not been answered. He said:
“The freedom of information request will be answered as soon as possible.”
He then added:
“It will and why should it not be?”—[Official Report, 23 January 2014; c 26962.]
Nearly three months on, that request has not been answered. Can Nicola Sturgeon tell me now why it should not be?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
I am quite flabbergasted that that is, in Johann Lamont’s mind, the big issue of the day. Nevertheless, she is the one who decides the questions that she asks.
All the relevant information about the trip to which Johann Lamont refers is, as far as I am aware, in the public domain. If there are specific pieces of information that Johann Lamont wants, she can request them and I will undertake today to seek to respond to that.
Johann Lamont started her question by referring to the First Minister’s trip to the United States of America to take part in tartan week. It is worth pointing out a couple of things to the chamber in that regard. In the space of five days, the First Minister will undertake more than a dozen meetings with United States businesses that have an interest in Scotland, which we hope will lead to the creation of hundreds of new jobs throughout the country. I would hope that Johann Lamont would mention that.
Johann Lamont also referred to the Government’s credit card. It might be interesting to the chamber if I shared some of the costs of previous tartan and Scotland weeks. I have the costs here going back to 2005; I will not read out the costs for every year, but I will take a couple of examples.
In 2006, when the current First Minister was not in office—I believe that it was one Jack McConnell—the bill for tartan week was more than £1 million. The bill for Scotland week in 2013—the most recent year that we have available–was £326,000. I think that the First Minister is right to promote the country in the United States this week. I think that he is right to do that and to get much more value for money than was perhaps the case on the part of the previous Administration.
All the relevant information about the trip to which Johann Lamont refers is, as far as I am aware, in the public domain. If there are specific pieces of information that Johann Lamont wants, she can request them and I will undertake today to seek to respond to that.
Johann Lamont started her question by referring to the First Minister’s trip to the United States of America to take part in tartan week. It is worth pointing out a couple of things to the chamber in that regard. In the space of five days, the First Minister will undertake more than a dozen meetings with United States businesses that have an interest in Scotland, which we hope will lead to the creation of hundreds of new jobs throughout the country. I would hope that Johann Lamont would mention that.
Johann Lamont also referred to the Government’s credit card. It might be interesting to the chamber if I shared some of the costs of previous tartan and Scotland weeks. I have the costs here going back to 2005; I will not read out the costs for every year, but I will take a couple of examples.
In 2006, when the current First Minister was not in office—I believe that it was one Jack McConnell—the bill for tartan week was more than £1 million. The bill for Scotland week in 2013—the most recent year that we have available–was £326,000. I think that the First Minister is right to promote the country in the United States this week. I think that he is right to do that and to get much more value for money than was perhaps the case on the part of the previous Administration.
We know that Alex Salmond is notorious for not answering the question that he was asked—[Interruption.]
Order, please.
—but now he and his Deputy First Minister are refusing to answer the question that he himself asked. For the information of the Deputy First Minister, the First Minister has not answered the freedom of information request and he has not answered a series of parliamentary questions either.
The First Minister chose to stay in the $2,000-a-night Peninsula hotel in Chicago, far away from the rest of the Scottish delegation. We know that because his spokesperson told an official briefing of journalists that that is where he stayed, and those journalists printed it. Now, the Scottish Government has said that it cannot tell us where he stayed, and for how much, for security reasons. Since the First Minister’s spokesperson has already told us where he stayed, can we now be told how much taxpayers’ cash Alex Salmond spent on himself in the Peninsula hotel?
The First Minister chose to stay in the $2,000-a-night Peninsula hotel in Chicago, far away from the rest of the Scottish delegation. We know that because his spokesperson told an official briefing of journalists that that is where he stayed, and those journalists printed it. Now, the Scottish Government has said that it cannot tell us where he stayed, and for how much, for security reasons. Since the First Minister’s spokesperson has already told us where he stayed, can we now be told how much taxpayers’ cash Alex Salmond spent on himself in the Peninsula hotel?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
I have absolutely no doubt that Johann Lamont would be standing in the chamber criticising the First Minister if he were not going overseas when appropriate to promote Scotland’s economic interests. However, when he does that, she stands here and criticises him as well. I think that we can safely conclude that Johann Lamont will criticise this Government regardless of what it does, and the reason for that is that she has no positive programme and no positive ideas of her own to put forward.
I can certainly tell Johann Lamont where the First Minister will not be staying when he is in New York this week. He will not be staying at the Benjamin hotel, which, I understand, is frequented by Paul McCartney, and was the favoured hotel of Jack McConnell when he attended tartan week.
Earlier, I gave the cost of tartan week in 2006. Let me give the 2005 figure: £895,000. The 2007 figure was £765,000. In no year since this Government has been in office have the costs of going to tartan week or Scotland week been anything close to the figures that I have just read out.
Can we agree that it is right for the First Minister, as it was right for his predecessors, to go overseas to promote Scotland’s economic interests? Can we also agree that they have a duty to ensure value for money for the taxpayer? Based on the figures that I have read out, I think that this Government is rather better at doing that than the previous Administration was.
I can certainly tell Johann Lamont where the First Minister will not be staying when he is in New York this week. He will not be staying at the Benjamin hotel, which, I understand, is frequented by Paul McCartney, and was the favoured hotel of Jack McConnell when he attended tartan week.
Earlier, I gave the cost of tartan week in 2006. Let me give the 2005 figure: £895,000. The 2007 figure was £765,000. In no year since this Government has been in office have the costs of going to tartan week or Scotland week been anything close to the figures that I have just read out.
Can we agree that it is right for the First Minister, as it was right for his predecessors, to go overseas to promote Scotland’s economic interests? Can we also agree that they have a duty to ensure value for money for the taxpayer? Based on the figures that I have read out, I think that this Government is rather better at doing that than the previous Administration was.
First, there is an issue of public trust and accountability for the public purse. [Interruption.]
Order, please.
Secondly, nobody is disputing that there should be visits abroad. The Deputy First Minister is able to quote figures about previous trips, but the point is that we cannot quote the figures for the cost of Alex Salmond to go to the Ryder cup. [Interruption.]
Order, please. [Interruption.] Ms Grahame!
It is an issue of transparency, and now the First Minister and the Deputy First Minister are refusing to answer. The only thing that we know for sure about the First Minister’s trip to the Ryder cup in 2012 is that the Scottish Government does not want to explain how much taxpayers’ cash Alex Salmond spent on himself. When we get an answer, the number of people on the trip changes and the figures change, but no accounting is given.
The First Minister went to the $2,000-a-night Peninsula hotel in September 2012. In January 2014, he still could not say how much money he had spent on himself. In January 2014, the First Minister said that the question about his spending would be answered
“as soon as possible”,
and he asked,
“why should it not be?”—[Official Report, 23 January 2014; c 26962.]
It is now April 2014. The question has not been answered. Why should it not be answered now?
The First Minister went to the $2,000-a-night Peninsula hotel in September 2012. In January 2014, he still could not say how much money he had spent on himself. In January 2014, the First Minister said that the question about his spending would be answered
“as soon as possible”,
and he asked,
“why should it not be?”—[Official Report, 23 January 2014; c 26962.]
It is now April 2014. The question has not been answered. Why should it not be answered now?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
This is desperate stuff from the leader of the Opposition. The key points about Alex Salmond’s visit to the Ryder cup are, first, that he was promoting Scotland as the host of this year’s Ryder cup. Secondly, the reason that I am able to quote the figures that I have just read out is that we are transparent about the cost of overseas trips. We are also transparent about the benefits from those overseas trips, such as the jobs created. As I have been able to demonstrate from the figures that I read out, it would seem that we get better value for money than predecessor Governments did.
What Johann Lamont has chosen to do today—not for the first time and, I am pretty sure, not for the last, she has indulged in smear and insinuation instead of discussing the real issues of the day—is probably one of the reasons that Labour is in the sorry state that it is in Scotland today. As was commented on in Holyrood magazine just this week, every second word of Johann Lamont’s party conference speech started with the letter “S” and ended with the letter “P”. She talks more about the Scottish National Party than she does about Labour’s prospectus for Scotland. I cannot put it any better than Holyrood magazine did:
“What has happened to Scottish Labour? It seems hope has been replaced by hate. It used to be a party of inclusivity but now it condemns its critics and isolates dissenters”.
Labour has lost its way and Johann Lamont has just demonstrated that today.
What Johann Lamont has chosen to do today—not for the first time and, I am pretty sure, not for the last, she has indulged in smear and insinuation instead of discussing the real issues of the day—is probably one of the reasons that Labour is in the sorry state that it is in Scotland today. As was commented on in Holyrood magazine just this week, every second word of Johann Lamont’s party conference speech started with the letter “S” and ended with the letter “P”. She talks more about the Scottish National Party than she does about Labour’s prospectus for Scotland. I cannot put it any better than Holyrood magazine did:
“What has happened to Scottish Labour? It seems hope has been replaced by hate. It used to be a party of inclusivity but now it condemns its critics and isolates dissenters”.
Labour has lost its way and Johann Lamont has just demonstrated that today.
It has been said that we can tell when the First Minister is “unadjacent to the truth”. Nicola Sturgeon’s lips are moving. [Interruption.]
Order.
The facts of the matter are very simple. In all of that nonsense, there was no answer to a simple question about spending public money. The public deserve to know.
The First Minister spent £500,000 to go to the Ryder cup, but he cannot, or will not, explain what he spent on himself. Was it like his trip to China, when he spent taxpayers’ money on himself and repaid it only when there was a freedom of information request? Is that why the First Minister has not answered the freedom of information request this time? Is that why, a year and a half later, ministers still will not answer parliamentary questions on how much cash he spent? Has he paid any money back? The First Minister posed the question in January. Why should these questions not be answered as soon as possible? I ask the Deputy First Minister, why should they not be answered now?
The First Minister spent £500,000 to go to the Ryder cup, but he cannot, or will not, explain what he spent on himself. Was it like his trip to China, when he spent taxpayers’ money on himself and repaid it only when there was a freedom of information request? Is that why the First Minister has not answered the freedom of information request this time? Is that why, a year and a half later, ministers still will not answer parliamentary questions on how much cash he spent? Has he paid any money back? The First Minister posed the question in January. Why should these questions not be answered as soon as possible? I ask the Deputy First Minister, why should they not be answered now?
Nicola Sturgeon
SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities · Glasgow Southside
link
Johann Lamont’s accusations and allegations are simply untrue. If her proposition is that money spent on the First Minister going overseas to promote the country is money spent on himself, I assume that she thinks that the more than £1 million spent on tartan week in 2006 was money spent on Jack McConnell personally. The utter hypocrisy of Johann Lamont on this issue is absolutely breathtaking.
Johann Lamont can smear the First Minister as much as she likes; she can smear me as much as she likes. The real question that Johann Lamont will have to answer—and she will have to answer it to her own back benchers—is why, seven years into this SNP Government, we are still ahead in the polls. She is languishing in the polls.
I can understand why Johann Lamont might not like the quotes that I have read out from Holyrood magazine. Here is another one: “Scottish Labour seems moribund.” Perhaps she will pay more attention to a quotation from Len McCluskey, the leader of Unite union. He said that Labour has to do more to show that it is,
“on the side of ordinary people”,
and suggested that the reason the SNP is in government and Labour is in opposition is that the SNP is more radical than the Labour Party.
On today’s performance, Johann Lamont is staying in opposition. In fact, on today’s performance she ain’t even fit to be in opposition, let alone government.
Johann Lamont can smear the First Minister as much as she likes; she can smear me as much as she likes. The real question that Johann Lamont will have to answer—and she will have to answer it to her own back benchers—is why, seven years into this SNP Government, we are still ahead in the polls. She is languishing in the polls.
I can understand why Johann Lamont might not like the quotes that I have read out from Holyrood magazine. Here is another one: “Scottish Labour seems moribund.” Perhaps she will pay more attention to a quotation from Len McCluskey, the leader of Unite union. He said that Labour has to do more to show that it is,
“on the side of ordinary people”,
and suggested that the reason the SNP is in government and Labour is in opposition is that the SNP is more radical than the Labour Party.
On today’s performance, Johann Lamont is staying in opposition. In fact, on today’s performance she ain’t even fit to be in opposition, let alone government.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 3 Apr 2014 →- Child Poverty Questions · 4
- Student Accommodation (Impact on Communities) Questions · 4
- Fixed-odds Betting Terminals Questions · 4
- Software Engineering (Skills Support) Questions · 4
- Rail Freight Questions · 4
- Cycle Infrastructure (Community Links Programme) Questions · 7
- School Closures Questions · 4
- Bowel Screening Awareness Questions · 5
- Asbestos in Workplaces Questions · 4
- First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Trident First Minister’s Questions · 16
- “An overview of local government in Scotland 2014” First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Police Scotland (Public Accountability) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Local Courts Members’ business · 18
- Defective and Dangerous Buildings (Recovery of Expenses) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 22
- Developing Skills for Scotland’s Digital Economy Debate · 35
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.