George Crooks told me to make sure that I immediately followed him. Laughter.I represent an organisation that has members throughout Europe from all sectors, including academia, industry, Government and health, and the external view of Scotland is that it is clear that you have recognised the power of digital health and working together. However—you may not want to hear this, but I will say it anyway—you must not become complacent. You might say, “We’re not complacent,” but my experience of going round Europe to many countries where we have ecosystems, as we call them, and we regularly meet all the different sectors is that it is easy to get carried away with a little bit of success. You have had success, and you deserve it but, as a critical friend of Scotland, I say that I think that you need to focus much more strongly than you appear to be doing on the economic benefits.If I may, I will take a moment to tell you about a piece of work that we did last year in Northern Ireland, which is my home country, involving the ministry of the economy, as I call it—it calls itself the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment, but I prefer to use the word “economy”. Until two years ago, the economy and health ministers, although they were from the same party, did not really see the need to have their departments work together, so we organised and arranged that there would be a formal memorandum of understanding between the two departments.That was challenged by one of the agencies of the economy ministry, which said, “Why do we need to do that? We know everyone.” We said, “Please name the client managers that you have for the health department,” and the answer was that there were none. Why were there no client managers for something that spends so much of the Government budget? The answer was, “Because it’s another Government department.” We learned a lesson from that, and we produced a report last year that I think is instructive.I realise that you are the Health and Sport Committee, but I suggest to you that there is a big economic opportunity here. In Northern Ireland, £4.5 billion a year is spent on health and social care—it is an integrated service—and that represents 40 per cent of the total public sector spend in Northern Ireland. That is bound to get anyone’s attention. Many people said that we should cut the budget. However, our report revealed that that £4.5 billion employs 70,000 people, which is almost 10 per cent of the total workforce in Northern Ireland, and that £3 billion of that money goes straight back into the economy through salaries and payments to doctors, dentists and so on. Some £1.3 billion is spent on buying things—on procurement—and the other £200 million is for capital spend.As a result of a single declaration, which has now been accepted not just by the two ministries but by the Executive in Northern Ireland, “the annual investment of £4.5 billion” is how it is referred to by everyone from Peter Robinson and Martin McGuinness down. That has created a complete change in the mentality, the culture and the way in which we look at healthcare, and as a result we are beginning to attract jobs, because people throughout Europe and the world realise that we have a joined-up approach involving both health and the economy.I recommend that the committee, no doubt working with other committees, should at least consider that approach. Sometimes, a statement of something obvious is really important, because it is not always obvious until you know it. One action that the committee could take is to consider whether there should be a formal, overarching MOU—there may be one already—that says, “We are going to work together.” It is amazing how it plays internationally when you brand a country as a place that is joined up not only in health and social care but in the economy as well.11:45
I do not know whether Scotland is very different from all the other countries in Europe, but one thing that is becoming very clear to us as we travel around Europe is that the more successful your health and social care policies are, the bigger your risk of failure is. By that I mean that in Northern Ireland and in other countries the big push is to keep people in their own home and out of hospital, and to get them out as quickly as possible if they are in hospital and stop them being readmitted. At the lower end—that is unfortunately how people look at it—there is a shortage of domiciliary care workers, as we call them in Northern Ireland.We can be successful in keeping people in their own homes, but if they go back through the revolving door into hospital, believe you me, that would be unacceptable both politically and economically and from a human perspective. I am leading a workforce skills programme in Northern Ireland at the moment to identify how many additional jobs we need to fill with people who are properly trained in the use of smart technology and in supervisory and managerial skills, because often those people do not have a career path. That is why they leave when a corner store opens, for example. They can get more money for stacking shelves in a supermarket than they can for providing hands-on care for people. I suggest that there might be an economic opportunity through digital health to create jobs and take people off the dole queue, as well as to stop people going back through the revolving door into hospital.