1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01907)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 5
The record
18 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01907)
Sadly, we had confirmation early this morning that a 62-year-old man fell from Taqa’s Harding platform in the North Sea during maintenance activity. He was transferred to Gilbert Bain hospital but, unfortunately, has passed away. I know that the whole chamber will join me in expressing our sincere condolences to the family, friends and colleagues at this distressing time.
We on this side add our condolences and recognise the importance of ensuring that people who go to work are kept safe when they are there.
Standard Life has made plans to leave Scotland if Scotland leaves the United Kingdom. How many more companies need to leave Scotland before the First Minister admits that a yes vote would be a disaster for Scottish jobs?
Standard Life has made plans to leave Scotland if Scotland leaves the United Kingdom. How many more companies need to leave Scotland before the First Minister admits that a yes vote would be a disaster for Scottish jobs?
Let me quote exactly from the question-and-answer session at the Standard Life annual general meeting today.
“How many people do you employ in Edinburgh/Scotland? What would be the impact on jobs of moving your HQ?
We have made no decisions to move any part of our operations from Scotland at the current time as a consequence of the constitutional debate. We are proud of our Scottish heritage and believe that Scotland is a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world.”
Standard Life then says that it has contingency plans
“if this does not continue to be the case”.
Our submission would be that Standard Life will find Scotland a good place to do business, as it finds the 10 countries around the world in which it does business. That will happen first and foremost because of the excellence of the staff. Its prime asset is the 5,000 people who work for it in Scotland, who are the strength of the company and what has made it successful. Secondly—this matters to some of the points that Standard Life has made—the Scottish Government puts forward the concept of a shared currency and regulatory framework, which are exactly the sort of things that Standard Life has been calling for.
Given that statement about the importance of Scotland as
“a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world”,
can the chamber not unite in having confidence that an independent Scotland—indeed, Scotland under any constitutional framework—will be exactly that?
“How many people do you employ in Edinburgh/Scotland? What would be the impact on jobs of moving your HQ?
We have made no decisions to move any part of our operations from Scotland at the current time as a consequence of the constitutional debate. We are proud of our Scottish heritage and believe that Scotland is a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world.”
Standard Life then says that it has contingency plans
“if this does not continue to be the case”.
Our submission would be that Standard Life will find Scotland a good place to do business, as it finds the 10 countries around the world in which it does business. That will happen first and foremost because of the excellence of the staff. Its prime asset is the 5,000 people who work for it in Scotland, who are the strength of the company and what has made it successful. Secondly—this matters to some of the points that Standard Life has made—the Scottish Government puts forward the concept of a shared currency and regulatory framework, which are exactly the sort of things that Standard Life has been calling for.
Given that statement about the importance of Scotland as
“a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world”,
can the chamber not unite in having confidence that an independent Scotland—indeed, Scotland under any constitutional framework—will be exactly that?
Only in Alex Salmond’s world is what Standard Life said today represented by what he has just said. A tried and tested path: denial, deception, delusion. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Ms Lamont, “deception” is not acceptable in the chamber.
It certainly is not. It is not acceptable in real life, either. Standard Life—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Ms Lamont, it is not acceptable in the chamber. Continue.
Standard Life employs 5,000 people in Scotland. It is worth nearly £250 billion and 90 per cent of its customers are in the rest of the United Kingdom. Now, Standard Life is actively making plans to leave Scotland if the First Minister gets his way. No amount of bluff, bluster and bullying from Alex Salmond can change that fact. Will the First Minister admit that, if Scotland leaves the United Kingdom, people’s jobs will leave Scotland?
Let me get this right for Johann Lamont: the bluff, bluster and bullying apply to George Osborne, who is the Tory chancellor that she is in alliance with; what Standard Life is saying is what I have read out.
Johann Lamont says that she does not believe what I say, but I was reading out exactly from the question-and-answer session at today’s AGM. Standard Life is pointing to the fact that it wants Scotland to be
“a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world”,
as it competes in 10 countries at the moment. We are putting forward the view that Scotland is going to be a good place from which to run business. We can do that because of the propositions that we make, which are that we will have a currency union and a secure regulatory environment. Above all, Standard Life depends on the skills and assets of its staff—they are what make and have made Standard Life a successful company.
The Scottish Government has put forward a viewpoint of what we believe to be in the best interests of Scotland—that is a logical and rational argument. Is Johann Lamont really making the case that Scotland is not going to be a good place to do business? That is what this hangs on. The evidence tells us—and it is substantial evidence—not only that it will be a good place to do business, but that an independent Scotland will be a more competitive place to do business.
Johann Lamont says that she does not believe what I say, but I was reading out exactly from the question-and-answer session at today’s AGM. Standard Life is pointing to the fact that it wants Scotland to be
“a good place from which to run our business and compete around the world”,
as it competes in 10 countries at the moment. We are putting forward the view that Scotland is going to be a good place from which to run business. We can do that because of the propositions that we make, which are that we will have a currency union and a secure regulatory environment. Above all, Standard Life depends on the skills and assets of its staff—they are what make and have made Standard Life a successful company.
The Scottish Government has put forward a viewpoint of what we believe to be in the best interests of Scotland—that is a logical and rational argument. Is Johann Lamont really making the case that Scotland is not going to be a good place to do business? That is what this hangs on. The evidence tells us—and it is substantial evidence—not only that it will be a good place to do business, but that an independent Scotland will be a more competitive place to do business.
It is precisely because Scotland is a good place to do business that we want it to stay strong in the United Kingdom and in the currency union that we have. The First Minister must explain why he wants to change something that works.
Of course, it is not just Standard Life that we are talking about. The Royal Bank of Scotland—the bank that the First Minister used to work for and the bank that he encouraged to do the deal that made it go bust—[Interruption.]
Of course, it is not just Standard Life that we are talking about. The Royal Bank of Scotland—the bank that the First Minister used to work for and the bank that he encouraged to do the deal that made it go bust—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
We have all seen the letter that the First Minister wrote to Fred Goodwin telling him to go ahead with the deal.
The Royal Bank of Scotland has said that uncertainty is damaging its fragile business. Standard Life is planning to leave Scotland, and RBS is shedding Scottish jobs. When the First Minister said that he “didn’t mind” Thatcher’s economics, he really was not kidding. Is it not the case that Alex Salmond’s plans would do more damage to Scotland than even Margaret Thatcher?
The Royal Bank of Scotland has said that uncertainty is damaging its fragile business. Standard Life is planning to leave Scotland, and RBS is shedding Scottish jobs. When the First Minister said that he “didn’t mind” Thatcher’s economics, he really was not kidding. Is it not the case that Alex Salmond’s plans would do more damage to Scotland than even Margaret Thatcher?
Only somebody who believes that Scotland is not “genetically programmed” to make political decisions could possibly come up with that concoction of nonsense. Let us take it apart piece by piece.
First, we have been here before: Standard Life has expressed concerns in the past. In 1992, the managing director of Standard Life wrote to every employee saying that any constitutional change would be damaging for the business and would cost jobs. However, by 1997, it had changed its mind as experience had shown that constitutional change could offer a secure business environment. Johann Lamont should remember that other people have been convinced by experience and evidence that Scotland is genetically programmed to make political decisions.
Johann Lamont mentioned other things. I point out that there has been a range of statements across the financial sector. Ross McEwan stated that the Royal Bank operates in 38 countries and that an independent Scotland would make it 39. Just a few days ago, the Barclays chief executive described independence as a matter for the Scottish people to decide. He said:
“we think we can make it work either way as a bank.”
Martin Gilbert, of Aberdeen Asset Management, said:
“If it did happen, it would be neutral for Scotland’s financial services industry.”
Major figures recognise that the operations of their business in an independent Scotland could be highly successful.
When we were faced with businesses who had concerns and doubts, the answer of those supporting constitutional change was to demonstrate by evidence and experience that Scotland would be more successful. That is what was done in the past; that is what will be done with the independence debate.
The onus is on Johann Lamont to say that she believes that Scotland is capable of making political decisions. If she does not believe that—she seemed to deny that in a debate earlier this week—the whole basis on which we have come so far with this Parliament is being denied. As we have demonstrated our ability to run so many of Scotland’s affairs—better than they have ever been run from Westminster—so, too, will we demonstrate our ability to run our economy and the other great issues for which an independent Scotland would be responsible.
First, we have been here before: Standard Life has expressed concerns in the past. In 1992, the managing director of Standard Life wrote to every employee saying that any constitutional change would be damaging for the business and would cost jobs. However, by 1997, it had changed its mind as experience had shown that constitutional change could offer a secure business environment. Johann Lamont should remember that other people have been convinced by experience and evidence that Scotland is genetically programmed to make political decisions.
Johann Lamont mentioned other things. I point out that there has been a range of statements across the financial sector. Ross McEwan stated that the Royal Bank operates in 38 countries and that an independent Scotland would make it 39. Just a few days ago, the Barclays chief executive described independence as a matter for the Scottish people to decide. He said:
“we think we can make it work either way as a bank.”
Martin Gilbert, of Aberdeen Asset Management, said:
“If it did happen, it would be neutral for Scotland’s financial services industry.”
Major figures recognise that the operations of their business in an independent Scotland could be highly successful.
When we were faced with businesses who had concerns and doubts, the answer of those supporting constitutional change was to demonstrate by evidence and experience that Scotland would be more successful. That is what was done in the past; that is what will be done with the independence debate.
The onus is on Johann Lamont to say that she believes that Scotland is capable of making political decisions. If she does not believe that—she seemed to deny that in a debate earlier this week—the whole basis on which we have come so far with this Parliament is being denied. As we have demonstrated our ability to run so many of Scotland’s affairs—better than they have ever been run from Westminster—so, too, will we demonstrate our ability to run our economy and the other great issues for which an independent Scotland would be responsible.
Yet more quotes from the First Minister—somebody must have been up all night googling “Alex Salmond is right.” I just hope that they were paid for that.
The issue is far too serious for the First Minister to debate by making cheap points, including on the significance of what Standard Life is saying. BP has warned that independence will damage Scotland; RBS is being damaged by the uncertainty that Alex Salmond is causing even now; Standard Life is planning to leave Scotland if there is a yes vote; and the workers on the Clyde are warning that there will be no shipbuilding after a yes vote.
The First Minister can selectively quote all that he likes. He can rewrite people’s words and try to mislead the people of Scotland all that he can. However, the reality is that more jobs would go than went at Ravenscraig, more jobs would go than at Bathgate, more jobs than at Linwood. If there is a yes vote, is it not the case that we will need to rewrite the song—[Interruption.] If there is a yes vote, is it not the case that we will need to rewrite the song: “Standard Life no more, RBS no more, shipbuilding no more, the Scotland we love and fight for no more”?
All that, for Alex Salmond, is a price worth paying. [Applause.]
The issue is far too serious for the First Minister to debate by making cheap points, including on the significance of what Standard Life is saying. BP has warned that independence will damage Scotland; RBS is being damaged by the uncertainty that Alex Salmond is causing even now; Standard Life is planning to leave Scotland if there is a yes vote; and the workers on the Clyde are warning that there will be no shipbuilding after a yes vote.
The First Minister can selectively quote all that he likes. He can rewrite people’s words and try to mislead the people of Scotland all that he can. However, the reality is that more jobs would go than went at Ravenscraig, more jobs would go than at Bathgate, more jobs than at Linwood. If there is a yes vote, is it not the case that we will need to rewrite the song—[Interruption.] If there is a yes vote, is it not the case that we will need to rewrite the song: “Standard Life no more, RBS no more, shipbuilding no more, the Scotland we love and fight for no more”?
All that, for Alex Salmond, is a price worth paying. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Does Johann Lamont not recall that what she has just quoted—Bathgate, Linwood, Lochaber no more—were put out by the no campaign in 1979, a campaign that she supported because she was against devolution? Scotland did not get a Parliament, and guess what happened? Bathgate, Linwood and Lochaber all closed.
Of course, if Johann Lamont had not supported the no campaign in 1979, she could have said that that was all Tory scaremongering, but now we are saying that it was not just Tory scaremongering, because Johann Lamont was a no voter in 1979. She agrees with the tactics that Scotland has grown out of over the past 20 years. We have seen through the scaremongering. If we had not seen through it, we would not now have this Parliament.
I say to Johann Lamont that Scotland will go on to prosperity and more equality through independence. It will not be “our business no more”; it will be “Labour no more”. [Applause.]
Of course, if Johann Lamont had not supported the no campaign in 1979, she could have said that that was all Tory scaremongering, but now we are saying that it was not just Tory scaremongering, because Johann Lamont was a no voter in 1979. She agrees with the tactics that Scotland has grown out of over the past 20 years. We have seen through the scaremongering. If we had not seen through it, we would not now have this Parliament.
I say to Johann Lamont that Scotland will go on to prosperity and more equality through independence. It will not be “our business no more”; it will be “Labour no more”. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
I call question 2—[Interruption.] Order.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 27 Feb 2014 →- Junior Doctors’ Hours Questions · 7
- New Psychoactive Substances Questions · 6
- Care Home Inspections (Standards) Questions · 5
- NHS Ayrshire and Arran (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Slipper Farming (Abolition) Questions · 4
- Bus Service Operators (Discussions) Questions · 4
- River Dredging (Powers) Questions · 4
- Scottish Housing Regulator (Discussions) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Welfare Reform (Food Banks) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Rape (Increase in Reported Incidents) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- National Health Service Settlement Agreements (Confidentiality Clauses) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Public Access Defibrillators First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Unite’s Back Home Safe Campaign Members’ business · 19
- Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 179
- Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.