1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01690)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
The record
10 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01690)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
This week, the Institute for Fiscal Studies, a respected independent think tank often quoted by the First Minister, said that because of falling North Sea oil revenues and an ageing population, an independent Scotland would face significant tax rises or public spending cuts.
I do not suppose that any of us here imagines that we are going to get an answer, but with a cock of the head and an indignant sideways look, could the First Minister tell us why the IFS is scaremongering like that?
I do not suppose that any of us here imagines that we are going to get an answer, but with a cock of the head and an indignant sideways look, could the First Minister tell us why the IFS is scaremongering like that?
We would do what the IFS report itself indicates: we would increase the Scottish tax base by growing the economy and generating extra revenue.
I do not know whether Johann Lamont is aware that the model that the IFS used, which is the Office for Budget Responsibility model, suggests that the United Kingdom will be in deficit for every one of the next 50 years—the next half century. It indicates that UK Governments will have to raise taxation or reduce expenditure to meet that sustained position. That is what the model tells us.
Instead of looking at that, we should be looking in Scotland at how we change the circumstances of this country by using investment to grow the economy, to generate more jobs and revenue and to give us a sustainable future.
I do not know whether Johann Lamont is aware that the model that the IFS used, which is the Office for Budget Responsibility model, suggests that the United Kingdom will be in deficit for every one of the next 50 years—the next half century. It indicates that UK Governments will have to raise taxation or reduce expenditure to meet that sustained position. That is what the model tells us.
Instead of looking at that, we should be looking in Scotland at how we change the circumstances of this country by using investment to grow the economy, to generate more jobs and revenue and to give us a sustainable future.
The IFS is just asking us to look at the real world. Why would we bother with all that malarkey when we can just make things up as we go along? How will we deal with an ageing population? Presumably we will all just get younger under independence. There will be £300,000-worth of Oil of Olay for each man, woman and child.
Of course, the IFS said that even in its most optimistic of forecasts, income tax would have to go up by 8p or VAT would have to rise to 27 per cent to fill the fiscal black hole.
Chuckling at his own jokes, as he likes to do, and selectively quoting lines that suit his argument—I am sure that he is looking for them right now—could the First Minister tell us why the people of Scotland should believe him rather than the evidence of their own eyes?
Of course, the IFS said that even in its most optimistic of forecasts, income tax would have to go up by 8p or VAT would have to rise to 27 per cent to fill the fiscal black hole.
Chuckling at his own jokes, as he likes to do, and selectively quoting lines that suit his argument—I am sure that he is looking for them right now—could the First Minister tell us why the people of Scotland should believe him rather than the evidence of their own eyes?
Let us talk about what is agreed in the IFS report. Page 9 confirms that Scotland pays more tax per head than the UK at the moment. Page 11 confirms that Scotland is in a stronger fiscal position than the rest of the UK.
To quote exactly, the report says:
“the average revenues raised per person in Scotland (£11,079 in 2013–14 prices) were higher than for the UK as a whole (£9,342 ... )”.
The IFS has validated an argument that I have brought to the chamber many times, from the “Government Expenditure and Revenue in Scotland”—GERS—forecast, that Scotland more than pays its way in the UK. In the past five years, that has amounted to many billions of pounds that could have been invested in Scottish public services, used to lower the rate of borrowing, or used to do a combination of both. However, because of our position with the UK, those resources have not been available to the people of Scotland.
Our case is a simple one: instead of not having those resources available, why not invest in the economy? Why not grow productivity—grow our exports—and ensure that we have growth in the economy, which generates more revenue, so that we do not have the dreadful future that has been forecast for the UK by the IFS, which says that it will be in deficit for the next 50 years?
Johann Lamont talks about changing the age structure of the country in an independent Scotland. How would we do that? Perhaps we could do it by allowing young Scots who want to work in this country the opportunity to stay here—or perhaps we could do it by not kicking out, as the Border Agency does, the many skilled young people who come to study at our universities and desperately want to work either for a time or permanently in Scotland. Would that not help to change the population’s age structure? Of course these things must be right because they are controlled from London and Johann Lamont backs control from London of the immigration policy that would consign us to that prospect.
The IFS’s central forecast, which has been taken from the Office of National Statistics, postulates 4 per cent population growth in Scotland over the next 50 years. The population of Scotland has grown by 5 per cent over the past 10 years but, as the IFS tells us, if we remain trapped in the policies that are governed from Westminster, Scotland faces a very poor prospect indeed. If we grow the economy and put the investment in, we have a bright and certain future.
To quote exactly, the report says:
“the average revenues raised per person in Scotland (£11,079 in 2013–14 prices) were higher than for the UK as a whole (£9,342 ... )”.
The IFS has validated an argument that I have brought to the chamber many times, from the “Government Expenditure and Revenue in Scotland”—GERS—forecast, that Scotland more than pays its way in the UK. In the past five years, that has amounted to many billions of pounds that could have been invested in Scottish public services, used to lower the rate of borrowing, or used to do a combination of both. However, because of our position with the UK, those resources have not been available to the people of Scotland.
Our case is a simple one: instead of not having those resources available, why not invest in the economy? Why not grow productivity—grow our exports—and ensure that we have growth in the economy, which generates more revenue, so that we do not have the dreadful future that has been forecast for the UK by the IFS, which says that it will be in deficit for the next 50 years?
Johann Lamont talks about changing the age structure of the country in an independent Scotland. How would we do that? Perhaps we could do it by allowing young Scots who want to work in this country the opportunity to stay here—or perhaps we could do it by not kicking out, as the Border Agency does, the many skilled young people who come to study at our universities and desperately want to work either for a time or permanently in Scotland. Would that not help to change the population’s age structure? Of course these things must be right because they are controlled from London and Johann Lamont backs control from London of the immigration policy that would consign us to that prospect.
The IFS’s central forecast, which has been taken from the Office of National Statistics, postulates 4 per cent population growth in Scotland over the next 50 years. The population of Scotland has grown by 5 per cent over the past 10 years but, as the IFS tells us, if we remain trapped in the policies that are governed from Westminster, Scotland faces a very poor prospect indeed. If we grow the economy and put the investment in, we have a bright and certain future.
Another of the First Minister’s tricks is to go on and on answering a question that he was not asked. When the IFS says that in its most optimistic forecast income tax would have to go up by 8p or VAT rise to 27 per cent to fill the fiscal black hole, only the First Minister could say that the IFS validates his position. It does not.
Indeed, I would not be surprised if convicted Enron executives across the United States were, at the moment, planning their appeals, saying, “I know we fiddled the figures, but Alex Salmond has taken it to a whole new level.” With every economic paper the First Minister publishes, Fred Goodwin must feel a day closer to redemption; each prospectus must make Bernie Madoff spit out his breakfast in admiration.
Feeling free to quote a former Labour chancellor in a falsetto voice, to dig up a blog that he was trawling through last night or to give us some more selective quotes like the last few we just got, can the First Minister explain to us why the fiscal black hole exposed by the IFS does not actually exist and why there is nothing to worry about after all?
Indeed, I would not be surprised if convicted Enron executives across the United States were, at the moment, planning their appeals, saying, “I know we fiddled the figures, but Alex Salmond has taken it to a whole new level.” With every economic paper the First Minister publishes, Fred Goodwin must feel a day closer to redemption; each prospectus must make Bernie Madoff spit out his breakfast in admiration.
Feeling free to quote a former Labour chancellor in a falsetto voice, to dig up a blog that he was trawling through last night or to give us some more selective quotes like the last few we just got, can the First Minister explain to us why the fiscal black hole exposed by the IFS does not actually exist and why there is nothing to worry about after all?
I point out to Johann Lamont that I quoted from the IFS because I think it very useful in agreeing the current position. The IFS backs the Scottish Government GERS figures in showing that Scotland more than pays its way in the United Kingdom—[Interruption.] I hear from the Tory benches that that it is not true. I have already given one quote; page 11 of the report points out that
“Scotland exceeded revenues by £1,550 per person”.
Given that direct quote from the IFS, let us agree that over the five-year period Scotland has more than paid its way within the UK.
I have pointed out to Johann Lamont that I do not think that the population structure of this country is a given; I think that it would be enormously improved if we did not refuse young Scots an opportunity to work in their own country and if we allowed other skilled people, many of whom we have educated, to work in Scotland. That, to me, would bring about a substantial and important change with regard to the sorts of challenges that the IFS has indicated and which face all European economies.
I have substantial admiration for the IFS, unlike Westminster politicians, including Alistair Darling, who have dismissed its various reports. Indeed, I see that the Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has
“taken the highly unusual step of attacking the ... Institute for Fiscal Studies, describing its methods of measuring the fairness of the coalition's controversial spending review as ‘distorted and a complete nonsense’.”
That is exactly why I have pointed out that on the basis of the IFS report we can now be reasonably certain that the arguments that we have been putting forward about Scotland being in a stronger fiscal position than the rest of the UK have been validated with regard to the past five years.
What happens over the next 50 years will depend on the policies that are pursued in this country, which, in turn, will depend on whether we have control of the policies that are pursued in this country. I say that we should get control of the economic levers, increase productivity, increase our exports and invest in our economy. Let us grow the Scottish economy and move forward to that better future.
“Scotland exceeded revenues by £1,550 per person”.
Given that direct quote from the IFS, let us agree that over the five-year period Scotland has more than paid its way within the UK.
I have pointed out to Johann Lamont that I do not think that the population structure of this country is a given; I think that it would be enormously improved if we did not refuse young Scots an opportunity to work in their own country and if we allowed other skilled people, many of whom we have educated, to work in Scotland. That, to me, would bring about a substantial and important change with regard to the sorts of challenges that the IFS has indicated and which face all European economies.
I have substantial admiration for the IFS, unlike Westminster politicians, including Alistair Darling, who have dismissed its various reports. Indeed, I see that the Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has
“taken the highly unusual step of attacking the ... Institute for Fiscal Studies, describing its methods of measuring the fairness of the coalition's controversial spending review as ‘distorted and a complete nonsense’.”
That is exactly why I have pointed out that on the basis of the IFS report we can now be reasonably certain that the arguments that we have been putting forward about Scotland being in a stronger fiscal position than the rest of the UK have been validated with regard to the past five years.
What happens over the next 50 years will depend on the policies that are pursued in this country, which, in turn, will depend on whether we have control of the policies that are pursued in this country. I say that we should get control of the economic levers, increase productivity, increase our exports and invest in our economy. Let us grow the Scottish economy and move forward to that better future.
The First Minister is guilty not just of selective quoting, but of selective thinking. The First Minister says that the IFS is helpful, but only to the extent that it agrees with him. We know that SNP back benchers are helpful to the First Minister only when they agree with him, but he ought to look at the whole of the IFS study and take it on board.
Just like at the start of his campaign, the First Minister is going to the cinema on Tuesday. What is he going to see—“Historic Day V” or “Honey I Shrunk the Fiscal Gap”? If the First Minister is to be believed, we will not just be a new country after independence, but he will invent a new arithmetic. While the choice in every other country in the world is between tax rises and cuts in spending, Alex Salmond will have us believe that we are the only country in which the future is this: how big a tax cut can we give to big business and how much more can we spend on good things? Is it not the case that at the very heart of next week’s white paper and at the heart of everything that the Government does is the belief that if the First Minister and his colleagues say something confidently and often enough, no matter how wrong it is, the people of Scotland will be daft enough to believe it?
Just like at the start of his campaign, the First Minister is going to the cinema on Tuesday. What is he going to see—“Historic Day V” or “Honey I Shrunk the Fiscal Gap”? If the First Minister is to be believed, we will not just be a new country after independence, but he will invent a new arithmetic. While the choice in every other country in the world is between tax rises and cuts in spending, Alex Salmond will have us believe that we are the only country in which the future is this: how big a tax cut can we give to big business and how much more can we spend on good things? Is it not the case that at the very heart of next week’s white paper and at the heart of everything that the Government does is the belief that if the First Minister and his colleagues say something confidently and often enough, no matter how wrong it is, the people of Scotland will be daft enough to believe it?
Let me try another quote from the IFS. Johann Lamont will say that I am being selective, but I think that it underlines the points that I have been making. The IFS acknowledges that
“These factors”—
in the report—
“are inherently uncertain and could also evolve differently if Scotland were independent rather than part of the UK; in addition, they could be substantially affected by the policies chosen by the government of an independent Scotland.”
That is basically what I am saying.
Johann Lamont says that the choice is between cutting spending and increasing taxation. That would be the Labour Party’s position, with, according to the IFS/Office for Budget Responsibility analysis, a deficit in every single one of the next 50 years. We now know exactly what, if Johann Lamont has any influence, the policy of the next Labour Government would be on that issue.
I do not think that Johann Lamont is in a particularly good position to talk about either economic advisers or the real world. Fred Goodwin was the economic adviser to Alistair Darling, not to me, and the current economic adviser to the Labour Party is the Rev Paul Flowers. I do not think that that gives us a tremendous indication of what the future should hold.
In addition, in the real world at present, Labour figure after Labour figure is saying exactly what they think of the Labour Party’s current coalition with the Tories. For example, according to the Scottish Labour Party chairperson, Labour activists “simply cannot stomach” working alongside the Conservatives in the no campaign. In the real world, key Labour figures such as Alex Mosson are coming out in favour of the yes campaign. That is what is happening in the real world.
As the white paper is launched next week, the yes campaign will be reinforced. Why? Because this party and this Government have ambition for this country. We think that we can invest in the future, grow our economy and give all our people a decent future.
“These factors”—
in the report—
“are inherently uncertain and could also evolve differently if Scotland were independent rather than part of the UK; in addition, they could be substantially affected by the policies chosen by the government of an independent Scotland.”
That is basically what I am saying.
Johann Lamont says that the choice is between cutting spending and increasing taxation. That would be the Labour Party’s position, with, according to the IFS/Office for Budget Responsibility analysis, a deficit in every single one of the next 50 years. We now know exactly what, if Johann Lamont has any influence, the policy of the next Labour Government would be on that issue.
I do not think that Johann Lamont is in a particularly good position to talk about either economic advisers or the real world. Fred Goodwin was the economic adviser to Alistair Darling, not to me, and the current economic adviser to the Labour Party is the Rev Paul Flowers. I do not think that that gives us a tremendous indication of what the future should hold.
In addition, in the real world at present, Labour figure after Labour figure is saying exactly what they think of the Labour Party’s current coalition with the Tories. For example, according to the Scottish Labour Party chairperson, Labour activists “simply cannot stomach” working alongside the Conservatives in the no campaign. In the real world, key Labour figures such as Alex Mosson are coming out in favour of the yes campaign. That is what is happening in the real world.
As the white paper is launched next week, the yes campaign will be reinforced. Why? Because this party and this Government have ambition for this country. We think that we can invest in the future, grow our economy and give all our people a decent future.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 21 Nov 2013 →- Aberdeen City Council (Transport) Questions · 6
- Environmental Noise Questions · 4
- Minister for Town Centres Questions · 8
- Superfast Broadband Questions · 4
- NHS Grampian (Primary Medical Facilities) Questions · 4
- Children’s Dental Health Questions · 4
- Abu Dhabi International Petroleum Exhibition and Conference Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Fiscal Sustainability (Independent Scotland) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Wilful Neglect of Patients First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Police Scotland (Statistics) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- John F Kennedy Assassination (50th Anniversary) Members’ business · 20
- College Courses (Gamekeeping and Countryside Management) Questions · 4
- Education (Health Promotion) Questions · 7
- National Exams Questions · 8
- Edinburgh College (Meetings) Questions · 5
- National 5 and Higher Mathematics Unit Assessments Questions · 6
- Creationism Questions · 4
- Colleges (Regionalisation) Questions · 6
- Disabled Students Allowance 2012-13 Questions · 6
- PPP/PFI School Contracts 2012-13 Questions · 4
- Scottish Qualifications Authority (National Exams) Questions · 4
- Student Numbers Questions · 4
- Highlands and Islands (Education and Skills Provision) Questions · 4
- Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce Questions · 6
- Disabled Students Questions · 4
- Dyslexia Questions · 6
- Commission for Developing Scotland’s Young Workforce Questions · 4
- Academic Freedom Questions · 7
- Burrell Collection (Lending and Borrowing) (Scotland) Bill: Preliminary Stage Bill debate · 11
- Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 71
- Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.